Location: New Lisbon
Where to eat American food in New Lisbon: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Reviews on American food in New Lisbon, Wisconsin, United States. New Lisbon is a city in Juneau County, Wisconsin, United States. The population was 2,554 at the 2010 census.
9. Mauston Park Oasis Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 129 reviews
Reviewed By AndrewFromMadison
Mauston has very large truck stop (you can't miss it because you will see real semi truck hanging on the pole when approaching), several gas stations and fast foods, and this family restaurant. Overall the restaurant is good. The ambience is good. Also helps that the restaurant is conjoined with a gas stations and convenience store. And they sell cheese and bakery here as well. You can't go wrong stopping at this place.
8. Culver's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 51 reviews
Reviewed By luvtafish
Food is usually pretty good thatâs why we usually stop at one while traveling. This is the first time in Mauston Wi. Traveling with a boat or trailer donât bother going there! Nowhere to park!! Saw several vehicles got stuck in the lot! Wonât be going there again!
7. Shipwreck Bay
Overall Ratings
4 based on 54 reviews
Reviewed By LaurieM0109
Go early to avoid the crowd!! Owners out on the floor and overseeing the crowd and pitching in. I ordered Taco salad- not great, my husband ordered the fish fry and liked it a lot...but had to wait a long time for more. Waitress friendly...but when we were leaving there were a couple of the wait staff out smoking by the entrance...not cool! Noise was very loud, looks like a good family atmosphere on the water. Will give it another try.
6. Roman Castle Italian Grill & Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 186 reviews
Reviewed By Mary M
I was planning to stop at the local Deli for a quick bite to eat. To my surprise they had closed early which lead me down the street to the Roman Castle. All of the staff was very friendly and attentive! I ordered the lasagna which came with soup or salad. I got the house salad with balsamic vinaigrette & it came with a single loaf of bread and butter. After salad and some bread I was nearly full but my lasagna came and it was beautiful, along with two pieces of garlic bread. So flavorful I could only eat half but I brought back 1/2 which I can enjoy later. Owner even came around table to table greeting guests and asking how things are, very classy! Iâll be back for sure!Thank you for letting us know how we're doing. We are pleased to hear you enjoyed your visit with us. Our team works hard to give great service and great food. We hope to see you again soon!
5. A&W Restaurant
Reviewed By Brenda J
Business lunch - on a short amount of time. Took way too long. They had only 3 orders and we watched as they cooked each burger from the orders separately. The grill was large enough to cook several orders at once. I had the chicken strips. I watched as they were cooked and the temperature tested by the worker with a probe. I saw one of the workers open the metal door beneath the cooker and use a screw driver on something. I don't mind if places are a little slow, but this was ridiculous and the food tasted terrible. Either bad grease or bad hamburger or both. I tasted a bite of my co-workers burger and it was like plasticy tasting. My tenders were rubbery and tasted "off". Won't be eating here again.
4. Silver Star Health
Reviewed By Brenda J
I've been here a few times. Very nice place. A real hidden gem in this small town. Lovely things for sale in the shop and really good food and coffee. Nice place to stop.
3. Pine Cove
Overall Ratings
3 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By Monankit
While the service was great (minor mistakes), the food was average and not worth the drive across the lake. They do offer outdoor seating which is nice. Overall, would not recommend this place. Prices were too high for the food you get.
2. Dirty Turtle
Overall Ratings
4 based on 60 reviews
Reviewed By Julie B
We were here on a Friday night for drinks. The bar was busy, but not that busy. The bartenders were huddled in a circle talking, and not really serving drinks. We were in the area for the weekend, and had actually planned on coming back for their Luau Saturday night, but found somewhere else to go since they made us feel so unwelcome.We are very appreciative that you took the time to leave us a review, Miss_gypsy_garmin! We will most definitely bring your concerns to the attention of our staff. We love to please, and we are sorry the service was not up to par as you expected. We hope we will have the pleasure of serving you again soon and provide you with a 5 star experience you deserve!
1. The Body Shop Bar and Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 33 reviews
Reviewed By Jennie N
It was totally awesome. Nice atmosphere, food was awesome, service was awesome and price was awesome. Very friendly place to eat and owner and some family members and a great waitress were the workers at around lunch time. The owner(who was also working in kitchen) came out and talked with patrons. Food prices are great and will be stopping there again. Great job to the Body Shop.
