Location: New Albany
Top Restaurants in New Albany
Top Things to do in New Albany
Countries
Where to eat Italian food in New Albany: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Reviews on Italian food in New Albany, Ohio, United States. New Albany is a city in the U.S. state of Ohio, just northeast of the state capital of Columbus. Most of the city is located in Franklin County and a small portion extends into adjacent Licking County. The population was 7,724 at the 2010 census. Founded in 1837, it is now a growing suburb in the Columbus area. New Albany is a very wealthy community, with a per capita income that ranks 12th out of 1,065 places in the state of Ohio. The mayor of New Albany is Democrat Sloan Spalding who was elected in 2015.
Things to do in New Albany
9. Piada Italian Street Food
Overall Ratings
4 based on 117 reviews
Reviewed By Michael M
Was brought to piada by my friend who is a local to Columbus. At first was very unsure because I am not huge on eating different items I am grilled chicken or hamburger guy. However piada made me a customer steak and pasta bowl and it was amazing!
8. Ange's Pizza
Reviewed By Radjeff
This is by far our favorite pizza when we are looking for something that's Columbus style thin and crispy. Good value friendly staff always very consistent. Don't miss a cold beer at cornerstone pub next-door and they serve Ange's pizza there.
7. BRIO Tuscan Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 415 reviews
Choose from our genuine Italian recipes, served by the best chefs at BRIO Tuscan Grille Easton Town Center. Enjoy the pleasure of metropolitan Northern Italian cuisine in our Italian restaurant. Be sure to try our patio dining to enhance your experience.
Reviewed By Docsmartie
Second visit to this outpost of Brio. Overall very good experience. We just stopped for appetizers. Theyâre flat breads are crackers thin crust with nice toppings but not really Napoleon style pizza. The carpaccio presentation was amazing !! it was a huge platter of perfectly sliced delicious tender beef with arugula salad olive oil and capers. Need a little salt but otherwise perfect. Calamari was delicious. Cocktails were very good. Atmosphere is lively they also have outdoor seating. Weâve had dinner items On previous visits and the food is always hot and delicious. Iâm nice option for families friends or relaxed romantic dinner
6. Bellacino's
Reviewed By ThreeWiseMen1998
Food is great, prices are normal, & you don't have to fight for a seat. They deliver, but eating is nice too.They have good daily specials and kids meals. My 7 & 8 year old love going their.
5. Olive Garden
Overall Ratings
4 based on 34 reviews
Reviewed By mckenzim1322
Our party of 20 was quickly seated and we had 2 waiters which was great. Food was good, they had gluten free options, which was surprising. It was nice to be able to come with a large party, be seated in a room pretty much by ourselves so the family could talk. Good overall experience.
4. Lola & Giuseppe's Trattoria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 286 reviews
We will be closed from Saturday 6/29 through Saturday 7/6 for our annual vacation. Normal hours will resume on Tuesday 7/9.
Reviewed By 721nesss
An unassuming little Italian restaurant with really friendly owners and servers. The restaurant itself is in a strip mall in Gahanna. The ambience inside is made to give you the feel of a simple Trattoria â relaxed and homey. They have a small wine list but I had no. Complaints with my Chianti. For appetizers, we shared the bruschetta. It was good, but I didnât like the fact that the bread was cold and not toasted. For dinner my son and I shared two dishes: he got the spaghetti meatballs and I got the shrimp and lobster special in creamy sauce. I liked both the dishes. The meatballs were nice, large, and juicy, and the spaghetti was cooked just right. The special was filled with a generous portion of shrimps and some lobster. It was delicious but after a while the heaviness of the creamy sauce hit you (so I was happy to have shared the dish :)). My wife got the baked ziti. A very large and heavy dish but flavorful.For dessert, we shared their bread pudding with whiskey sauce and their cheesecake special. I didnât get to trying the cheesecake but the bread pudding was moist and excellent. Itâs a pity that the restaurant is a good 30 mins drive from where we live, but we plan to return. Such a warm and wonderful owner and server. It made for a delightful evening.
3. Zero's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 17 reviews
Reviewed By MrEdnWilbur
I wanted something quick and so ordered the chicken sub and the cheese sticks to go. Both were good and tasty. Since they do have a small lobby and parking out front is limited, choosing delivery is probably the best option.
2. FireFly American Bistro
Overall Ratings
3 based on 55 reviews
Reviewed By disgusted012
Last visit gave them a pretty bad rating. This tie the service and food was outstanding. I guess no matter what establishment you visit you can have either a good or bad experience. This time the service was outstanding. Food was prepared as ordered and well presented. Worth a visit.
1. Eagles Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 104 reviews
New Albanyâs Pizza at its Best! Dine In or Carry Out Located in the heart of New Albany, Ohio, our restaurant offers a great variety of pizza, subs, sandwiches, dinners, salads and desserts in a friendly, casual atmosphere. Grab some great food to go or d
Reviewed By Wesley L
This pizzeria, along with its sister "Johnnies' Villa Pizza in Johnstown, have been local favorites for years. I'm not altogether sure why that is. The pizza is rather mundane in my honest opinion. The pepperoni is much too salty and the sausage has waaaaaaaaay too much fennel for my personal taste. The few times I've been in, the service has been rather poor. Regretfully, there aren't to many other options in New Albany.
