Location: West Tisbury
Top Restaurants in West Tisbury
Massachusetts, United States Food Guide: 10 Bar food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in West Tisbury
Reviews on Bar food in West Tisbury, Massachusetts, United States. West Tisbury is a town located on Martha's Vineyard in Dukes County, Massachusetts, United States. The population was 2,740 at the 2010 census. Along with Chilmark and Aquinnah, West Tisbury forms "Up-Island" Martha's Vineyard.
Things to do in West Tisbury
10. Nancy's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1062 reviews
Reviewed By GMOAA
The food was very good, but the table service was very average. The hostess greeted me with âAre you eating or just here for drinks? I canât seat you at a table if you are just drinking.â That was her âHello, how are you? Will you be having lunch with us today?â LoL. She sat us facing straight into the afternoon sun with no umbrella or cover, so the view was wasted because it was so intense we actually had to turn around and face her at the hostess stand.
9. The Port Hunter
Overall Ratings
4 based on 292 reviews
Reviewed By JoeKupe
Owned by local guys who care about the local economy The Port Hunter is a great addition to the Edgartown restaurant scene. We were three for dinner and I had fabulous cod fish tacos while the other two folks enjoyed the Vegatabowl. Each dish was prepared very carefully and was very fresh. The food was delish but the service was at yet another level. The staff is attentive and everyone has a job. Our waters running low, someone is right on it. Dishes need to be cleared, again someone is right on it. Food coming from the kitchen, there are two folks whose job is it to wipe each plate and make sure it looks professional. Want raw oysters, there are two people at the raw bar keeping it fresh and ready all the time. At one point we were curious how low our waters could go before being refilled, they never got below 75%! And it was not to the point of being annoying, it was professional and very well done. They do not take reservations unless you are a party of six; we were three on Monday night and got right in, but we did see lines later in the week. We will return for sure!
8. Martha's Vineyard Chowder Company
Overall Ratings
4 based on 911 reviews
BEST CHOWDER IN NEW ENGLAND FROM YANKEE MAGAZINE, BEST CHOWDER 2015 from CAPE & ISLANDS MAGAZINE, MV MAGAZINE and winner of the 2015 MV CHOWDER CONTEST!! - Copper and mahogany grace our nautically chic dining room creating a casual-fine dining atmosphere.
Reviewed By Kristine G
The chowder was perfectly madeâright amount of salt, perfectly cut potatoes, perfectly diced clams. My husband had the lobster roll and I had shrimp cocktail. Not the best shrimp cocktail Iâve ever had, but not bad. The lobster roll was delicious. They have a really good bar with great drink selectionsâwines, beers, vodkas, and tequilas. Checked out the loft upstairs and it was hopping. We left to get Backdoor Donuts, but would return to play darts, pool, etc. Great place.
7. Offshore Ale Company
Overall Ratings
4 based on 860 reviews
The Offshore Ale Co. restaurant and brewery is open for lunch and dinner year round on Martha's Vineyard, with award winning beer and food, Offshore serves up good cheer and something for all tastes!
Reviewed By genwings
We walked by several mostly empty restaurants before finding this one. The place was hopping, the staff knew the regulars by name, and the waiter was very familiar with the food. My partner had a lobster roll that was recommended and it was a great choice. I had the special, skirt steak in a rice and bean bowl that was very tasty. Now I wish I had the recipe so I could make it at home.
6. Sharky's Cantina
Overall Ratings
4 based on 329 reviews
Quality ingredients, large portions, great prices and the freshest Margaritas in a 175 seat restaurant that is fun for families, singles, couples, young and young at heart...Open YEAR ROUND for lunch and dinner. This is where the Locals go.
Reviewed By MVresident
I always come back for my favorite dish here, chicken enchiladas. The service is fast and for me at 120lbs it is exactly 2 meals. Love being able to have it for dinner the next day.
