Top Restaurants in Maui
Top 10 Italian food in Maui, Hawaii, United States
Best Italian restaurants nearby. Discover the best Italian food in Maui. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Italian restaurants near you.. The Hawaiian island of Maui is a destination for true nature lovers. The ethereal bamboo forest and churning waterfalls in Haleakala National Park can be explored via the Waimoku Falls Trail. Stretch out on warm, golden sands or hit the surf for an unforgettable windsurfing or snorkeling session. Driving the scenic road to Hana along the island’s northeastern shore will be among the most spectacular journeys of your life. Time stands still at the Hawaiian village of Keanae, definitely worth a visit.
Things to do in Maui
10. Pulehu, An Italian Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 753 reviews
Pulehu, an Italian Grill. Italian cuisine with a modern flair. "Pulehu", which means grilled or cooked over an open flame in Hawaiian language, offers Italian favorites cooked over an open flame. Let our chefs take you on a culinary journey during your va
Reviewed By nickthepackerbacker
We had a large party of 6 for dinner, all ages and everyone enjoyed their meal. The fettuccine was a hit as the sauce seemed homemade. The lasagna was amazing and a portion the size for two. Great wine list although nothing local. Beer was a nice local selection. Great place for a sunset as well.
9. Fabiani's Bakery and Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 882 reviews
Reviewed By emcee215
We only had pizza that we ordered for takeout. The pizzas are small and very thin crust so one pie will not satisfy a family. You'd need maybe 3 pies (or more) for a family of 4+ if you are hungry. Although small they are tasty and I loved the thin crust. The one with arugala, mushrooms & prosciut was my favorite. They aren't cheap either but overall they were good pizzas.
8. Ferraro's Bar e Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1614 reviews
Ferraroâs Bar e Ristorante at Four Seasons Resort Maui epitomizes every element of the perfect place to dine in Hawaii. Its spectacular beachfront setting is enhanced by Ferraro's open-air design, which takes full advantage of Wailea's warm, dry, sunny we
Reviewed By Joisey46
Yes, Ferraro's is expensive, but this is Wailea and this is The Four Seasons. The setting alone is incredible, dining watching the sunset over the Pacific Ocean. Fantastic service, extremely attentive, never rushed. Both our server, Madeline and the busboy, Richard, were incredible. The Burrata salad is delicious and was the snapper entree. It's worth every penny.
7. Pi Artisan Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 450 reviews
With spectacular ocean views on our Oceanfront Lanai, we feature Artisan Pizzas, Starters, Salads, Sandwiches and Pasta. We handcraft our artisan dough, make fresh mozzarella, grind our own pork & beef and create a wide variety of sauces. Our full bar fea
Reviewed By dtowne421
What a beautiful and delicious place to eat. The food - spaghetti and butcher meatball was outstanding!!! But donât leave without trying the Pi Dessert Knots - WOW...simply fantastic!!!! Thanks for great service as well.
6. Lahaina Pizza Company
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1601 reviews
Located in the former home of the world famous Blue Max Restaurant, Lahaina Pizza Company is a local landmark. The upstairs restaurant, located directly across the seawall offers stunning ocean views. Watch surfers and fishermen as they depart Lahaina Har
Reviewed By Christian C
There was nothing special about the pizza, in fact, it tastes exactly like a pizza from Bjâs Brewhouse. Took awhile to get seated and it wasnât busy, but once we got service, it was good. Great atmosphere though, open view of the ocean, sports on the tv and a really good one man entertainer.
