Location: Orchard Park
Top Restaurants in Orchard Park
Top 10 Italian food in Orchard Park, New York, United States
Best Italian restaurants nearby. Discover the best Italian food in Orchard Park. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Italian restaurants near you.. Dr. Patrick J. Keem (R)
Things to do in Orchard Park
10. Olive Garden
Overall Ratings
4 based on 102 reviews
Reviewed By chris45ny
On 10/2/18 my husband and I decided to stop for an early dinner after some shopping in the area. This Olive Garden is located by the McKinley Mall. There is plenty of parking and handicap parking is also available. We were seated at our requested booth right away. Our server was Drew F. He was friendly and provided very good service.Since it was around 4:00 PM we decided to order from the early dinner duos menu. This is a great value where several entrees are offered for $8.99 each. Available Monday-Thursday from 3:00-5:00 PM. Comes with either salad or soup and breadsticks. We chose the salad. I like the dressing a lot and was glad when it became available at my TOPS to buy. I got my personal favorite-breaded chicken parmigiana which came with a generous helping of spaghetti. The chicken was perfectly breaded and cooked. Yummy sauce over all. My husband ordered the spaghetti with meat sauce. He said the pasta was not overcooked and the sauce was tasty. Coffee rounded out the meal. Cost without tip was $25.53.
9. Lucia's on the Lake
Overall Ratings
4 based on 237 reviews
Lucia's on the Lake is a New American / Italian Waterfront Restaurant and Bar featuring fresh seafood, seasonal locally sourced ingredients, and an eclectic menu of Italian, Seafood, and Contemporary American cuisine.
Reviewed By jackiebr63
This a beautiful spot close to Lake Erie with lovely water viewing while drinking cocktails/wine on the upstairs outside deck. Ideal spot except for wires making it a somewhat obstructed view. Too bad food isnât served up there because not only lovely but quiet. Downstairs in the main eating area itâs a bit noisy and although windows with seats next to them, the view wasnât quite the same, especially since they kept moving the shades to protect those who didnât want the sun in their eyes, despite offering sunglasses for those patrons. We just wore our sunglasses because how often is that view available on a sunny Buffalo evening? The food was good, the seafood very fresh and tasty, sauces good, but the biggest drawback to this place is that the pasta is made elsewhere, and definitely stale compared to fresh house made pasta and risotto. And you really notice the flavorless stale pasta That really disappointed the four of us especially since early that week and the following night we ate fresh house-made pasta in two different terrific Buffalo restaurants. We also ordered the huge bruschetta plate and we did eat that all down. Pricy but decent.
8. Lucia's on the Lake
Overall Ratings
4 based on 237 reviews
Lucia's on the Lake is a New American / Italian Waterfront Restaurant and Bar featuring fresh seafood, seasonal locally sourced ingredients, and an eclectic menu of Italian, Seafood, and Contemporary American cuisine.
Reviewed By jackiebr63
This a beautiful spot close to Lake Erie with lovely water viewing while drinking cocktails/wine on the upstairs outside deck. Ideal spot except for wires making it a somewhat obstructed view. Too bad food isnât served up there because not only lovely but quiet. Downstairs in the main eating area itâs a bit noisy and although windows with seats next to them, the view wasnât quite the same, especially since they kept moving the shades to protect those who didnât want the sun in their eyes, despite offering sunglasses for those patrons. We just wore our sunglasses because how often is that view available on a sunny Buffalo evening? The food was good, the seafood very fresh and tasty, sauces good, but the biggest drawback to this place is that the pasta is made elsewhere, and definitely stale compared to fresh house made pasta and risotto. And you really notice the flavorless stale pasta That really disappointed the four of us especially since early that week and the following night we ate fresh house-made pasta in two different terrific Buffalo restaurants. We also ordered the huge bruschetta plate and we did eat that all down. Pricy but decent.
7. Pappaceno's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 15 reviews
Reviewed By Sir_Lupe
Ordered the white pizza which was am said to be very popular. Upon arrival for pickup, food was ready, but staff forgot how to smile or be friendly. Substantial crust: crispy outside and chewy inside/ just how I like it.Cheese was plenty and stringy. Overall hot and fresh, but the other toppings lacked flavor. I got bored after the first slice.
