Location: Phelps
Top Restaurants in Phelps
Top Things to do in Phelps
Top 10 Italian food in Phelps, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Phelps, New York, United States. Norman Teed (D)
Things to do in Phelps
10. Corner Tavern
Overall Ratings
3 based on 59 reviews
Reviewed By D1169LZjeremyh
Previous reviews and especially the online menu sounded encouraging. Reality was quite different. Actual menu rather pedestrian. Service was horrible - we were the only table occupied on the restaurant side after a party of 8 left shortly after we were seated but had to remind wait staff to bring appetizers after 1/2 hr. wait. Another reminder to check if entrees ready. Beef on bun was ok. Portabella pannini was garlicky with nice hot bun but cold portabella, minimal cheese or balsamic. Meh.
9. Sbarro
Home of the original XL NY Slice. Since 1956, Sbarro has been serving the XL NY Slice. Starting with made-daily hand stretched dough, San Marzano style sauce and topped with 100% Whole Milk Mozzarella cheese.
Reviewed By Horty83
While I wasn't expecting much from a service plaza restaurant, the meal was terrible. $14 for a small plate of spaghetti, Caesar salad, a breadstick and a drink. While none of the options looked promising, I can't imagine them being worse than my choice. The spaghetti was the worst I've had. The salad was the only item I had any hope for yet it was soggy and the croutons were just gross. I would have been upset spending 5$. I won't be eating at Sbarro again.
8. Ventosa Vineyard
Overall Ratings
4 based on 232 reviews
Ventosa Vineyards opened its doors for business September 25, 2005. Ventosa offers premium wine tastings in a beautiful Tuscan setting. Ventosa offers premium vinifera wines ranging from dry reds to dry and semi dry whites. Ventosa specializes in Italian
Reviewed By domtt62
One of the nicer wineries in the area. If your there on days they have singers on patio, itâs even better. The winery has a tasting bar but on certain evening they have BOGO and entertainment. They also serve food, ok selection, with friendly wait staff. Worth the evening.
Phelps Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Phelps
7. Cobblestone Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 176 reviews
The Cobblestone Restaurant in Geneva, New York provides casual, intimate fine dining.
Reviewed By heatherbI1760DE
Very clean and nicely decorated. Service was friendly but just a little odd overall experience. They didnât seem to have a handle on who was assigned our table as we kept getting asked the same questions by various staff. Had calamari for an app. And it was just ok. A little over cooked and the batter was plain. Just some basic pepper jelly on the side for dipping. I ordered the Delmonico special and my husband ordered the pasta pomadora. Our order was brought out by another staff member and we started eating. Our original server came by and asked if we received the right food and kind of looked at our plates. Odd question we thought. Then the other server came by and asked the same thing , not how was it but did you get the right order ? clearly there was a issue. Steak was ok , but not a delmonico I thought but hadnât paid too much attention as it was covered in a strange tasting âbrown gravyâon it that literally tasted like jar gravy. Now the server came back when we were almost done eating and apologized for us getting the wrong food and said she wouldnât charge us for the Delmonico steak but for what I received? All very odd. Then I overheard a server tell the next table they received the wrong steak. Oh my. Anyway , they were over apologetic and then offered a free dessert as well. We never complained or even acknowledged an issue , but they continued to make a big deal. We Had the chocolate, peanut butter cake which was very good. Overall , not sure weâd return, though they tried hard.
Where to eat Pub food in Phelps: The Best Restaurants and Bars
6. Bella's Sicilian Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 52 reviews
Reviewed By NormP732
This is one of the best restaurants in the Finger Lakes region! They serve a great variety of classic Italian dishes- especially their lasagna! Another really neat treat is when one of the owners begins singing classic Italian songs. Because itâs such a popular place, Iâd encourage you to make reservations.
5. Cams New York Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 76 reviews
Reviewed By Denise C
Great wings and pizza. My favorite is the white garlic pizza. You need to buy the xlarge to get the thin crist. Thats the only way i like my garlic pizza.
Where to eat Fast Food food in Phelps: The Best Restaurants and Bars
4. Torrey Park Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 113 reviews
Reviewed By yvonneb443
Seems like all weâre eating here in Geneva is Italian food but with the quality of the meals, who cares. Torrey Park was no exception. Recommended by the Mgr of our hotel he warned me the servings were huge (as seems to be the norm everywhere we go). So being forewarned we opted for the small plate meals. Alas, serving size was perfect. Hubby polished off his stuffed rigatoni in vodka sauce & my chicken French over angel hair divine. Our server, Mary, provided stellar service throughout our meal & made dessert recommendations. Oh my, the key lime cheesecake & coconut cream pie (both made in-house) were spectacular. Going shopping tomorrow for bigger clothes . Another great restaurant tucked inside a large former house on a neighborhood street. The GPS had no problem getting us there with no problems. Ample free parking. Highly recommend.
3. Cosentinoâs Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 303 reviews
Family owned business since 1996, serving classic Italian cuisine.
Reviewed By Choosyeaterfoodie
This is a popular restaurant, but with fatal flaws. Service was horrendous. It took lots of time for our waitress to get our order, but we passed this off as the business of the restaurant. We ordered the corn soup that came slowly, but was worth the wait. Then we sat and sat while other tables were attentively paid tended to. After 45 minutes we approached the hostess and told her of the wait. After a few more minutes our dinners arrived with a mild apology from the waitress. The Seafood pasta was good, especially the scallops that were done to perfection. The shrimp were slightly overcooked. The marinara sauce was just ok, it could have used a bit more herb seasoning. The veal ala Cosentino a combination of veal, eggplant and mozzarella slathered in marinara sauce. The eggplant was very good, but the veal was very chewy and the sauce too abundant. The side of pasta was not memorable. We skipped dessert, we had just had it. The saddest commentary is that despite knowing of the interminable wait, the manager never came to apologize or offer something to allay our bad service.
New York, United States Food Guide: 10 Bar food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Phelps
2. Uncle Joe's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 100 reviews
Reviewed By brandylei12
I got a pepperoni pizza and cheese sticks and both were very mediocre. The cheese sticks were probably the most disappointing not just because they werenât hot but just the breading tasted uncooked and like cornmeal. The pizza wasnât to my liking other than the crust I will say the crust was soft and I could have eaten an order of just that but the pizza left me under whelmed and made me wish Iâd just got out to eat or gotten a pizza from a chain. Really wish Iâd loved it like my friend did.
1. Nima's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By U634XYjeffb
Food: ordered two toasted subs and both were excellent. We are Clifton Springs natives back for an overnight visit and were hoping for classic NY toasted subs and we were thrilled to get what we had hoped. The bread was great, the meat was plentiful, and the sandwiches were the best we had in years.Value: around $7.50 each per large sub which is a good value. Well worth the money spent.Service: pretty average. Older lady who served us seemed worn out and overworked although they had only been open for 3 hours and weren't very busy. But unfortunately there's more mediocre service these days than service to brag about.Overall a great visit and I strongly recommend their subs.
