Location: Grand Island
Top Restaurants in Grand Island
Best Pizza food near Grand Island, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Pizza food in Grand Island, New York, United States. Nathan McMurray (D)
Things to do in Grand Island
10. Wine on Third
Overall Ratings
4 based on 462 reviews
Wine on Third is the premier dining, tapas, and wine bar in Niagara Falls, New York USA. We offer a full bar with cocktails and martinis and our food quality is unmatched anywhere in Western New York. We are family friendly with a dining room where you ca
Reviewed By LeeRides
On a relatively quiet Monday evening, my husband and I visited Wine on Third accompanied by our fur-kid. We asked permission to sit outside with our dog and our waiter said "of course." As the evening progressed, he even topped off her water bowl! Eric took good care of us. Our pizzas were fabulous. I really enjoyed the garlic-chicken-spinach white pizza. Thank you for the review! We are always pleased to hear when a customer enjoys their experience with us. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
9. Donatello's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 434 reviews
Reviewed By TravelBugVA
This unassuming family place has excellent pizza!! We ordered the 17â pizza that easily serves 3-4 people. We wanted the âItalianoâ with artichoke hearts, ricotta cheese, mozzarella cheese, red bell peppers. Wow! We loved it! Another person got a Greek salad with sliced, grilled chicken. The salad was very large with lots of black olives, feta cheese, and very fresh tomatoes. Another person in our party got a personal pizza with ham and mushrooms. Againâexcellent!Please keep in mind that this little place is not fancy. You use paper plates and plastic utensils. We certainly didnât mind a bit. We went there for the great food!
8. Michael's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 354 reviews
Reviewed By ChiefM55
We had the Italian Veal Dinner, the Spaghetti and Meatballs and Ziti and MeatBalls Entrees. Waitress was really helpful. We also added the plus up option to the house salad - sliced mozzarella cheese rolls. the salads were good. We were disappointed in the Veal, the veal was what appears to be frozen Breaded veal patties, not home made or a fresh pice of veal. the meatballs were fantastic, the sauce was excellent. The pasta was cooked well.
7. John's Pizza & Sub Shop
Overall Ratings
4 based on 23 reviews
Reviewed By pmhorv
Visiting Niagara Falls and wanted to get out of the mess down there. We both had 8" steak sandwiches. Mine on wheat, husbands on white. Bread was fresh. Meat was cooked perfect. Good and gooey with cheese, mushrooms, peppers and onions. (All optional). Bagged chips and soft drinks. Total cost was $17. Bathrooms could use some cleaning/deep cleaning for sure (at least womens). Door was grimy and scuffed and inside was pretty dirty too.) Other than the bathrooms I have no complaints.
6. Pizza Amore
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
Reviewed By ejtanner
Ordered a steak and cheese pizza, California pizza, and a prosciutto and arugula pizza the other night. Can't decide which one we liked best! The wood fire adds so much to the flavor of any pie from here. Oh, and loved the cannolis!
5. Just Pizza & Wing Co.
Overall Ratings
4 based on 14 reviews
Reviewed By JohnG126
Took a large pizza and wings for take out from here and they had it ready well ahead of when I thought it would be ready. The wings were cooked to perfection and the staff is always friendly.
4. Buzzy's New York Style Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 450 reviews
Reviewed By Kaupert
Dont know how we have missed this place all these years !! Delicious !! We ordered 2 specialty pizzas and wings !! Plenty left over.
Best American food near Grand Island, New York, United States
3. Rocky's Island Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 28 reviews
Your search for the best pizzeria in Grand Island, NY ends with Rocky's Island Pizza. Our local pizzeria has been serving up fresh food for years. We are well-known for our freshly made pizzas and our signature sweet pizza sauce. We keep you and your need
Reviewed By Amusementparkguy
While traveling to several places over the July 4th holiday, a friend and I came here to have dinner after spending some time at Fantasy Island amusement park. We always treat ourselves to this pizza whenever we are in the area. The service was great, and the pizza tasted excellent. It arrived quickly and was served hot. The restaurant appeared to be clean, and the employees were very friendly. The manager even stopped by the table to see if everything was okay. A must try experience.
Most Popular Bar food in Grand Island, New York, United States
2. Say Cheese Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 78 reviews
Reviewed By Kellysbflo
My grandsons , 3 and 5 years old , couldnât get enough of this place. They were so excited to see all the marvel characters while eating there kids pizza meal. The French fries are delicious and highly recommend them . They also enjoyed their toy that you can purchase for an additional $4.00. The toy is cheap and not sure if I would buy again but my grandsons liked it. Overall it is a great place to take the kids . I will return again . Thanks for the great review! We are so glad you enjoyed your experience.
Where to eat Brew Pub food in Grand Island: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Brick Oven Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 119 reviews
Brickoven Pizzeria & Pub has a great atmosphere. The dining area, and the pub, where we feature 28 beers on tap, are separated to establish a great balance. We have dine-in, patio, pick-up and delivery services available.
Reviewed By Andrea M
The pizza was ok but the place was really warm and cozy, great to grab some food after freezing while visiting the falls.
