Location: Penfield
Top Restaurants in Penfield
Most Popular Italian food in Penfield, New York, United States
Best Italian restaurants nearby. Discover the best Italian food in Penfield. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Italian restaurants near you.. Tony LaFountain (R; 2010-present)
Things to do in Penfield
10. The Northside Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 146 reviews
Reviewed By Alisonvo
A large group of family attended a holiday Brunch at Northside and it was horrible. The dining room was WAY too crowded, to the point that it was difficult to even get to the buffet. We had to move tables for a lady with a walker to get through. The buffet had run out of many items by the time we got there (not even at the end of the seating times), and staff were distracted and surly when we asked if there would be more food. (The answer was no.) The food that was left was not tasty and not good. We asked for a refund and got yelled at--needless to say, there was no refund. We will never go back.
9. Compane....A Brick Oven Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 112 reviews
Been open for about a year now. Excellent. Would like to write a review.
Reviewed By Larry W
We had talked about visiting this place on Main Street in Fairport numerous times, but this was our first actual visit for dinner, and we were fairly impressed. It's a pretty place inside, with only 20 tables, but very intimately arranged and decorated. Our waiter walked us through the long list of entrees and specials, many of which were created with a lot of imagination. I had the salad special, which was greens with figs and goat cheese, plus other compatible veggies and more. It was very good. I also had another appetizer as my main course; the lightly-fried calamari, which was also very nicely done and served with a pair of dipping sauces. It was a nice meal, and dinner for the three of us (with no alcohol or desserts) came to $77, which was quite reasonable. We will return in the future. BTW, we had reservations (for 5:15 PM), which is probably a good idea as they did get crowded.
8. Mr. Dominic's on Main
Overall Ratings
4 based on 278 reviews
Reviewed By Elliemae2828
We ate here for the first time. Calamari was hot and crispy, delicious. Salads were okay, bread was too. I had chicken saltimboca with rigatoni. It was very good. My husband had blackened swordfish with rigatoni, he enjoyed it. The waitress was fine, friendly and helpful. The only problem was the party of 6 seated next to us, with one loud, obnoxious drunk being in charge. He kept telling the waitress to take care of them and she would get 35% tip. Wow, arenât you impressed, or so we were supposed to be. I donât know what the restaurant could do, but it clearly was spoiling our meal and several other tables too. Will go back, but hope the drunk is elsewhere.
7. TK's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 67 reviews
When you're in the mood for a slice of pizza that will overtake your mouth with the robust flavors of fresh tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and hints of garlic and Italian spices, visit the finest pizza place in Fairport, NY. TK's Pizzeria is the place to go
Reviewed By Jerold J
T K's has been our favorite for many years. We get pizza from all the other places, but keep coming back to T K's because we like it the best.Although there is seating, the interior isn't much. I'll stop in for lunch if by myself but otherwise we use them for takeout.I've read a couple of comments about the owner being rude. He is matter-of-fact, and maybe a bit blunt, but I've never considered him rude. He is hard working and extremely fair. One time I came in at the tail end of lunch service (they close immediately after until evening) and he was done serving. He had a couple of slices left but just gave them to me because they'd been sitting for a bit. Anyway, great spot, give them a try.
6. Lillian's Restaurant & Party House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 66 reviews
Reviewed By Larry W
We have come to Lillian's on a number of occasions, and always enjoyed superb food and great service. Last week was no exception. The Ukrainian food was wonderful, (my wife says it reminds her of her grandmother's cooking), and my eggplant Parmesan was also fantastic. The portions were so large that we were both able to use the leftovers for lunch the next day! I highly recommend this place. We may even use their party room for our next family function.
5. Charley Brown's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 125 reviews
Serving hungry Rochestarians since 1967, Charley Brown's provides comfort and happiness in a casual and warm environment. We strive to impress our customers by giving them the highest degree of service possible while satisfying their tastes at fair and re
Reviewed By cdl17
Our hotel recommended Charlie Brown as a great restaurant for dinner! They were right! A great place! Very comfortable pleasant environment! Very relaxing with excellent service! Nice bar to enjoy a drink while you wait for your table! It was very busy so we were glad we had a reservation! The food was amazing! We had pasta and roast beef! Well cooked and presentation was very nice! Friendly, well trained servers! Restaurant is within walking distance of the hotels in that area! Stop at the Pour House Bar for a drink before dinner it is literally next door to a Charlie Brown! We had a great evening and amazing food! Great menu!
4. Rosey's Italian Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 63 reviews
Reviewed By cath27x
A small restaurant that puts out a lot of good italian food. Good place to stop and dine when you are in a hurry. Also offers take out which is great. Good menu selections (pasta, eggplant, chicken, greens and beans, etc.) Worth a try.
3. Joey's Pasta House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 172 reviews
Reviewed By John S
We went here with some friends that had been here before. This restaurant is very nice. It is a little "close quarters" in some areas of the restaurant. The staff is polite and friendly. The menu carries a lot of different choices, from seafood to steak and of course, a large selection of pasta. The dinners that we had were very good. They were well prepared, fresh and hot. It took a little bit for our meals after an appetizer, but we were catching up with friends so we were ok with that. The bread that is brought out to the tables was promised between the appetizer and salads, but didn't show up until after our meals were brought out. A couple of meals were ordered to go as we ate and they too were a little slow coming out. The kitchen seamed to be slow. Overall, this is a very good restaurant. We will return and would recommend.
2. Perlo's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 213 reviews
Perlo's offers a warm, comfortable atmosphere with a true feeling of being part of the family. Youâll find great food and a full bar in our upscale yet casual atmosphere. Wonderful home cooked meals including seafood, steaks, chops, Italian specialties an
Reviewed By Clarkvara
Love the Chicken Riggies at Perlo's, good size portions means Chicken Riggies for breakfast the next day. Place is usually pretty packed on Fridays and Saturdays so call ahead for a reservation. Service is good. If there's a down side it's their extremely small and limited wine list.
Where to eat American food in Penfield: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Lemoncello Italian Restaurant & Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 278 reviews
Considered one of the most authentic Italian restaurants in Monroe county. A place where visiting Italians are referred to for a meal most resembling home. Dinner Monday-Saturday starting at 5pm. Dinner Sunday starting at 4pm. Happy Hour Monday-Sunday 4pm
Reviewed By msrachacha
Lemoncello's has become one of our favorite restaurants! The chicken lemoncello is to die for as is their lemoncello salad dressing - which you can buy to take home! They are currently expanding their outdoor patio which is a great place to dine during the summer. You can't go wrong here!
