Location: Peekskill
Top Restaurants in Peekskill
Best American food near Peekskill, New York, United States
Find out what American restaurants to try in Peekskill. 914
Things to do in Peekskill
10. NY Firehouse Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 43 reviews
Reviewed By Jen K
I frequent this place quite often. The ninja warrior wings are my favorite. Tuesday nights are the night to go. Troy, the bartender, and Nikki, the go-to girl for anything you may need, are the best. I recommend this place for good food, good service, and great company! If you are looking for a laid back night out, go to FHG!
9. Touch Of Class Caribbean Fusion Cuisine
Overall Ratings
5 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By Andrea P
I had company from the west coast and wanted to try something different. Suffice it to say we had dinner on Thursday and was back on Friday for lunch. We had snapper, curry goat, jerk chicken and mahi mahi as main entrees . Chef wanted us to sample his oxtail and of course we had to take some home. The environment was pleasant, the wait staff incredible (Kitty and Jason) and Chef Mo has an artistry that infuses warmth, love and Caribbean flavors in every bite. Great for any occasion. Come quick and enjoy before this hidden gem is discovered.
8. Cortlandt Colonial Restaurant & Ballroom
Overall Ratings
4 based on 66 reviews
Restaurant and Catering Facility In Cortlandt Manor NY - Serving Mediterranean inspired New American Steaks and Seafood
Reviewed By loveftlaud
Mostly known as a catering hall, but just unbelievable restaurant too!Lovely, cozy, and warm dining room. All items on menu come with fantastic salad bar.Excellent service, aim to please. Freshly baked bread....my personal favorite is theprime rib, fresh seafood. I usually go for dinner, they even have weekly Sunday brunchbut havenât tried that yet.
7. The Peekskill Brewery
Overall Ratings
3 based on 248 reviews
The Peekskill Brewery is a restaurant and brewpub located on the Riverfront Green in Peekskill, NY. PB's lineup of beers consist of CREAM Ale, Hop Common, Old Wagon Ale and VB Stout- plus seasonal favorites such as Sally Sweeney Stout and Rosemary's Baby.
Reviewed By Greg808
So I take a lot of family and friends here and Iâm surprised by the reviews. This restaurant / brewery also features a small coffee bar recently opened during day time hours (its confusing in a brewery but good coffee). The upstairs features a short bar and more seating and the downstairs a long bar and a couple of booths. for those looking for service, I highly recommend the upstairs when dining. Most / not all of the staff here are great! Food is always excellent. Rotating food menu and Iâve never been disappointed. A little pricey / smaller portions than expected. Great beer menu, do not order mixed drinks, this bar prides themselves in NOT having a good mixed drink menu. If you can appreciate a really good beer, definitely make this place a destination. Big supporter in NY breweries as well as some creative creations in blends. Iâm never disappointed here.
6. Hudson Room
Overall Ratings
4 based on 76 reviews
We are a new restaurant in the Hudson Valley, New York. Centered in the middle of Peekskill (Westchester County), we welcome everyone to come experience our locally sourced and globally inspired food, tradition and atmosphere! We have a full Sushi bar and
Reviewed By Fudbutter
Food: AverageService: GoodDécor: GoodValue: PoorClosest place to the Paramount Theater so it is tempting to come here but the prices for the quality of food and drink are essentially highway robbery. $38 for a $25 bottle of wine, $13 for a Johnny Black single, $29 for $22 Jambalaya. In addition, side dishes are extraFood is OK, but the smell from the sushi bar (something was waaaay past it's prime in there) was sickening. Good service and nice room, thoughThere are many better places within a short walk. Your money is better spent thereForewarned is forearmed
5. Division Street Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 101 reviews
Located in the heart of Historic Downtown Peekskill's Artist District, The Division Street Grill offers eclectic American and International Cuisine, with Live Jazz Entertainment featuring a New York Style setting.
Reviewed By MichaelsFood
With 75% of existing reviews coming in at Very Good and Excellent, there's no real need to rehash how extremely good the food is.... and it really IS GREAT..... No, instead, for this review, I am going to focus on how a top quality staff and owner handle themselves when things go wrong.Division Street closes to traffic on weekend evenings and restaurants expand their dining to be out under the stars. Some put more effort into the outdoor seating area than others..... The Grill does a nice job with their linens, silverware and cloth napkins. Outdoor live music is also provided - one band for all restaurants. It's a really nice setting to be in downtown Peekskill dining outdoors in a very open space.Having all these extra tables puts a big strain on the kitchen brigade, and things can and will go wrong. Any restaurant, any day of the week, can have problems. We, as patrons, expect perfection but most have no idea how insane a commercial kitchen gets on a regular night, let alone a night when seating is nearly doubled.Long story short.... our appetizer order got lost somehow. Once alerted, our waiter got a rush on it and to make up for it, he bought us a round of drinks. When the entrees came out, my wife's was the wrong dish... like completely wrong. Fortunately she had ordered a salad with grilled sword fish, so that mistake was quickly rectified as well. Again our waiter was mortified at the mistake and offered free desserts for all three of us, which I thought was quite nice. After we finished dessert, the owner came over to chat.... also apologizing profusely. He comped my wife's salad as well, as, in his words, "A lady should never have to wait for anything".Sometimes things go wrong. We don't live in a perfect world. Most good restaurants work their tails off to give you the best they have to offer... day in and day out... because the love food and love to feed people. Division Street Grill understands the importance of this dynamic between house and patron better than most, I think.Sure they made mistakes that night, but they corrected those mistakes and made up for them without batting an eyelash. Yes, this restaurant gets an Excellent rating from me.... because they understand food as well as the industry better than most.
4. Birdsall House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 167 reviews
Reviewed By WonderSuz
Small pub with a chill vibe and great service. Large beer selection of mostly local breweries. The food is amazing; they have frequent delicious specials. I personally recommend the brisket burgers with hand cut fries and homemade ketchup. I've been several times and have yet to try something I don't like!
3. Gleason's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 76 reviews
Reviewed By James W
We stopped in here for dinner, and enjoyed a nice meal at this establishment. We started with drinks (they have a nice selection of draft beer), then ordered several of their specialty flat-bread pizzas, along with a couple of salads. They do have some other non-pizza menu items, but you're probably going to want to try the pizzas if you come here. They have a variety of different, and interesting choices, any of which can be customized (additional toppings, substitutions, etc). You can also build your own, selecting your favorite ingredients, which is what I did. My pizza was quite good, and really much more than I could eat by myself (these pizzas seem a little large for being single-serving entrees) The kitchen was not particularly fast, which was not an issue for us, but it was a little odd that my house salad took so long (it was brought out after all the pizzas arrived). But the salad was made with good, fresh greens. We didn't have any room for dessert, the pizzas were already more than we could eat. Will definitely be back to try more pizza combinations.
2. Table 9
Overall Ratings
4 based on 321 reviews
Reviewed By merlot94
We had a great dinner here on a Friday. Portions are huge, food was delicious and service was superb, very friendly and attentive. Prices were quite reasonable for size and quality of the portions. We were pleasantly surprised given some of the "average" reviews. Don't miss the lava cake! Only complaint is they don't take reservations for tables of less than six.
1. Kathleen's Tea Room
Overall Ratings
4 based on 161 reviews
Reviewed By Jean W
Saw a review on this restaurant and wanted to try it. Our family had brunch there and we all enjoyed everything. Our 10 year old granddaughter had the children's lunch and her own tea which she thoroughly enjoyed. Highly recommend this restaurant.
