Location: Fayetteville
Top Restaurants in Fayetteville
Pennsylvania, United States Food Guide: 10 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Fayetteville
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Fayetteville. Fayetteville is an unincorporated community and census-designated place (CDP) in Franklin County, Pennsylvania, United States. The population was 3,128 at the 2010 census, up from 2,774 at the 2000 census.
Things to do in Fayetteville
10. Little Vince's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
Reviewed By charlieome
Found myself in a strange hotel in a strange town with no knowledge of the local atmosphere. The motel operator told me to try these guys I wouldn't be disappointed he was correct. The service was fast price was very fair, reasonable if if any delivery charge, I was very impressed. I only had a pizza but I'd be very willing to try anything else on the menu on my next time through.
9. Brother's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By CDRKMP
We heard good things about Brother's, so we tried them for delivery. Very, very disappointing!! My son ordered a meat stromboli... plenty of meat but the crust was terribly soggy (top and bottom). I ordered the Italian sausage sandwich.... WHERE'S THE MEAT??? I expected a 3-4" long link of spicy Italian sausage, not the bland little pizza topping size slices I received in my sandwich. Anybody know where I can I get a proper Italian sausage sandwich in this area???
8. Olive Garden
Overall Ratings
4 based on 110 reviews
Reviewed By LordThomMohr
My wife and I made our first visit to the Olive Garden at this location, and had a very nice dinner. Jhonzsie provided us with great service, the kitchen provided the delicious food, and all at a good price.
7. Cafe Del Sol
Overall Ratings
4 based on 90 reviews
Reviewed By Nihilator
Stopped in with friends for lunch mid week. They were steady. We were seated quickly. Service was very good. Items tried were the chicken basil chili and tomato gouda bisque soup, both were very good. The tomato gouda could have had a little more cheese and some more spices. 1/2 Ham and turkey sandwich, full turkey wrap were both very good. I tried the 1/2 grilled chicken pesto sandwich. It was very good, but needed to have more chicken out to the bun line. The house made chips and regular fries were good. I devoured the waffle sweet potato fries with a extra helping of the spicy dipping sauce. Those fries with the sauce are out of this world. Wish they would not up charge for the sweet potato fries. Everyone tried a small dessert shooter. They were very good as well, enough to finish off the meal. Overall a very good experience.
6. Benny's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 56 reviews
Reviewed By LordThomMohr
Benny's Italian Restaurant is our go-to restaurant for a fine Italian food meal. Pizza, subs, entrees, Benny's has it all. On our latest excursion into the realm of fine food, we ordered a Veal Parm dinner, and an order of Sicilian Meatballs. Utterly delicious!
5. Vince's New York Pizza
Reviewed By Neena B
We were looking for a place for dinner and this was just about the last place before we went back to our hotel. We were quite surprised and pleased with our meal. The small dinner salad was fresh and good sized. We split a stromboli and found it very good and plenty for two. Server was pleasant and attentive. Thanks to the staff.
What to do and see in Fayetteville, United States: The Best Places and Tips
4. Giacomo's Italian Restaurant
Reviewed By Charles Brian G
This is my favorite Italian restaurant! Many of the recipes are authentic. I especially enjoy the Italian Night dinners which are served on the second Tuesday of February, April, June, August, October, and December. One must purchase tickets ahead of time. Seating is limited to 60. At $35-$45 per person, I feel the price is reasonable for what I get: three appetizers, two entrees, salad, coffee/tea/espresso, and dessert. Water and soda are included. The restaurant does not serve alcoholic beverages, but dinners may bring their own.
Fayetteville Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Fayetteville
3. Ciao Bella
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
Reviewed By patrick m
On our way to the Winery on a Friday afternoon we needed to grab a quick lunch. We drove by this place on the way so we decided to stop. Not knowing what to expect we were very pleasantly surprised. Clean environment, friendly service, great food, and prices were very wallet friendly. We were greeted when we entered and our server was personable throughout the visit. There were 7 of us and we all agreed that if we lived closer this would be a regular stop. The 6" sub and soup combo was only $6.75. I had the mushroom and crab soup with an Italian sub. fabulous flavor in both. Rolls were fresh and tasty. Soup had just the right spices and flavor. One of us ordered the 10" pizza for $6. Crust was crispy and perfectly cooked. The fries were so good and portion so big that they had to be boxed up to go. If your in the area and don't know where to eat take stop here and enjoy the food while not hitting your wallet hard. They also serve beer which is another plus. I don't give too many 5 ratings but I couldn't find any fault with this gem.
Best Sushi food near Fayetteville, Pennsylvania, United States
2. Maria & Sal's Pizzaria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By kristin5133
We live close, so my family gets takeout from here a LOT! We have even eaten inside a couple times. We have now had most of the menu, and itâs all excellent. The homemade bread and sub rolls are delicious. The portions are large, especially for the reasonable prices. Wait times are usually not long, and staff is friendly. My husband loves the Buffalo wings in particular. Highly recommend!
Most Popular Asian food in Fayetteville, Pennsylvania, United States
1. Giacomo's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 49 reviews
Reviewed By joehebda
This is a hidden gem in the area and is worth any drive. The salad was excellent with shaved param cheese. Our dinners included: Chicken Marsala, Chicken Al Pepe and Veal Piccata. The food was fantastic very well prepared. Seriously folks you need to check this place out. Take time and make the drive. There are other menu items that I need to try, so I will be back.
Where to eat Japanese food in Fayetteville: The Best Restaurants and Bars
