Location: Dover
Top Restaurants in Dover
Top Things to do in Dover
Where to eat Italian food in Dover: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Dover, Pennsylvania, United States. Dover is a borough in York County, Pennsylvania, United States. The population was 2,007 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Dover
10. La Famiglia Bistro
Reviewed By WOLVES911
They have lovely bread they use on their sandwiches(high quality) I am in love with. They have a clean appearance and most staff is smiley and pleasant. The lady at the front however is my only problem with this place, she picks up the phone while your ordering, holds a personal conversation on the phone and makes you wait. You ask her if you could have a soda she will grab it, ring it up, and never make eye contact or answer you other than when she gives you the price. She is very unpleasant and nothing like any of the guys I encounter there any other time. This is my favorite sandwich place now and they actually have good pizza as well. I am picky when it comes to pizza. Prices are decent and reasonable. It is a casual setting of course.
9. Victor's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 206 reviews
A neighborhood staple since 1984, Victorâs has evolved into the perfect reflection of an Italian Trattoria. Though the quality of the food, thoughtfulness of the service, and the caliber of wines, beers, and cocktails offered may hint at a more upscale Ri
Reviewed By Tomkypa
We don't go here very often and when we do it's a treat. The restaurant is in an old church in a residential part of York. It seems to be always busy when we are there so you need reservations. They have a varied menu. All good, good wine selection and full bar. Parking can be tight on north side of church. There is a bustle about the place but not obtrusive. This is not in cheap eats category.
8. Genova's Pizza and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By lafoose
Haven't been in a while, should have known when there were absolutely zero cars in the parking lot at supper time. Got a meat lovers pizza and a Greek salad. Both were mediocre IMO. The pizza was no better than fast food, and the salad was atocuious. Is feta cheese good? Sure is, but when a salad consists of pretty much nothing but that, olives, and celery, Houston, we have a problem. Won't be back soon. A huge waste of $25.
7. Tutoni's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 131 reviews
Tutoni's menu of creative dishes and new spins on traditional Italian standards - rooted in the region's abundant agricultural scene - offer customers a dining experience they can't find anywhere else. Tutoni's strives to pair top-notch service in a sophi
Reviewed By Patty6316
Well I loved the atmosphere. Not crazy about the Tapas Bar. There was NO service at the tables - at least we did not get any. Had to wait on ourselves by going to the bar for everything we needed and they were not the friendliest people either. Don't get the fried oysters - $8.00 for 2 small oysters smothered in some white sauce. The Mushroom Bruschetta was delicious. Total menu is very limited. All wine is measured prior to pouring into glass and they use the same measuring cup for white or red. Don't like that. We did not stay long and don't plan to return there anytime soom.We are so sorry to hear that you had less than a great experience at our restaurant. We take pride in giving our guests a top notch experience and feel terrible that this wasn't the case for you. Our bar area has recently been recently revamped/restructured to make sure every guest that sits at a table is able to receive service without needing to go to the bar. Our tapas menu is small but rotates through items, so the oysters will not always be there. In addition to the tapas menu, guests that sit at the bar are also able to order from our regular dinner menu. We also offer self-serving wine pour stations, so that is always a back up option if you don't like the way our bartenders are pouring.Thank you for your feedback, we will make sure we pay attention to the aspects you touched on to ensure improvement in our bar service. The next time you choose to come in, please send us an email ([email protected]) or send a Facebook message to Tutoni's and we will be sure to take care of you.
6. Olive Garden
Overall Ratings
3 based on 127 reviews
Reviewed By Inspire51306200580
We arrived at 11am at opening for soup and salad. No one was there. It was a Monday. We waited 30â to be seated. The table and seats were filthy so clearly no cleaning had be done from the day before, and there was a horrible stench in the room. Were we not meeting family, I would have left. I used Napkins as best as I could to clean. We were given water and then waited 30â minutes for salad. We had 3 little ones with us who behaved amazingly considering we waited 15â more for breadsticks that were âin the oven.â They were warm, but by the time our soup arrived, 15â more had passed, and we were all pretty much done. It was 40 degrees outside, and we had cold air blowing down us. The waitress was nowhere to be found, and when she did serve, she served over the top of a one year oldâs Head! The tomatoes in my minestrone were too tough to eat and none of the vegetables were really cooked. I will not be going back.
5. Pizza al Bacio
Overall Ratings
4 based on 33 reviews
Reviewed By Becky E
This was the first time visiting this place. It is near my house, so I thought I would try it after just having an ordeal with another pizza place.We ordered a large pepperoni/green pepper pizza. Everyone enjoyed it. The pizza had just the right balance of sauce and cheese. The crust was thin (I prefer this!), but not crispy. The sauce had good flavor too. All around a good pie.My only suggestion would be to have an extra large pizza. I thought the large was a bit small (16"). Maybe go to an 18" for the XL pizza. I'll admit it, I just wanted more pizza to eat!
4. The Vault Pizza & Grill
Reviewed By cornmanrichards
Been here a few times and great place to get appetizers, pizza and sandwiches. Not a craft beer place like we typically go to, just a nice local bar that isnât a dive.
3. Sal's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By cornmanrichards
This place knows how to make pizza and subs! Don't forget to order cheese and bacon fries. You might get a heartattack, but you'll go with a smile on your face. This is good food!you rock!
2. Jim & Nena's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 25 reviews
Reviewed By Greg S
We were recently camping at Gettysburg Farms and the staff recommended Jim & Nena's pizza. We ordered on Saturday night and less than 30 minutes later they were at the campground gate with three boxes of deliciousness. The pizza was fantastic!!!!!!! I would definitely recommend Jim & Nena's next time your in the East Berlin area!
1. Moonlight Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 154 reviews
Moonlight Cafe in Dover, Pennsylvania has been York County's hidden Italian treasure for almost a decade. The secret is out. Bring your bottle of wine and discover the area's finest traditional Italian cuisine, new favorite dishes, and the best espresso i
Reviewed By hharing1972
Had the chicken parm. First of all the chicken was a plain piece of breast laying on a pile of spaghetti. And had to pay for the mozzarella to put of top. Last I heard the chicken should be breaded and fried and come with the cheese. Cute place and smelled amazing just very disappointed.
