Location: West Tisbury
Top Restaurants in West Tisbury
Top 10 American food in West Tisbury, Massachusetts, United States
Best American restaurants nearby. Discover the best American food in West Tisbury. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for American restaurants near you.. West Tisbury is a town located on Martha's Vineyard in Dukes County, Massachusetts, United States. The population was 2,740 at the 2010 census. Along with Chilmark and Aquinnah, West Tisbury forms "Up-Island" Martha's Vineyard.
Things to do in West Tisbury
10. The Barn Bowl & Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 185 reviews
Year-round neighborhood bistro & bar located in Oak Bluffs, serving fresh local cuisine at family affordable prices. There is also a boutique bowling alley with full food and beverage service at the lanes. Private event space upstairs for parties, confere
Reviewed By OnAir560676
Trip Advisor rated this place number one on Marthaâs Vineyard where there are dozens of superb restaurants. I thought âBowlâ in the name had something to do with food. Nope. This place is a bowling alley! It has five bowling alleys, a bar and a few tables for diners, but itâs NOT a first class restaurant. Clearly, itâs a place frequented by the Oak Bluffs locals, not a place that attracts Vineyard visitors. We tried it anyway. The service was outstanding. The food was average at best. Donât be fooled by this rating.Sorry to hear you had such false expectations of our business. I have to say, I find it really unfair for you to leave such a poor and highly inaccurate review about our establishment because you made a false assumption based on a word in our business name. We don't disguise anywhere that we have modern bowling lanes as part of our overall entertainment experience. If you read almost any of our online reviews, or visited our website, or even just googled us, you would quickly realize we have bowling lanes (10 of them, not 5). But the reason we are rated so highly on TripAdvisor, Yelp, and elsewhere is because our very separate Bistro and Bar (with over 100 seats) has become one of the most popular year-round restaurants on Martha's Vineyard. And it's not because we are (or perhaps are not) a first class restaurant. It's because we have a diverse menu that offers something for everyone, that is affordably priced - without compromise on quality of product. But hey, I guess you can't please everyone.
9. Waterside Market
Overall Ratings
4 based on 228 reviews
Amazing Sandwiches and Salads with breakfast served until 4:00pm. Now serving Dinner nightly 5:00pm to 9:00pm
Reviewed By Joe6strings
The Waterside Market was a great find for us, located conveniently in Vineyard Haven. We ordered a few cups of hot coffee and the Red White and Green sandwich - a delicious combo of mozzarella, tomato, fresh basil and balsamic vinaigrette. Perfect and recommended.
8. Chilmark General Store
Overall Ratings
4 based on 75 reviews
Reviewed By One_Big_Hopping_Dot
Their lunch sandwiches are better than their pizza slices. The quality is good, and the taste and the general prep are mediocre, and sometimes, above average. The taste is gentle, but, a few of them can be sometimes subtly pleasant. Chicken Bahn Mi sandwich $13 was festive but Road Race (Chicken Avocado) $12 was much smaller and boring. The soft drinks are $3-6, and, for the credit card payment, the cashier guy tore off the receipt and would not give back the transaction receipt. And, when I demanded for my copy, the nasty young cashier guy was annoyed instead of being apologetic and stared at us until we picked up the sandwiches. That attitudes cost them the tip. I love the hard working kitchen guys, I recognize for years, but, the owners tend to hire these inconsistent temp workers at the cashiers. After all, this is the summer business for a quick sweep of cash, I guess.The whole place is crowded with little children beyond control and few supervising parents. Imagine one 20-somthing mom with 8 children, running around the porch. The porch is very noisy and messy with food stains left at the covered porch. Idyllic it may look from the outside, but, it is very compromised unhygienic setting. The parking is limited and the customer's driving pattern is chaotic and often aggressive exiting the site. This is always the mixed bag. Not my destination, but, this is the last chance to grab a quick bite before heading to Gayhead beach. However, I found out , this year, Moshup beach parking lot now sells a cold water bottle at $1 if you wish to avoid this uncontrolled crowd and the overpriced store. I hope the owners of the store step up for the A game just like any other vendors on the island.
7. Artcliff Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 403 reviews
Reviewed By ppochiro
We arrived at 7:30 for a nice breakfast and got right in. As we were leaving around 8:30 a line was forming. Food was very good and service was excellent. Get there early to avoid a wait
6. Chilmark Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 126 reviews
BYOB Tavern Serving local grown + responsibly raised ingredients from farmers + artisan producers who share our sustainable philosophy in a warm inviting dining room. -Cheers from the wettest dry tavern in America
Reviewed By Frank H
Ate here with friends whilst holidaying on the island. All of our dishes were freshly prepared often with local seafood and ingredients. The cooking was often imaginative with some novel twists. Service was very good, efficient and effective. Noise level in the restaurant was high with hard walls and ceilings. Conversation was not easy. This is not fine dining and it is expensive, but the food is excellent
5. Plane View
Overall Ratings
4 based on 67 reviews
Reviewed By taftdev
Had just a short amount of time to eat and thatâs all it took.we each had a very nice bowl of clam chowder and we shared an order of chicken fingers with fries. Eaten here before and I am sure we will again in the future.
4. Little House Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 184 reviews
We will be closed from February 24-March 11. See you soon!! Open year round, Little House is a cozy Martha's Vineyard cafe and restaurant which uses local produce to create unique, exotic menu items. Healthy and gluten-free options abound with great salad
Reviewed By mercybe
An abbreviated menu of delicious food, reasonable lunch prices, quaint environment, and very attentive staff. It is refreshing to visit restaurants where the food menu has been so thoughtfully crafted. The lentil salad and lamb burger are two of my favorites. You can't really go wrong here though. I hope Little House Cafe is in Vineyard Haven forever!
3. Larsen's Fish Market
Overall Ratings
4 based on 420 reviews
We are located in the fishing village of Menemsha on the island of Martha's Vineyard. Open seasonally, we offer fresh, locally caught seafood in our market and from our kitchen. Come enjoy your food with us on the harbor, on the beach, or take something h
Reviewed By Jack M
On this trip we didn't have takeout, but bought a generous, locally fished piece of Sea Bass to have at our cottage. It did not disappoint. Historically, the takeout selection of cooked or prepared foods (e.g. chowders and lobsters) have been a pleasure to consume. None of the fish markets on the Vineyard are cheap, but the quality and freshness of the locally sourced seafoods are worth it.
2. Menemsha Fish Market
Overall Ratings
4 based on 239 reviews
Reviewed By wvillamil
Stopped for lunch at the menemsha fish market. Ordered a lobster roll with lobster bisque and a lobster quesadilla. Everything was good, hoped the lobster roll would have been a little bigger.
Where to eat Southwestern food in West Tisbury: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. State Road Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 330 reviews
State Road opened in 2009 in the agricultural town West Tisbury on the island of Marthaâs Vineyard. Our interiors were designed by Michael S. Smith. Michael appointed unique American antiques throughout the restaurant and called on regional craftsman and
Reviewed By CharlesA
We enjoyed our dining here. Started with the Serrano ham, and scallops and crab cake small plates. Finished with Trombette Pasta - local cranberries, english peas, north tabor arugula pistou, cheddar espuma.What an excellent experience.Alexandra's service was superb- thank you!
Most Popular Mexican food in West Tisbury, Massachusetts, United States
