Location: Orchard Park
Top Restaurants in Orchard Park
Where to eat Seafood food in Orchard Park: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Reviews on Seafood food in Orchard Park, New York, United States. Dr. Patrick J. Keem (R)
Things to do in Orchard Park
1. Lucia's on the Lake
Overall Ratings
4 based on 237 reviews
Lucia's on the Lake is a New American / Italian Waterfront Restaurant and Bar featuring fresh seafood, seasonal locally sourced ingredients, and an eclectic menu of Italian, Seafood, and Contemporary American cuisine.
Reviewed By jackiebr63
This a beautiful spot close to Lake Erie with lovely water viewing while drinking cocktails/wine on the upstairs outside deck. Ideal spot except for wires making it a somewhat obstructed view. Too bad food isnât served up there because not only lovely but quiet. Downstairs in the main eating area itâs a bit noisy and although windows with seats next to them, the view wasnât quite the same, especially since they kept moving the shades to protect those who didnât want the sun in their eyes, despite offering sunglasses for those patrons. We just wore our sunglasses because how often is that view available on a sunny Buffalo evening? The food was good, the seafood very fresh and tasty, sauces good, but the biggest drawback to this place is that the pasta is made elsewhere, and definitely stale compared to fresh house made pasta and risotto. And you really notice the flavorless stale pasta That really disappointed the four of us especially since early that week and the following night we ate fresh house-made pasta in two different terrific Buffalo restaurants. We also ordered the huge bruschetta plate and we did eat that all down. Pricy but decent.
Most Popular Bar food in Orchard Park, New York, United States
2. Lucia's on the Lake
Overall Ratings
4 based on 237 reviews
Lucia's on the Lake is a New American / Italian Waterfront Restaurant and Bar featuring fresh seafood, seasonal locally sourced ingredients, and an eclectic menu of Italian, Seafood, and Contemporary American cuisine.
Reviewed By jackiebr63
This a beautiful spot close to Lake Erie with lovely water viewing while drinking cocktails/wine on the upstairs outside deck. Ideal spot except for wires making it a somewhat obstructed view. Too bad food isnât served up there because not only lovely but quiet. Downstairs in the main eating area itâs a bit noisy and although windows with seats next to them, the view wasnât quite the same, especially since they kept moving the shades to protect those who didnât want the sun in their eyes, despite offering sunglasses for those patrons. We just wore our sunglasses because how often is that view available on a sunny Buffalo evening? The food was good, the seafood very fresh and tasty, sauces good, but the biggest drawback to this place is that the pasta is made elsewhere, and definitely stale compared to fresh house made pasta and risotto. And you really notice the flavorless stale pasta That really disappointed the four of us especially since early that week and the following night we ate fresh house-made pasta in two different terrific Buffalo restaurants. We also ordered the huge bruschetta plate and we did eat that all down. Pricy but decent.
Top 10 Italian food in Orchard Park, New York, United States
3. Lucia's on the Lake
Overall Ratings
4 based on 237 reviews
Lucia's on the Lake is a New American / Italian Waterfront Restaurant and Bar featuring fresh seafood, seasonal locally sourced ingredients, and an eclectic menu of Italian, Seafood, and Contemporary American cuisine.
Reviewed By jackiebr63
This a beautiful spot close to Lake Erie with lovely water viewing while drinking cocktails/wine on the upstairs outside deck. Ideal spot except for wires making it a somewhat obstructed view. Too bad food isnât served up there because not only lovely but quiet. Downstairs in the main eating area itâs a bit noisy and although windows with seats next to them, the view wasnât quite the same, especially since they kept moving the shades to protect those who didnât want the sun in their eyes, despite offering sunglasses for those patrons. We just wore our sunglasses because how often is that view available on a sunny Buffalo evening? The food was good, the seafood very fresh and tasty, sauces good, but the biggest drawback to this place is that the pasta is made elsewhere, and definitely stale compared to fresh house made pasta and risotto. And you really notice the flavorless stale pasta That really disappointed the four of us especially since early that week and the following night we ate fresh house-made pasta in two different terrific Buffalo restaurants. We also ordered the huge bruschetta plate and we did eat that all down. Pricy but decent.
Best American food near Orchard Park, New York, United States
4. Lucia's on the Lake
Overall Ratings
4 based on 237 reviews
Lucia's on the Lake is a New American / Italian Waterfront Restaurant and Bar featuring fresh seafood, seasonal locally sourced ingredients, and an eclectic menu of Italian, Seafood, and Contemporary American cuisine.
Reviewed By jackiebr63
This a beautiful spot close to Lake Erie with lovely water viewing while drinking cocktails/wine on the upstairs outside deck. Ideal spot except for wires making it a somewhat obstructed view. Too bad food isnât served up there because not only lovely but quiet. Downstairs in the main eating area itâs a bit noisy and although windows with seats next to them, the view wasnât quite the same, especially since they kept moving the shades to protect those who didnât want the sun in their eyes, despite offering sunglasses for those patrons. We just wore our sunglasses because how often is that view available on a sunny Buffalo evening? The food was good, the seafood very fresh and tasty, sauces good, but the biggest drawback to this place is that the pasta is made elsewhere, and definitely stale compared to fresh house made pasta and risotto. And you really notice the flavorless stale pasta That really disappointed the four of us especially since early that week and the following night we ate fresh house-made pasta in two different terrific Buffalo restaurants. We also ordered the huge bruschetta plate and we did eat that all down. Pricy but decent.
5. Red Lobster
Overall Ratings
3 based on 44 reviews
Reviewed By chris45ny
My husband and I go to this Red Lobster frequently because I love Walt's favorite shrimp. I'm going to combine 2 trips into 1 review this time. We stopped here on 8/17/18 and on 12/23/18. We were seated quickly in a booth both visits as requested. Our server on 8/17/18 was Paige W and on 12/23/18 our server was Jennifer S. I must say that every time we come to this Red Lobster all the servers we've had have been friendly and have provided excellent service. There is a large parking area with handicap spaces. On 8/17/18 I ordered-what else-Walt's favorite shrimp. I chose broccoli for my side. For the choice between soup or salad I went for the house salad with the champagne vinaigrette dressing. I also asked for and received extra cocktail sauce and lemon. My husband also ordered his usual-the broiled flounder with the broccoli and the house salad but with French dressing. Coffee was hot and strong but not bitter. Those divine cheese biscuits arrived before our salads. Whoever Walt is I just love his shrimp and happy to see it still on the menu! My husband enjoys his flounder as it's always been cooked just the right amount of time. Cost without tip was $38.15The next visit of 12/23/18 we did deviate a bit. My husband knew we would be having lots of food Xmas Eve so he opted for just soup and salad. House salad with French dressing and lobster bisque soup. He said the soup was very good. He was expecting the soup to have some bits of lobster but all the ingredients were pureed together. I am a creature of habit and I just love those shrimp so much. However, I got the Walt's favorite shrimp as a side. This meant I got 6 shrimp instead of the 12 with the dinner choice. I can do 9 shrimp but then I end up giving my husband 3. He's not into the shrimp like I am. I also got a house side salad with my favorite champagne vinaigrette dressing. And those biscuits!!! We both got tea instead of our usual coffee. This was a light dinner but very tasty and just the right amount of food for us seniors! Cost without tip was $25.49. I can only hope that Walt's favorite shrimp stays on the menu because what would I do without it???!! I've had fried shrimp at home and at other restaurants but for me Red Lobster's Walt's is my favorite shrimp.We're so glad you had a great experience at our Buffalo Red Lobster!
