Location: Peekskill
Top Restaurants in Peekskill
New York, United States Food Guide: 9 Pizza food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Peekskill
Best Pizza restaurants nearby. Discover the best Pizza food in Peekskill. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Pizza restaurants near you.. 914
Things to do in Peekskill
9. Paradise Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 26 reviews
Reviewed By NancyLes69
Was skeptical when we walked in to the dated restaurant, but putting appearances aside the food was good. Ample portions and very tasty food made for a good meal.that was moderately priced. Service was a little slow since there was only one waitress, but overall it was good.
8. La Villetta Pizza & Pasta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 58 reviews
La Villetta Pizza & Pasta is an Italian Family Restaurant known for its great food, generous portions and fair prices. We are open 7 days a week for Lunch & Dinner. La Villetta features a full Italian Menu including Pizza, Pasta, Specialty Pizzas, Chicken
Reviewed By Stellarviews
Had the Calamari Fra Diavalo. Made fresh, good red sauce, friendly staff, owner on premises and circulating, clean well maintained dining area, clean restrooms, mid level pricing as expected, expansive menu. All and all a great experience on my quest for the best in Westchester. Go, youâll enjoy it.
7. Little Sorrento
Overall Ratings
4 based on 101 reviews
Reviewed By Codysmom4475
I've lived in the area for many years & have dined here many, many times.The owners & staff were always lovely, friendly & accommodating. The food was always consistently terrific. However, lately they are falling short in all areas. During a recent Sunday afternoon visit we were seated immediately but then waited forever for drink orders to be taken. The restaurant was not particularly crowded so there was really no excuse. The bread (usually a favorite of ours) was stale & the butter was melted to the point of being liquefied. Our house salads were wilted & our appetizers cold. When the entrees finally arrived they were ok but not up to the usual standard. I didn't see the owner so I am not sure if they are under new management. Maybe they are preoccupied with another location? All I can say, is that we were sorely disappointed. Not sure we will return for a while.
6. Annabella's Pizza & Pasta
Reviewed By ScenicTrek
We were in town for the Peekskill Film Festival, and we walked around a two-block perimeter of the theater to check out local restaurants. After sifting through several of them, we decided to eat here because pizza is always a good choice!We opted for the specialty pizzas. I had a slice of lasagna pizza, and my sweetheart had a slice of chicken marsala pizza. Both of them were absolutely delicious. We also had a slice of regular cheese pizza and a pepperoni roll, and they too were outstanding. Pizza pies made for slices are usually a little larger than the take-out versions, and even accounting for this fact I thought that the slices were substantial in size. There is a wide selection of bottled beverages. For instance, for just the iced tea alone there were about ten flavors. I found the place to be very reasonably pricedâso much so that when we paid for our meal I thought something had been overlooked, but upon review of what we ate the total was correct. The woman behind the counter (presumably the owner) was very cordial and accommodating.The restaurant is located right on the corner of No. Division and Park Streets, adjacent to a gazebo / platform, so itâs easy to find. While we were there we noticed barriers being set up outside to block off No. Division Street. We inquired about this and were told that on Fridays and Saturdays the street is closed to vehicular traffic because there is live music in the evenings. Annabellaâs couldnât be located in a more prime spot for such an event!The place seats probably about two dozen people inside, and there is additional outdoor seating for about ten people. Menu items include standard pizzeria fare, such as appetizers, soup, pasta, calzones, eggplant and veal dishes, wraps, heroes, salads, and of course pizza, which you can order in three sizes. There is also a limited kidsâ menu, a handful of seafood specialties, and a few dessert items.I would absolutely eat here again because I am curious to try some of their other specialty pizzas. You canât go wrong here because they offer solid food at great prices.If my review was helpful to you, please consider clicking the green thumbs-up / Thank / Yes button. Thank you!
5. Forno Brickoven Pizzeria
Reviewed By L4301AElindac
I read the reviews and was ready for some really good pizza but it had no flavor. I never use salt and pepper but I did on that pizza and it made it edible. By the way it's not a real brick omen either.
4. Amici's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 17 reviews
Reviewed By Mishy119
We always order out from here - hubby loves the ceasar salad with breaded chicken cutlet and mozzarella sticks. I like the beer patties. My favorite is just when I can stay and eat there. Everyone is friendly and the food comes fast. Pizza is good. Nice local place
3. Ravenna Osteria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 50 reviews
Reviewed By arnie31346
As time goes by the food here keeps getting better.A staple like Rigatoni with Broccoli Rabe and Grilled Children is delicious, as it always is.It's easy to get used to great food here.And then:Lobster Fra chaise? Portobello Risotto Mushrooms and Lobster Claw Meat ? OUTRAGEOUS !And the Service is just as good as the food.You really are missing something if you don't come here.Nov. 21, 2015Baratta? Fresh soft centered Mozzarella with Greens, Prosciutto and Roasted Peppers OUTRAGEOUS!  A huge order of Mussels in a Garlic White sauce and toasted Garlic bread. OUTAGEOUS! Braciole rolled with a great Marinara sauce and with Mushroom Risotto. OUTRGEOUS!. Orecchiette with Brocolli Rabe and home made Sausage. OUTRGEOUS! Delicious well prepared and fresh food, wonderful friendly service , pleasant atmosphere, good size portions and reasonable prices. Also, no rush stay as long as you like. How is it possible to take food this wonderful for granted?We are so used to the great food here that we forgot how lucky we are to live nearby.
Where to eat Italian food in Peekskill: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Gleason's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 76 reviews
Reviewed By James W
We stopped in here for dinner, and enjoyed a nice meal at this establishment. We started with drinks (they have a nice selection of draft beer), then ordered several of their specialty flat-bread pizzas, along with a couple of salads. They do have some other non-pizza menu items, but you're probably going to want to try the pizzas if you come here. They have a variety of different, and interesting choices, any of which can be customized (additional toppings, substitutions, etc). You can also build your own, selecting your favorite ingredients, which is what I did. My pizza was quite good, and really much more than I could eat by myself (these pizzas seem a little large for being single-serving entrees) The kitchen was not particularly fast, which was not an issue for us, but it was a little odd that my house salad took so long (it was brought out after all the pizzas arrived). But the salad was made with good, fresh greens. We didn't have any room for dessert, the pizzas were already more than we could eat. Will definitely be back to try more pizza combinations.
1. Nonna's Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 123 reviews
Reviewed By lizziebm
clean,friendly,quality, generous portions,and willing to customize my order.Eagle is a terrific server,and everyone was pleasant,the pizza looked great too.We found a new place.
