Location: Bay Shore
Top Restaurants in Bay Shore
Top 10 Italian food in Bay Shore, New York, United States
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Bay Shore. Bay Shore is a hamlet and census-designated place (CDP) in the Town of Islip, Suffolk County, New York, United States. It is situated on the South Shore of Long Island, adjoining the Great South Bay. In 2008, Bay Shore celebrated the 300th anniversary of the purchase of the land from the Secatogue Native Americans. The population of the CDP was 26,337 at the time of the 2010 census.
Things to do in Bay Shore
10. Giordano's Pizzeria
Reviewed By Dianne J
A hidden gem. Great attentive service and the eggplant parmesan was very good. Thinnly sliced and not overcooked with what I think was a homemade sauce.
9. Mamma Santina Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 26 reviews
Reviewed By LongIslandMabel
With friendly service and wonderful pizza, Mamma Santina's can't be beat for help with supper plans! My husband and I enjoy a big chopped tomato and chopped onion pizza that lasts for more than one meal at least every couple of weeks and can highly recommend this local pizzeria. They also cook up great Italian meals liked Baked Ziti in addition to their pizzas.
8. Joe's Pasta & Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By golf472
Located in a strip mall off 5th Avenue, this pizza place offers very good sit down meals that are reasonably priced. Their pizza is outstanding and they offer all types and the typical garlic knots, calzones, etc. All of which are better than all of their competitors. Their sit down restaurant is separated by a glass wall and is elevated by one step up from the pizza section. Service is very good and the staff has been there for years. Entrees run on average $17,00 and are sizable. Wine glasses could be bigger. This place is a step above the usual, Pizza/restaruant. Very clean and they take reservations. Lots of locals do take out.
7. Slice of Bay Shore
Reviewed By LongIslandMabel
The old Friendly's building has been totally reimagined into a delightful new Italian restaurant. I went for lunch recently and was charmed by the décor, Debbie the waitress and my delicious and abundant food. I had Pasta Fagioli with a Greek Wrap on the lunch special "pick 2." The soup was so delicious and filling that I took the whole huge wrap home and shared it with my husband for supper! Can't wait to return to try every pizza and pasta dish on the menu--guess that will take countless visits! There is an area in the front for sitting down for a quick slice, another small bar area and then a bigger dining room area for table service. Even the bathrooms have been lovingly decorated!
6. Buseto Pizza
Reviewed By Kenneth C
This authentic Italian restaurant has an outstanding menu,not gourmet food that you have never heard of,but traditional Italian selections like Grandma used to make ! From appetizers to desserts ,pizza ,calzone, Busetos is above the rest . reasonably priced,attentive servers,and delicious food in generous portions...you never leave hungry!!
5. Mulberry Street Bay Shore
Overall Ratings
4 based on 26 reviews
Established in 1976, Mulberry Street Restaurant has been setting the standard for Italian cuisine and pizza in the Bay Shore community for years. Whether you choose to dine in our private cozy dining room, or take your food to go, you can be assured of a
Reviewed By kbockl
Giant portions of traditional red sauce Italian food are served in the pleasant dining room next to the pizzeria. My husband eats nothing but veal parmigiana. My favorite is pasta Charlie. The pizza is excellent. I skip the wine. It's just not the best. But that's my only complaint.
4. Fratelli Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
Reviewed By Kieran S
The snap of a crisp Crisp Crust, Flavorful Sauce, Perfect ratio of cheese. This is what NY pizza is all about.I have been going to Fratelli for years, and still can't figure out how they are not on ever top pizza list around.It is getting harder and harder to find pizza this good in NY. I am partial to a Meatball Pie or slice, the house made meatballs are outstanding.My wife will get a slice of each, regular pizza, and a slice of Sicislian which is equally as delicious.If you are a pizza lover you owe it too yourself to visit Fratelli
3. Verace
Overall Ratings
4 based on 176 reviews
A fusion of classic Italian cuisine with modern sensibilities, Verace effortlessly combines fresh ingredients into new interpretations of traditional Italian dishes. The intimate setting pivots around our exposed Woodstone oven creating the warmth you fee
Reviewed By Journey791604
Not knowing what to expect I was pleasantly surprised by just how delicious our dinner was. We started with Drinks which were made just the way we like. Hot bread was brought to the table with a bowl of Ricotta drizzled with Honey, great combination. We shared a Pasta for our Appetizer. It was so good that I want to go back and have it again. We had CACIO E PEPE spaghetti, cracked black pepper, pecorino romano cheese....seriously amazing! We then had Chicken Parmesan and Chicken Milanese topped with arugula, shaved parmesan, grilled lemon. The portions were so big we had to take them home for another meal. For dessert our server overheard me say to my Boyfriend, you pick it is your birthday. He picked the tiramisu, mascarpone cream, lady fingers, espresso was one of the best we had. He brought it over with a lit candle which was so nice and classy since my boyfriend would not have liked a Big Birthday Song....When the bill came they took of the dessert and they gave my boyfriend a $25 gift card to use the next time we visit, which will certainly do! Great room, great music and really great service and food!!!
2. The Pie at Salvatores
Overall Ratings
4 based on 61 reviews
Reviewed By Shaf47286
My husband and I get the Neopolitan pizza and it's great. The crust is thin and crusty and it has light cheese and a great sauce. It's light but very filling and tasty. They have individual servings of pizza that are perfect for s simple lunch. The regular size pizza is perfect for three people.
Where to eat Bar food in Bay Shore: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Da Noi Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 79 reviews
Reviewed By Seapinesmiserable
This was our second visit to Da Noi and it unfortunately did not meet our expectation this time. We still enjoy the ambiance and the service is good. However, it was a busy night and the food was not up to par.We ordered the duck and a fish special. The meats were good, but the sides came out cold, an indication that the plate sat waiting for the special to be finished before the server brought the dinner to us. More attention would have made our meal better. A small restaurant like Da Noi should check the sides first and not serve cold food. So, we were disappointed.Da Noi is expensive, so our review should be nothing short of excellent, but this visit fell short.
Most Popular Seafood food in Bay Shore, New York, United States
