Location: Penfield
Top Restaurants in Penfield
Most Popular Restaurants in Penfield
Penfield in United States, from Nouth America region, is best know for Takeout. Discover best restaurants in Penfield with beautiful photos and great reviews from traveller around the world here!
Things to do in Penfield
1. Leo's Elite Bakery
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 119 reviews
Reviewed By Sharon H - Crewe, United Kingdom
Stopped in here with some friends for coffee and dessert. Great choice of desserts and reasonably priced too.
Coffee was self serve, but seemed to be freshly ground. One member of our party disappointed that they don't do lattes and cappucinos.
The shops has the feel of an upmarket farm shop. Everything looked delicious and fresh. The apple pies looked especially good.
Would definitely try the lunch next time we are visiting
2. Lemoncello Italian Restaurant & Bar
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 235 reviews
Considered one of the most authentic Italian restaurants in Monroe county. A place where visiting Italians are referred to for a meal most resembling home.Dinner Monday-Sunday starting at 4pm. Happy Hour Monday-Sunday 4pm-7pm in Bar Room only. Beautiful Patio in the warmer months as wellLive Music. See Website
Reviewed By Marlene W - Hong Kong, China
Lemoncello is not about pampered, chi chi tiny-portion-Italian cuisine - it is robust Italian-American of a stellar quality. The specials indicate however the genius of chef - we tried a combination of the specials and the items on the regular menu, which are your basic Italian-american dishes (parm! spag bol! etc). The special soup of the day was a mushroom that was exceptional, trimmed with just the right amount of truffle oil and garlic essence. The fish special featured stunning seafood and wahoo, grilled to perfection, with garlic mash and sauteed vegetables. Just these two dishes indicated the genius of chef. The items off the menu: the linguine vongole with red sauce was oversauced with unfortunate gobbets of marinara, probably an indication of the Italian-American interpretation of the dish. The greens, beans on pappardelle was also oversauced, but extremely tasty. Needless to say, the homemade pasta in both cases was fantastic - however, quality of the pasta would have been more apparent if not buried by the extreme quantities of sauce. Waitstaff was brisk but friendly and knowledgeable. Note: it was a bit offputting to arrive at what looks to be a restaurant to enter straight into a bog standard neighborhood bar, complete with long haired chappy playing '70s guitar. Advice to management: give more scope to chef, please!
3. Pittsford Farms Dairy
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 299 reviews
Reviewed By Marlene W - Hong Kong, China
For the 30 years we've lived in Pittsford, buying the tree was the joyful part of this old establishment. This year, 2 of "santas helpers" (blokes to tie and tether) were reprimanded when they sold me a tree with a label indicating US34 and the boss elf stated that that label was wrong: it HAD to have "fallen off" one of the wreaths and hooked itself firmly into the tree. Boss elf produced an entirely different tag which was for US49 which was supposedly the RIGHT tag. Santa's helpers not impressed. Boss elf as grumpy pants. Solution: split the difference, fer petesakes. My recommendation: the venue is nostalgic, but some Ebeneezer is running the show. Go with the Boy Scouts, use this place for photo ops. (Oops, Ebeneezer might want his royalty fee...).
4. Signatures at the Humphrey House
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 97 reviews
Reviewed By Larry W - Rochester, New York
Signatures continued to serve outstanding food in their re-done version of the Humphrey House in Penfield. They have a very diverse menu that has appetizers and entrees across a wide variety of selections. Their scallop salad is wonderful, although last night I tried their Shrimp & Pork Noodle Bowl. I thoroughly enjoyed that entrée, although I thought I improved it a bit by shaking on a lot of red pepper, which they brought to the table. (Hey, what can I say? I love things very spicy.) My appetizer was very unique...the Jerusalem artichoke & tomato salad dish, which was on their listing of appetizer specials.
By the way, I graded "Service" as a '4' instead of a '5'for last night, and that wasn't because there was anything really wrong with the service. But after the first few visits by "our" waitress (who was very nice), suddenly we seemed to be visited by several different waitresses....one bringing drinks, one bringing more bread, one bringing whatever. By the end of the meal we didn't know who was really our waitress. (We assumed it was the first one.) Once again, they were all really friendly, but given my 'druthers I'd rather know who was our actual waitress.
We thoroughly enjoyed our entire meal. They serve wonderful food that is truly unusual. I highly recommend this place.