6. Cappelli's Pizza
Reviewed By ronaldg863
Cappelli's serves great pizza cooked to perfection the way you wish. We always ask for a slightly brown underside to eliminate soggy pizza as toppings seep through the dough. We had a large pizza with onions and sausage: excellent. Highly recommend Cappelli's pizza.
5. Mulberry Italian Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 975 reviews
Reviewed By Junejude
5 of us gathered to celebate a milestone birthday. Our server Amy was simply excellent with a great sense of humor! We all enjoyed different entrees..especially homemade manicotti, lasange and meatballs of course!. All food arrived as ordered and hot. It was quite busy, but that did not impact our food or service.
4. Ilio DiPaolo's Restaurant and Banquet Facility
Overall Ratings
4 based on 173 reviews
Are you looking to host a corporate event, wedding reception, birthday party or special event? We have more than 50 years of experience to provide you and your guests a pleasurable evening. Our banquet facility seats up to 275 people, so call us today to
Reviewed By Christine2335
Recently, my mother, son and I enjoyed a fantastic dinner at Ilio DiPauolos for my motherâs birthday. Wow! We were in love with the menu, the restaurant and ambience and the attentive server. We started with an order of stuffed mushrooms which were excellent and fresh bread and oil. I thoroughly enjoyed my spaghetti and sauce topped with mushrooms and mozzarella cheese. Mom loved the lasagna and son raves about the fettuccine Alfredo. We were all in the mood for a traditional Italian dinner and we were not disappointed. I enjoyed my supper with a nice Pinot Noir and we finished with a good old fashioned cannoli. Perfect. We were able to park in front of the entrance for my mother but there is plenty of parking behind the restaurant. I made same day reservations on a Sunday and had no trouble. I highly recommend for family dinners, romance or any occasion! Enjoy. Mangiamo!Christine,Thank you for taking the time to leave us a great review! We wouldn't be in business for over 50 years if we didn't have great friends like you. We're so glad to hear you enjoyed the Spaghetti, Lasagna and Fettuccine Alfredo! We look forward to seeing you and your family again soon. Thank you,Dennis DiPaolo
3. Dove Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 69 reviews
Reviewed By adwoman
This place has been going strong for years and shows no signs of losing its appeal. Really excellent homemade meals with a decidedly Italian bent. And your meal comes with the works: soup, salad, palate cleanser, even a warm cookie (the cookie wasn't very impressive though). We could smell the garlic from the parking lot, luring us in. I had the special, a pork chop, and it was really delicious. Nothing much fancy about the decor, but the service is excellent (same waitress has been there for years and she shows no signs of slowing down). We went on a busy Friday and were lucky enough to snag one of the last tables with no waiting. A very pleasant and yummy evening for not a bad price.
2. Mangia Ristorante & Caffe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 248 reviews
Reviewed By tellurideplunge
Charming Italian restaurant. Seven of us had dinner and a variety of meals. Most were quite good. The lasagna looked huge. My friend says thatâs her meal that every time. My veal parm was good but Iâve had much better. My kids enjoyed their pasta. Overall a very good meal.
1. Lucia's on the Lake
Overall Ratings
4 based on 237 reviews
Lucia's on the Lake is a New American / Italian Waterfront Restaurant and Bar featuring fresh seafood, seasonal locally sourced ingredients, and an eclectic menu of Italian, Seafood, and Contemporary American cuisine.
Reviewed By jackiebr63
This a beautiful spot close to Lake Erie with lovely water viewing while drinking cocktails/wine on the upstairs outside deck. Ideal spot except for wires making it a somewhat obstructed view. Too bad food isnât served up there because not only lovely but quiet. Downstairs in the main eating area itâs a bit noisy and although windows with seats next to them, the view wasnât quite the same, especially since they kept moving the shades to protect those who didnât want the sun in their eyes, despite offering sunglasses for those patrons. We just wore our sunglasses because how often is that view available on a sunny Buffalo evening? The food was good, the seafood very fresh and tasty, sauces good, but the biggest drawback to this place is that the pasta is made elsewhere, and definitely stale compared to fresh house made pasta and risotto. And you really notice the flavorless stale pasta That really disappointed the four of us especially since early that week and the following night we ate fresh house-made pasta in two different terrific Buffalo restaurants. We also ordered the huge bruschetta plate and we did eat that all down. Pricy but decent.
