Location: Middle Island
Top Restaurants in Middle Island
Top Things to do in Middle Island
- 1. Fire Island National Seashore
- 2. Country Fair Entertainment Park
- 3. Bridgeport and Port Jefferson Steamboat Company
- 4. Holtsville Ecology Site
- 5. Long Island Private Wine Tours
- 6. The Pennysaver Amphitheater
- 7. Calverton National Cemetery
- 8. Regal Cinemas Ronkonkoma Stadium 9 Movie Theater
- 9. Cedar Beach
- 10. Massage Envy Spa
Where to eat Pizza food in Middle Island: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Find out what Pizza restaurants to try in Middle Island. Middle Island is a hamlet and census-designated place (CDP) in Suffolk County, New York, United States. The population was 10,483 at the 2010 census. It is situated between the hamlets of Coram and Ridge, to the west and east, respectively, and Rocky Point and Yaphank to the north and south. The name derives from the fact that it lies approximately halfway between the eastern and western ends of Long Island (Montauk Point and the East River) as well as halfway between the northern and southern boundaries (the Long Island Sound and the Atlantic Ocean).
Things to do in Middle Island
10. Cafe Gia Pizza & Pasta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 81 reviews
Reviewed By OzzysAngel
This is my 2nd review of Gia's, the 1st written a few years ago. The reason for an updated review is my disappointment in all my visits since. Note: this is for the pizza side only. Saturday afternoon, 4pm. I was a few miles away and my daughter wanted pizza. Upon entering, the counter was pretty bare, and anything resembling pizza was burnt looking and old. It's nice to see the same miserable faces behind the counter. They don't smile or pay attention to you for longer than the few seconds it takes to take your order. They put the pizza in the oven and move on to the next person. Every. Single. Time. I have to ask them to take my food out. If I don't, it gets overcooked, crust burnt. They never give a receipt nor are there signs anywhere telling you how much anything is. Chicken bacon ranch slice? I think he called it? Old, hard chicken, cheddar cheese? And no ranch anywhere. Threw most of it out. The pepperoni pinwheel is always good. And the regular slice was ok. There were no knives or napkins in the dispensers. The garbage was full. The tables and floors were absolutely disgusting. I just stood there waiting for the young girl at the door to stop looking at us and get someone to wipe down a table. She finally looked annoyed enough and did it herself. I wish I could say that it was a one time deal, but the past few times we drove out of our way, it's just been bad. I'm disappointed. I used to love going here. What happened Gia's?
9. Matt's Pizza
Reviewed By RachelDT29
The pizza is good, not to die for but very good. I love their burgers also - but call ahead it will take 10 or 15 minutes. Its a quick easy meal to pick up, and they also deliver. The Wings are also pretty good.The Prices are great also.
8. Colosseo
Overall Ratings
4 based on 142 reviews
Reviewed By natashat996
âDOMINATING THE PIZZA/ITALIAN EATS WORLD.....IN EXCELLENCEâ.....If you want a.....âA LITTLE TASTE OF ITALYâ in Port Jefferson Station this is the ITALIANO spot to be at....This stop in was for pizza pick order for work....Makayla & Stephanie were friendly & on point....Success...in the bellies of co-workers breaking bread together.... â¨Long standing Primo Perfecto Business....If you havenât been itâs a highly suggested try....â¨
7. Carlo's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By AlyssaAdventures
Absolutely love this pizzeria. Food is always piping hot and pizza is always perfect. We call in advance to pick up and it can sometimes be 30-45 minute wait but it's always worth it.
6. Pompei Pizza & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 37 reviews
Reviewed By alysong57
I love a good corner round table to tick the kids in the back out of the wait staffs way and still leaves them room to play and be kids. Too that with some good food and we make this a regular visit.
5. Medford Pastaria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 114 reviews
Reviewed By HannahLee123
Excellent eggplant anything (parmigiana and rollatini). Nice restaurant ambiance and service for local casual dining in strip mall.
4. Bella Roma
Overall Ratings
4 based on 33 reviews
Reviewed By Barbara P
Food is excellent, restaurant nice, take out available, generally 45 minute wait for delivery, food is hot though. Great bargain is the shrimp with scampi sauce over angel hair. Huge portion! Garlic knots are very good, zeppoles are also a good deal. Pizza is fair, had better but the main menu items are all good.
3. Alfredo's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 28 reviews
Reviewed By johnkL3739AE
So went in for a bite on Sunday evening. The girls working the front said we could sit anywhere; OK, all the tables were dirty, so we sat at the table she was using to drop her serving tray. So to rephrase, 8 tables 7 dirty, one had a serving tray sitting on it. The two young girls were sweet and friendly, maybe there first job. They need to be taught how to be a server.Its not like they were busy, you clear, set and serve then repeat. Another couple came in after us, had to be in there 80's they sat down and said "the table is dirty" again after the girls said sit anywhere you want. They don't know.I order the Pasta Alfredo, specifically fettuccine, Alfredo. and a dish on the menu called Chicken Vendura Balsamic grilled chicken with spinach, broccoli and mushrooms. The young lady came back and asked me if I ordered fettuccine pasta. My wife was brought a dish of Chicken fried in egg batter topped with broccoli. She didn't want to change the dish, but when the girl came over she made mention of it. I had looked at the menu and did not see the dish she brought us was not listed. I pointed that out to the server. So to reiterate, the dish she brought us was not on the menu, how could we have ordered it.The food was good the servers need work.
2. Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Reviewed By L T
This is a pizzeria with an Italian food menu. Seating is in booths with plastic seats and tables. In other words, a standard pizzeria setup. Counter service was great, friendly, professional. They do deliver the pizza to your table but you order at the counter. Pizza was very good. They also have many specialty pizzas and wraps. Would definitely recommend trying Capio's. Gave it 4 stars due to 'ambiance' factor - it is a place to eat pizza and good Italian dishes. Not a stylish decor.
Top 10 American food in Middle Island, New York, United States
1. Middle Island Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 24 reviews
Reviewed By kevinmannmail
middle island pizza is not flashy or extraordinary.it delivers consistent pizza parlor cuisine.the dining room in the back is a bit dated as is the restaurant itself.this is not the place for a romantic encounter.MIP does host weekly Rotary club meetings and serves as a civic hub in some ways.
Most Popular Italian food in Middle Island, New York, United States