5. Matteo's Osteria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1108 reviews
Matteoâs Osteria is Italian Soulfood in the heart of Wailea located at The Wailea Town Center. As the 2016 âAipono Award winners for "Best Italian Restaurant on Maui," we invite you to savor our healthy, locally-sourced, homemade pastas, pizzette & entrée
Reviewed By Judy3720
I have previously wrote positive reviews and this was our favorite hidden gem restaurant in Maui...have recommended Matteo's to dozen of friends. Last night, however, we were terribly disappointed. Table was in horrible location...a third chair was added to a table of two. We were exhausted from a long trip to Maui but were looking forward to a leisurely dinner for my husband's birthday. Bad table, behind large wedding party in cramped area. Appetizers were brought out within minutes of ordering. So rushed with bus boys hovering over our table and trying to take plates away before we finished. It was clear they were trying to rush us through service to accommodate long line of people waiting outside. It was nothing like we remembered. We agreed to stop after four rushed appetizers and skip entrees... 35 minutes later and $100 tab for 4 appetizers and one glass of wine. The entire experience threw us in a whirl of exhaustion. The check promptly left with us sans any birthday recognition. Mahalo...we won't be back.
4. Prison St Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 468 reviews
Reviewed By outdoorsgal123
Delicious NY style pizza in a unique, fun little spot. The Caesar salad and garlic bread was yummy too. With a local vibe, quick friendly service and mouthwatering pizza, this spot is easily our new favorite pizza place in Maui!
3. Pizza Madness Maui
Overall Ratings
4 based on 466 reviews
Reviewed By Sarah H
We were here over the summer and ordered a large Hawaiian pizza (ham and pineapple). The pizza was crispy, the ham was excellent, and they used Maui pineapples which made for one of the best pizzas we´ve ever had! The atmosphere of the restaurant is also nice. The wooden walls with weird artwork reminded me a little of Pirates of the Caribbean for some reason. It was just a casual, rustic place along the main road next tot he beach. The restaurant itself is indoors (don´t go if you are imagining beautiful views or nice patio seating). A great place to take the family if you are craving pizza!
2. Sale Pepe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 646 reviews
Reviewed By amn2117
Came here on recommendation of other hotel guest and already have passed recommendation onto others. Iâm from New Jersey where there are an abundance of great Italian restaurants. Seemed wrong to come and eat Italian in Hawaii as I figured it might disappoint but after reading reviews decided to take a chance. We started with burrata capprese. We each ordered one. It is large enough for 2. Was delicious. My friend got lasagna which she loved (she is first generation Italian). I got Maui cattle Guanciale di Manzo (sort of a rich bolognase). Also delicious. Pasta itself was great as well. Sauce rich and aromatic. Prices are reasonable. Service was stellar (Joe). They charge for bread but in light of reasonable prices well ok. However, bread nothing to write home about so I would skip the bread. The place is small with kind of a partially open kitchen, pizza counter and bar area. Cozy seating. Definitely make a reservation. They have pizzas which someone next to us got and looked quite good. Waiter said they do very thin crust but to be honest it didnât look that thin so if that is what you like you might want to investigate that further. We plan to return during this trip to Maui as it was that good.
Hawaii, United States Food Guide: 10 Seafood food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Maui
1. Flatbread Company
Overall Ratings
4 based on 2372 reviews
Reviewed By OnWings2
I have reviewed Flatbread a few times before but had to review again because 5 years after our first experience there this still continues to be an absolute favourite! The pizzas are delicious, the drinks are scrumptious, the staff is friendly and helpful, and the atmosphere is fun and relaxed. This is a wonderful restaurant whether you are travelling with family or with friends. For the kids there is the opportunity to colour pictures that actually go in the menus or play with dough or watch the pizzas being made or put in the big open oven. Everything is local, organic, and fresh. The salad there is sooo tasty and one of the best vinaigretteâs I have had anywhere. Made from scratch with pineapple. I love their fresh juices that have no additives, just straight up delicious organic juice. They are also extremely accommodating to any food allergies or sensitivities. Pizzas are creative and tasty. My husbands favourite is the Mopsyâs Pulled Pork. I love the Pele Pesto. I would eat here every day if it was an option. So good!There is only one small downside and that is that the bathrooms here were quite unclean on our last couple visits. However, because I loved every other aspect of the restaurant so much it wasnât enough to detract from continuing to earn them a 5 star review.
Where to eat Steakhouse food in Maui: The Best Restaurants and Bars
