Location: Phelps
Top Restaurants in Phelps
Top Things to do in Phelps
Phelps Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Phelps
Phelps in United States, from Nouth America region, is best know for Takeout. Discover best restaurants in Phelps with beautiful photos and great reviews from traveller around the world here!
Things to do in Phelps
1. Parker's Grille & Tap House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 86 reviews
Reviewed By Thedevelopingimage
We stopped in Newark to do a little exploring on our way back to Macedon to turn in our houseboat. We passed Parker's Grille and decided to give it a try for dinner. We were greeted upon walking in and told we could sit wherever we wanted. So we found a table and a server came around quickly with menus. There are a lot of options on the menu. Anyone could find something to eat here. I ordered the lake perch basket and my husband ordered a blt. Our dinners came out hot and tasty. My husband actually ended up with the souped up kong blt. Food was good, service was good, Place looked clean. As we sat there people kept streaming in. Good experience.
2. Warfield's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 117 reviews
Reviewed By Ray S - Rochester, New York
Warfield's is a culinary exemplar of creative fare in a small town atmosphere. Offerings are classic, with emphasis on local produce.
As with any fine restaurant, dinner starts with house made bread. Their's was light with a salt crust, and served with a variety of tapenade.
They offer many starters and many steak choices. They have limited seafood and vegetarian choices, a limited wine list, but a wide range of craft beers.
Service was friendly and attentive.
3. Historic Phelps Hotel Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 80 reviews
1-315-548-5200
Reviewed By Larry F - Rochester, New York
It is time for a significant restoration of this old building. Traditional furnishings, non soiled and non smelling carpeting, a fresh coat of paint - these could make it an attractive dining environment. Now as for the meal . . . the dinner rolls were quite good. But things went down from there. My wife and I both had steaks. Her's was quite good. Mine was the toughest ever with much gristle. The twice baked potato was very good, but the main entre flunked. Our server was excellent, but overworked. We won't be back.
4. Old Mill Hot Dog Stand
Overall Ratings
4 based on 17 reviews
Reviewed By Faith P - Phelps, New York
The Old Mill is not just a hot dog and burger joint. They have everything from dogs to shrimp and everything in between. The wait staff is fun, friendly, personable, and attentive to detail. The owner is awesome, friendly, and professional. Don't miss the chance for a good meal and the most ice cream varsity I have ever seen.
5. Dunkin' Donuts
Overall Ratings
4 based on 6 reviews
Reviewed By Larry W - Rochester, New York
Yes, I know...ordering iced coffee on a night when it is 5 degrees outside makes little sense, but I still felt like having something cold anyway. The staff at this Dunkin Donuts location is friendly and make a good cup of almost anything. My drink was fresh and refreshing...thank you serving staff!
6. Nima's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 17 reviews
Reviewed By Stephen D - Greenwood, South Carolina
We grew up in Geneva and Phelps, but now live in SC. There is no such thing as good pizza (any Italian food) in SC. For years we have been coming home to visit and we search for good Italian food. Well, the pizza here is the best we have had in 40 years of being away. We tried all the old spots, but they are not the same. Nima's pizza only reached my stomach by first making love to my heart!!! It was 1970 again!!! Thank you so much.
7. Crafty Ales & Lagers
Overall Ratings
5 based on 13 reviews
Craft brewery on site with tastings, pints and beer to go options.
Reviewed By Kim_Sc0tt - Geneva, New York
The beers here are the best around. It has a wide variety of beer and there is something for everyone. Whatever your taste is stouts or you like hoppy ones, there is a beer there that you will enjoy. The place is so friendly. When you sit down it is like being home with friends. Once a new person walks in, everyone is talking with them like they were an old friend. If you want good beer and a friendly atmosphere, this is the place for you.
8. Kindred Fare
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 257 reviews
Kindred Fare is a Finger Lakes dining experience inspired by farmhouse cooking and spirited gatherings with family and friends. We are in the heart of the Finger Lakes Wine Region and right down the street from Hobart and William Smith Colleges. We have a private room that sits up to 36 people perfect for family gatherings, rehearsal dinners, wine dinners, corporate events and birthday parties. Join us for our happy hour in the bar or in our lounge Sunday-Friday from 5PM-7PM.
Reviewed By winedown186 - Albany, New York
We stopped in on a Monday night after a day of wine tasting. This restaurant was highly recommended by friends who are vineyard owners in the area. We were not aware that Monday nights are prix fix dinner specials (Salmon) for $35.00 which my wife ordered. I had the fried chicken and poutine. Poutine was excellent, so was the salmon. My take on the chicken was that it was OK. The bartender was very good, beer and wine list were good and since we dined at the bar we were able to partake in happy hour. The location is a bit oddly located but the space is deceptively large while being welcoming. Definitely worth finding.
9. Halsey's
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 362 reviews
Reviewed By Summersnuggles - Greenwich, Connecticut
Came to halseys after Andrews came against
U mass He lost 4-3 in o t
Got outshot 53-46 crazy game
Anyway the restaurant was as good as ever.
I had the Caesar salad which is excellent all the time.
Andrew had the meatballs which are famous on the menu and rightfully so.
Absolutely great. We spilt a pizza which was very good.
I had the scallops and Andrew had a burger
Great dinner.
Service was wonderful
Best in Geneva by far
10. Blue Ribbon Smoke House & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 44 reviews
Reviewed By Grangers25 - Phelps, New York
I have eaten here for breakfast, lunch and dinner. There is a wide variety of foods to choose from at reasonable prices. There is always a daily specials and soups. The service is prompt and friendly. There is also a selection of homemade pastries, pies, and etc. I have eaten here solo, with family and with friends. You won't be disappointed.
