Location: Herkimer
Top Restaurants in Herkimer
Top 10 American food in Herkimer, New York, United States
Best American restaurants nearby. Discover the best American food in Herkimer. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for American restaurants near you.. Dominic J. Frank (R)
Things to do in Herkimer
10. Arby's
Arby's is a leading global quick-service restaurant company operating and franchising over 3,400 restaurants worldwide. Arby's was the first nationally franchised, coast-to-coast sandwich chain and has been serving fresh, craveable meals since it opened i
Reviewed By krb96
stopped for lunch at got it to go, ordered Jr. RB, fries and drink, left, started eating sandwich, and the bread was so hard couldn't eat it, why would they serve it, it was obvious the roll was hard. serve was kinda slow.
9. Asteroga Ale House
Reviewed By ernest b
Food awesome !! Bartender ruined the night her nochalant attitude. Refused to correct beer that was awful! Thinks sheâs their to be pretty!! Clothing inappropriate for food service. Did shots with patrons before getting check or to go boxes! Will not go back in with the attitude that she gives!! Your bartender needs a lesson in customer service.. short skinny blonde bad attitude
8. Miners Table
Overall Ratings
4 based on 23 reviews
As Herkimer Diamond Miners discover a grouping of diamonds in a vug - or pocket - they hit what we call the "miners' table". It's usually a place where they are always greeted by Mother Natures' many great finds. And, although you won't discover diamonds
Reviewed By capt38
While staying at the KOA, we had dinner here. The menu is way more than pizza & wings, and prepared on site. I would recommend the NY strip steak, it's huge and cooked to perfection. Our server was knowledgeable of the menu and very friendly. Prices are very reasonable, we'll be back!Thank you for visiting Miners Table during your stay at the Herkimer Diamond KOA Resort! We're so glad that you were impressed by our menu and that you enjoyed the NY Strip Steak that you ordered. We appreciate your feedback and look forward to seeing you again sometime.
7. Applebee's
Overall Ratings
3 based on 55 reviews
Reviewed By hlawlor24
Having previously worked at a different Applebee's my expectations were exceptionally low. However, the food came out incredibly fast, everything was good, and the service was awesome. My server Erika was really friendly and quick, and went out of her way to track me down when I inadvertently left my card behind. She was an amazing waitress. The restaurant was also very clean and the hostess was really friendly too. I would definitely come back when I'm in the area.
6. Jamo's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 50 reviews
Reviewed By Meditators
The worst meal I have had within the last five years. Ordered the grilled pork chops. My shoe soles would have been a better choice. Tougher than shoe leather. The salad was hideous. House dressings they say. Advise to the restaurant. Buy some Hidden Valley. At least we know it's a dressing. The string beans were inedible. What was that sauce?The service was slow and inattentive. I had to ask another waitress several times. Couldn't find ours.What a waste of good money with so many good restaurants out there. The dining room was loud and noisy. Terrible experience. Will never come back.
5. Denny's
Overall Ratings
3 based on 114 reviews
For more than 65 years Denny's has been bringing people together over great food. It's the place where people can relax and be themselves; where they can enjoy classic American comfort food and everyday value. 24 hours a day. 365 days a year. Here, you ca
Reviewed By toostie123
dennys offers a birthday breakfast for free,show your drivers license and you get a grand slam breakfast,your choice of 4 diffrent things,was great blueberry pancakes eggs sausage home fries ,,the waitress was very nice.not to many places offer this ,so thank you to Dennys for a great birthday breakfast
4. Pk's tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 29 reviews
Reviewed By STEBAY711
We traveled to Herkimer as a half way stop to our annual holiday celebration in The Finger Lakes. We decided to go out and eat and PK's was recommended by both the hotel and Tripadvisor. We walked in and were immediately greeted with "Do you have reservations?! We are full up with reservations this evening". Not necessarily a warm welcome. We asked if we could eat at the bar and then they said, "yes, that would be fine". I was then worried we would wait forever, but our salads came immediately and the meals followed just fine. We were glad we decided to stay after the cool (outsider) welcome as the food, service, and evening turned out to be just fine, very good. It seems they get flustered when they are nearing capacity, but there is no reason to make new customers skeptical about dining there. This is a duplicate of PK's Pub which appears to be the same place (same location), unless I am missing something...?
3. Waterfront Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 243 reviews
Reviewed By butch180
Rocky, the owner, was the chef last night. My wife and I were with one of the better chef's in Herkimer County. Former owner of Canal Side, and his wife.. We are both critical, because we both have owned restaurants , Forever. Rocky prepared a Platter, yes platter of Fresh Caprese. Onions, peppers, fresh tomatoes and unreal mozzarella, Buffalo, Surrreal. Dinner, he prepared us a Bone-in Maygu, Steak, enough for 4. Unreal/surreal and perfectly cooked, presented. Sorry, but we all " Pigged Out ". He must be one of the best Chef's in Upstate NY.
2. P K's Pub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 85 reviews
Reviewed By Dees20
I love the homey atmosphere of this restaurant. I had some sort of steak stew that was absolutely incredible.
1. Crazy Otto's Empire Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 305 reviews
Welcome to our original 1952 Mountainview Diner voted Best Upstate New York Diner. Best Atmosphere. Best Bacon. Best Hollandaise. Best Pie Crust. Now celebrating 65 years in the Mohawk Valley and once noted as the "most modern kitchen in New York." We hav
Reviewed By Sarsprdoc
Driven the thruway many times and always just use the rest area food courts but this time We looked for something different and glad we did. Eclectic decorated old railway car less than a mile from tool booth. Friendly fast staff. I had Belgian waffle and 2 eggs with sausage patty. The patty was huge and freshly pressed not some tiny precut circle. My wife had freshly cooked chicken sandwich with homemade chips. Kind of weird side of bread pudding but was delicious. $35 for us. Definitely worth a trip off the usual thruway fare. Thanks so much. Glad you loved our place.
