Location: Grand Island
Top Restaurants in Grand Island
Best American food near Grand Island, New York, United States
Find out what American restaurants to try in Grand Island. Nathan McMurray (D)
Things to do in Grand Island
10. Mc Mahon's Family Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 35 reviews
Reviewed By BergholzTimelord
We had stopped for Breakfast at Mc Mahon's Family Restaurant one morning. It was the first time for us and late morning it seemed fairly quiet.The restaurant is a bit run down and not the cleanest place, which didn't bother us, but may bother others. We seated ourselves and it took some time for staff to come to us. We had ordered coffees, which came in HUGE mugs, and ordered our meals. Others had come in after us, and we had noticed that their orders came out before ours, so that was strange, but our food did eventually come out. Breakfast servings were quite large and we could not finish them. Food was as expected and tasted fine. We had finished our coffee early and no one followed up to see if we had wanted more.By the time we finished, the bill was dropped off at our table and I paid at the register. Prices were good for what we ordered.
9. Webster's Bistro and Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 223 reviews
Reviewed By baummy617
We've dined here several times. Webster's Bistro is literally everything I want when dining out. The ambience is warm and lovely. Food is prepared perfectly and beautifully presented. Our party had 3 different entrees tonite. All were nothing less than spectacular. Hearty portions mean leftovers for tomorrow. Woohoo can't wait! I love the service as well. Our server, Jessica, was top notch. This is really everything I want when springing for an evening out. Webster's Bistro has never disappointed. Oh..and be sure sign up for rewards card. Wow. Thank you so much for your five stars and your words really tell us that we are reaching our goal in providing our guest with a spectacular dining experience. We are excited to have you as a VIP member and look forward to serving you again very soon.
8. Say Cheese Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 78 reviews
Reviewed By Kellysbflo
My grandsons , 3 and 5 years old , couldnât get enough of this place. They were so excited to see all the marvel characters while eating there kids pizza meal. The French fries are delicious and highly recommend them . They also enjoyed their toy that you can purchase for an additional $4.00. The toy is cheap and not sure if I would buy again but my grandsons liked it. Overall it is a great place to take the kids . I will return again . Thanks for the great review! We are so glad you enjoyed your experience.
7. 773 North
Overall Ratings
4 based on 32 reviews
773 North is a new restaurant brought to you by owners Executive Chef Christy Zippier & her husband Jason Zippier. Their mission is to bring a new dining experience to Grand Island combining a great atmosphere with a trendy but humble menu. From homemade
Reviewed By Joel C
Four of us went to dinner, and we all left very pleased. The food was excellent and perfectly prepared. Two of us had haddock: one lemon pepper broiled and the other Parmesan. The green beans were done perfectly. The other two dishes ordered were Lazy Lasagna and Parmesan Crusty Chicken, also done perfectly. We finished eating near the time the ktchen was closing, and the chef came out to our table to get feedback on the meal, all of which was positive.
6. Riverstone Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 159 reviews
Reviewed By parakayjay
Review Note: 1 star deducted per item below.We have visited a number of times. However, this time we were very underwhelmed by the "Herculean meal" we ordered and comparing the photos of our previous visits, the steak we were served this time looked definitely way smaller than what we were served on previous visits. This was a very disappointing experience based on expectation versus reality.Secondly, the current and previous printed menu was very clear that it is served with soup or salad. Then in the description it indicates that the meal will come with a side of 1 pound of fries AND 1 pound of sweet potato fries. Only one side was provided and not until we complained that we were given only a small serving of sweet potato fries instead of 1 pound, claiming that the print out was incorrect. You can even view the old menu having the same wording that the meal is served with fries AND sweet potato fries.Third, the lights in the restaurant kept on flickering now and then when we visited. Correct lighting certainly has an impact on the experience of diners and should always be fully working and maintained well.Lastly, the price of the steak meal has soared a lot in the last couple of years since we first visited. Conclusively, my review is that this place has gone down a bit in both with the soaring prices and declining serving quantity.
5. The Beach House Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 92 reviews
A cozy family-friendly restaurant on the north end of Grand Island,NY. Though we are best known for our Fish Fry(served Wednesday through Friday) There is something on our menu for just about everyone. Open Seven days a week from 11am-10pm on Monday throu
Reviewed By Ann Marie K
I only had a burger and onion rings when I was here last week but they were delicious. On the burger: Fried onions, mayo and lettuce, just like I ordered. The fish fry and chicken parm that was delivered to the table next to me looked delicious too!
4. Brick Oven Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 119 reviews
Brickoven Pizzeria & Pub has a great atmosphere. The dining area, and the pub, where we feature 28 beers on tap, are separated to establish a great balance. We have dine-in, patio, pick-up and delivery services available.
Reviewed By Andrea M
The pizza was ok but the place was really warm and cozy, great to grab some food after freezing while visiting the falls.
3. The Village Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 121 reviews
The Village Inn is located in the historic Ferry Village in Grand Island, New York. Its quaint, homelike atmosphere and close proximity to the Niagara River make this restaurant a popular meeting place for locals, as well as for those visiting off island.
Reviewed By kathryngray
We were surprised when we realized the geography of Grand Island, so while staying at the Radisson, we looked for a restaurant on the island itself. The Village in was a delightful discovery. The menu was diverse. The food was delicious home style cooking and the portions were enormous!We ordered Hot Wings as an appetizer since we were so near Buffalo, primarily to take out for lunch tomorrow. We each sampled one and they were wonderful!! Spicy and tangy with just the right amount of heat at "medium."I ordered one of the daily specials, meatloaf with mashed potatoes and broccoli. John ordered the chicken Parmesan. Both plates were extremely generous and so very tasty that there was no room in the tank for dessert. Bummer. The double chocolate cake was so tempting at the next table over...
2. Dick and Jenny's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 278 reviews
Hand crafted food with Louisiana flair.
Reviewed By 207cindyl
We are staying at Branches if Niagara and decided to stop in here as itâs close. This is a New Orleans flavored restaurant. The atmosphere is eclectic, lots to look at. Service was excellent from our server Mike. The food was great. I had the Breast and Belly which was excellent. Would definitely come back again.
1. Chill 443
Overall Ratings
4 based on 178 reviews
Chill 443, located inside Wyndham Garden At Niagara Falls, features accessible full-service dine-in cuisine, casual lounge spaces with contemporary design and interactive game elements. Its carefully crafted coffee bar, creative cocktails & gourmet grab-a
Reviewed By Teertha G
Had lunch here during our Niagara Falls visit. Restaurant is located inside Wyndham Garden hotel. It was a short walk from our hotel, Comfort Inn.The restaurant was quite empty. Maybe early-mid September was already low season for Niagara. The food deserves a bigger crowd. The service was prompt although there was only one person taking care of the guests. We ordered Drunken Pork Cops, Chill 443 Burger and Grilled Fish Tacos. Taste wise this was the best food we experienced in Niagara. Presentation was nice too. Considering the food quality we found the price to be quite reasonable.Overall absolutely recommended.Teertha,Thank you for taking the time in providing feedback regarding your recent experience. I am so please to see that the food and service exceeded your expectations. I will be sure to share your positive feedback with our team. They work very hard to create memorable experiences like yours! We hope that you decide to join us again!
