Most Popular Italian food in Middle Island, New York, United States

February 10, 2020 Janean Rudisill

Best Italian restaurants nearby. Discover the best Italian food in Middle Island. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Italian restaurants near you.. Middle Island is a hamlet and census-designated place (CDP) in Suffolk County, New York, United States. The population was 10,483 at the 2010 census. It is situated between the hamlets of Coram and Ridge, to the west and east, respectively, and Rocky Point and Yaphank to the north and south. The name derives from the fact that it lies approximately halfway between the eastern and western ends of Long Island (Montauk Point and the East River) as well as halfway between the northern and southern boundaries (the Long Island Sound and the Atlantic Ocean).
Things to do in Middle Island

10. Colosseo

1049 Route 112, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776-6000 Italian, Pizza Lunch, Dinner, Late Night Takeout, Seating, Wheelchair Accessible, Table Service +1 631-928-4972 http://colosseopizzaandrestaurantportjeffersonstation.dishdesigner.website
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere
Overall Ratings

4 based on 142 reviews

Colosseo

Reviewed By natashat996

✍DOMINATING THE PIZZA/ITALIAN EATS WORLD.....IN EXCELLENCE”.....If you want a.....“A LITTLE TASTE OF ITALY” in Port Jefferson Station this is the ITALIANO spot to be at....This stop in was for pizza pick order for work....Makayla & Stephanie were friendly & on point....Success...in the bellies of co-workers breaking bread together.... ✨Long standing Primo Perfecto Business....If you haven’t been it’s a highly suggested try....✨

9. Carlo's Pizza

451 Glen Dr Ste A, Shirley, NY 11967-1100 Italian, Pizza Lunch, Dinner Takeout, Wheelchair Accessible, Seating, Table Service +1 631-924-8760 http://www.carlospizzeria.com
Food
Service
Value
Overall Ratings

4 based on 21 reviews

Reviewed By AlyssaAdventures

Absolutely love this pizzeria. Food is always piping hot and pizza is always perfect. We call in advance to pick up and it can sometimes be 30-45 minute wait but it's always worth it.

8. Pompei Pizza & Restaurant

346-64 Route 25A Ste 64, Rocky Point, NY 11778-8425 Italian, Pizza Lunch, Dinner Takeout, Seating, Wheelchair Accessible [email protected] +1 631-744-0140 http://Pompeipizzarestaurant.com
Food
Service
Value
Overall Ratings

4 based on 37 reviews

Pompei Pizza & Restaurant

Reviewed By alysong57

I love a good corner round table to tick the kids in the back out of the wait staffs way and still leaves them room to play and be kids. Too that with some good food and we make this a regular visit.

7. Medford Pastaria

3209 Horseblock Rd, Medford, NY 11763-2545 Italian, Pizza Lunch, Dinner Delivery, Takeout, Reservations, Seating, Parking Available, Highchairs Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Table Service +1 631-758-5252 http://www.medfordpastaria.com
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere
Overall Ratings

4 based on 114 reviews

Medford Pastaria

Reviewed By HannahLee123

Excellent eggplant anything (parmigiana and rollatini). Nice restaurant ambiance and service for local casual dining in strip mall.

6. Orto

90 N Country Rd, Miller Place, NY 11764-1409 Italian Dinner Reservations, Seating, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Table Service, BYOB +1 631-473-0014 http://restaurantorto.com
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere
Overall Ratings

4 based on 148 reviews

Reviewed By Ktw141

The food and the service here is above and beyond amazing. Anything I have ever had here has been cooked perfectly. We come when they participate in resturant week every few months and get something different each time. They never cease to impress us. Highly recommend giving it a tey if you're in the neighborhood!!