5. Lookout Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 719 reviews
Called Lookout Tavern for a reason, the establishment has one of THE best water views on Martha's Vineyard! Overlooking the Nantucket Sound, the Lookout Tavern caters to both sea and land lovers alike. Known for it's amazing sushi, raw bar and seafood. Lo
Reviewed By Localgirl0330
This place is always packed- even at 5pm- so get there early. Nice views of the fishing pier and harbor. Friendly staff, no frills interior and delicious food. I went two nights in a row having their cod tacos the first night and the mahi mahi tacos the second. Both were excellent. Cocktails were delicious and the wine menu was quite good for a small place. Loud, noisy and fun, this is a cool place to come and one I frequent every time I'm in Oak Bluff. Great lobster rolls although I didn't have one this trip.Thank you for your review.
4. 20byNine
Overall Ratings
4 based on 167 reviews
We serve food to share, small plates, large plates, charcuterie and cheese, including the best Oak Bluffs brunch. Our ambition is to stand out in our community by making nearly 100% of whatâs on your plate from scratch. So please, gather around, share amo
Reviewed By JB M
Great bar, cocktails, and small plates. Was really impressed. Best wings I've had on island since Smoke n Bones closed. Bluefish pate great. Whiskey's and cocktails top notch. Great bartender. This is a place for adults and maybe large groups to sit a big high top or at bar. It is a small joint, so best to go in shoulder season. Loved it and wished we hadn't saved it for the end of the season.
3. Black Dog Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 803 reviews
Reviewed By alicew919
I was beyond hungry when we showed up...no waiting around 6:15. We ordered quickly. Hot bread arrived quickly, took the edge off my hunger.I ordered steak tips;very tender, very juicy! Mashed potatoes were real. My fussy husband ordered the garlic crusted cod; he pronounced his entire meal as âtopsâ. Well prepared.We watched the ferries going out and coming in; It is very entertaining to sit in this restaurant and watch the harbor.Pricing was very reasonable.
2. The Barn Bowl & Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 185 reviews
Year-round neighborhood bistro & bar located in Oak Bluffs, serving fresh local cuisine at family affordable prices. There is also a boutique bowling alley with full food and beverage service at the lanes. Private event space upstairs for parties, confere
Reviewed By OnAir560676
Trip Advisor rated this place number one on Marthaâs Vineyard where there are dozens of superb restaurants. I thought âBowlâ in the name had something to do with food. Nope. This place is a bowling alley! It has five bowling alleys, a bar and a few tables for diners, but itâs NOT a first class restaurant. Clearly, itâs a place frequented by the Oak Bluffs locals, not a place that attracts Vineyard visitors. We tried it anyway. The service was outstanding. The food was average at best. Donât be fooled by this rating.Sorry to hear you had such false expectations of our business. I have to say, I find it really unfair for you to leave such a poor and highly inaccurate review about our establishment because you made a false assumption based on a word in our business name. We don't disguise anywhere that we have modern bowling lanes as part of our overall entertainment experience. If you read almost any of our online reviews, or visited our website, or even just googled us, you would quickly realize we have bowling lanes (10 of them, not 5). But the reason we are rated so highly on TripAdvisor, Yelp, and elsewhere is because our very separate Bistro and Bar (with over 100 seats) has become one of the most popular year-round restaurants on Martha's Vineyard. And it's not because we are (or perhaps are not) a first class restaurant. It's because we have a diverse menu that offers something for everyone, that is affordably priced - without compromise on quality of product. But hey, I guess you can't please everyone.
Where to eat Southwestern food in West Tisbury: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Sharky's Cantina
Overall Ratings
4 based on 329 reviews
Quality ingredients, large portions, great prices and the freshest Margaritas in a 175 seat restaurant that is fun for families, singles, couples, young and young at heart...Open YEAR ROUND for lunch and dinner. This is where the Locals go.
Reviewed By MVresident
I always come back for my favorite dish here, chicken enchiladas. The service is fast and for me at 120lbs it is exactly 2 meals. Love being able to have it for dinner the next day.
Most Popular Mexican food in West Tisbury, Massachusetts, United States