5. Pattaya Thai Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 75 reviews
Reviewed By Larry W - Rochester, New York
My wife & I visited for dinner this weekend. We enjoy the food here because it is very tasty, inexpensive, and it comes out VERY quickly. I had my usual Masaman shrimp with three extra peppers...nice and spicey! Also, I recommend trying the fresh (not fried) shrimp spring rolls. They are WONDERFUL in their special peanut sauce. I highly recommend this place.
6. Perlo's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 164 reviews
Perlo's offers a warm, comfortable atmosphere with a true feeling of being part of the family. You’ll find great food and a full bar in our upscale yet casual atmosphere. Wonderful home cooked meals including seafood, steaks, chops, Italian specialties and wonderful wood-fired pizzas are what have made Perlo’s a Rochester tradition for over 12 years.In the warmer months, we invite you onto our outdoor patio. Owner Donna Perlo is delighted to host your private event or provide you with catering options. And remember, no one leaves Perlo’s a stranger—Donna guarantees it!
Reviewed By AD M - Rochester, New York
Great service even though it was extremely busy. We all had different dishes and all were very good. One was seafood that my wife had. She said that it was delish. The birthday boy had an egg plant special, which he devoured. My chicken parm.
was huge, I had to bring half of it home.
Excellent value !
7. Donnelly's Public House
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 141 reviews
Reviewed By Alisonvo - Rochester
YOU HAVE TO GET THE TATER TOTS! Food is generally large is quantity and fine in quality--hamburgers, sandwiches, wings (the grilled wings are especially good). Many people loudly at the bar, and couples/families/grandparents/kids at the tables ordering food. Good beer selection. TVs around.
8. Joey's Pasta House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 153 reviews
Reviewed By BlueMaxx14 - ROCHESTER NY
Another visit to Joey's, my wife's favorite local restaurant. We were treated very very well by Katrina, food was terrific. Always a treat. Outside the building there is some serious construction improvements goon' on, but inside, still comfortable and friendly.
9. Good Smoke BBQ
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 98 reviews
defining our own style of modern barbecue - come visit rochester's experts Good Smoke BBQ was formed in 2006 in a bid to destroy the competition at Oinktoberfest in Clarence, NY. Well we didn’t exactly destroy the competition but we didn’t finish last either! What we did do was ignite a love affair with barbecue and the need to perfect every aspect of our cooking with the goal of becoming competitive on the professional barbecue circuit. In the intervening years we have been lucky enough to have many successes on the circuit and want to offer competition level food to our customers. Family owned by Rochester natives.
Reviewed By AviMom2006 - Rochester, New York
As far as we are concerned, Dinosaur who? This place has phenomenal service, incredible food and it's reasonably priced. The server recommended the crispy ribs and we decided to give them a go. Needless to say, my husband ended up with only one rib because we stole them from him. My daughter, the riblet, enjoyed the crispy and regular ribs so much, she couldn't help gnawing at each bone like a little T-Rex. The brisket was tender, juicy and savory. Even the bbq chicken was incredibly moist and tender. I shared my plate with my daughter and couldn't finish the meal, so we got leftovers. The sides were definitely homemade and tasty. They use real potatoes in the mashed. We have not been enjoying the barbeque restaurants scene in the area lately, as they've become quite complacent in service and taste. Good Smoke BBQ has renewed our faith. We will return soon. The only negative was the plastic silverware because I had a hard time cutting my chicken.
10. McArdle's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 124 reviews
Welcome to McArdle’s Restaurant. We are a family owned and operated restaurant located just outside the village of Fairport near the Erie Canal. The attention to detail, quality and superior service makes McArdle’s a locals’ favorite. As you enter McArdle’s the first thing you will notice is the warm interior woodwork and the high backed wood booths crafted from hand selected pieces of white ash. These private booths provide the perfect setting for an intimate date night or family night out.
Reviewed By Roy P - Fairport, New York
This place is a good place to eat, just not a great place for us. The food is good, and they have a full bar within the dining area. My wife and I actually don’t frequent this restaurant very often because there is not a lot of seating available, which means a bit of a wait at dinnertime - even though it’s not crowded. I guess we need to show up very early with the retirement crowd if we don’t want to wait for normal dinner time seating. So basically - this is a smaller sized restaurant, so if you can come to eat here at off eating times; then I would give it a go!