5. Bella Roma

264 Middle Country Rd, Coram, NY 11727 Italian, Pizza Lunch, Dinner Delivery, Takeout, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Seating, Table Service +1 631-732-3000 https://www.facebook.com/BellaRomaRestaurantPizzeria/
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere
Overall Ratings

4 based on 33 reviews

Bella Roma

Reviewed By Barbara P

Food is excellent, restaurant nice, take out available, generally 45 minute wait for delivery, food is hot though. Great bargain is the shrimp with scampi sauce over angel hair. Huge portion! Garlic knots are very good, zeppoles are also a good deal. Pizza is fair, had better but the main menu items are all good.

4. Alfredo's Pizza

1679 Middle Country Rd, Ridge, NY 11961-2403 Italian, Pizza Lunch, Dinner Takeout, Seating, Wheelchair Accessible, Delivery +1 631-924-7713 http://www.5brotherspizzeria.com
Food
Service
Value
Overall Ratings

4 based on 28 reviews

Alfredo's Pizza

Reviewed By johnkL3739AE

So went in for a bite on Sunday evening. The girls working the front said we could sit anywhere; OK, all the tables were dirty, so we sat at the table she was using to drop her serving tray. So to rephrase, 8 tables 7 dirty, one had a serving tray sitting on it. The two young girls were sweet and friendly, maybe there first job. They need to be taught how to be a server.Its not like they were busy, you clear, set and serve then repeat. Another couple came in after us, had to be in there 80's they sat down and said "the table is dirty" again after the girls said sit anywhere you want. They don't know.I order the Pasta Alfredo, specifically fettuccine, Alfredo. and a dish on the menu called Chicken Vendura Balsamic grilled chicken with spinach, broccoli and mushrooms. The young lady came back and asked me if I ordered fettuccine pasta. My wife was brought a dish of Chicken fried in egg batter topped with broccoli. She didn't want to change the dish, but when the girl came over she made mention of it. I had looked at the menu and did not see the dish she brought us was not listed. I pointed that out to the server. So to reiterate, the dish she brought us was not on the menu, how could we have ordered it.The food was good the servers need work.

The 10 Best Things to Do in Middle Island, United States

3. Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant

1259 Middle Country Rd., Middle Island, NY 11953 Italian, Pizza Lunch, Dinner [email protected] +1 631-345-5454 http://capiospizza.com

Reviewed By L T

This is a pizzeria with an Italian food menu. Seating is in booths with plastic seats and tables. In other words, a standard pizzeria setup. Counter service was great, friendly, professional. They do deliver the pizza to your table but you order at the counter. Pizza was very good. They also have many specialty pizzas and wraps. Would definitely recommend trying Capio's. Gave it 4 stars due to 'ambiance' factor - it is a place to eat pizza and good Italian dishes. Not a stylish decor.

Most Popular Restaurants in Middle Island

2. Lombardi's Italian Restaurant

175 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953-2503 Italian Lunch Reservations, Seating, Serves Alcohol, Takeout, Table Service +1 631-924-8933 http://lombardisitalianrestrntsuffolkny.com
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere
Overall Ratings

3 based on 70 reviews

Lombardi's Italian Restaurant

Reviewed By wbogardus

I stopped to fulfill my craving for spaghetti with meat sauce and must say that I got a wonderfully prepared dish in traditional Italian prepared style that fit the bill with enough left over for an encore presentation tomorrow. The bill was a bit steep but not so much that it wasn’t out of line. After all the service and atmosphere were good; a place for family and friends.

Best Diner food near Middle Island, New York, United States

1. Middle Island Pizza

586 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953-2543 Italian, Pizza Lunch, Dinner Delivery, Takeout, Wheelchair Accessible +1 631-924-0091 http://www.middleislandpizzeria.com/
Food
Service
Value
Overall Ratings

4 based on 24 reviews

Middle Island Pizza

Reviewed By kevinmannmail

middle island pizza is not flashy or extraordinary.it delivers consistent pizza parlor cuisine.the dining room in the back is a bit dated as is the restaurant itself.this is not the place for a romantic encounter.MIP does host weekly Rotary club meetings and serves as a civic hub in some ways.

Top 10 American food in Middle Island, New York, United States

TAGS

ThingsTodoPost © 2018 All rights reserved.