Location: Fayetteville
Top Restaurants in Fayetteville
Fayetteville Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Fayetteville
Fayetteville is an unincorporated community and census-designated place (CDP) in Franklin County, Pennsylvania, United States. The population was 3,128 at the 2010 census, up from 2,774 at the 2000 census.
Things to do in Fayetteville
1. Giacomo's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 41 reviews
Reviewed By PennNationalRog - Fayetteville, Pennsylvania
Almost everything on the menu is made in house. Best meatball sub ever. Shrimp Giacomo is out of this world. Southwest Panini with Boom-Boom sauce came with homemade chips which were warm and lightly seasoned. Fantastic! Our waitress was always on point and made certain we were pleased. We will be back!!!
2. Inka Kitchen
Overall Ratings
5 based on 170 reviews
Reviewed By Lindaqvx195 - Bolton, Massachusetts
I wanted to try so many things on this interesting menu! I wish I lived closer and could return. The chicken dish I tried was excellent. Not much on the menu for vegetarians, but my dining partner talked to the cook and was served an excellent meal.
3. Flamingo Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 59 reviews
Reviewed By Dutch1638 - Fayetteville, Pennsylvania
.....ESPECIALLY if you have there pancakes! The blueberry pancakes are the best and biggest in the entire area.
This morning (6/24/2017) we took our precious bottle of Vermont Maple Syrup and went to the Flamingo for blueberry pancakes. We each had two plate-covering pancakes - at $4.90/plate, the biggest bargain in the area. In reality, we should have ordered only one pancake each - that's how big they are! Mrs Dutch couldn't finish hers and I forced myself to finish.
Never had lunch or dinner at the Flamingo so I can't comment on those dishes. But, their breakfasts are wonderful. As noted in the review of May 2016, the Flamingo is very popular and the servers really have to work to keep-up. Overall this is - at best - probably a 3-Star restaurant but the pancakes for breakfast is an absolute 5-Star, belt loosening experience.
4. Kenzo Japanese & Asian Fusion
Overall Ratings
5 based on 181 reviews
Reviewed By Lewis B - Shippensburg, Pennsylvania
This is my wife's favorite place to eat. We love it here, small, quant place. Always busy. The people that own this place always makes us feel welcome and right at home.
never had a bad meal here. We come here at least every other month
5. Meadows Frozen Custard of Chambersburg
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 24 reviews
Reviewed By bcwestvirginia2 - Great Cacapon, West Virginia
The turtle sundae is the best ever. They must toast the pecans - nice and crunchy. And the ice cream is delicious. So is the mango italian ice. We drive a long way to go here and it's worth it!
6. Montezuma Mexican Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 268 reviews
Reviewed By scottmpd28 - Martinsburg, WV
I was looking for some mexican cuisine while traveling down I-81 and found Montezuma conveniently located off the interstate with good reviews. We arrived around 630 on a Sunday night and were seated immediately. Waiter brought out chips and salsa almost immediately and took our drink order. Both my son and I ordered burritos and everything was very good. Only complaint would be that they could freshen things up a little as there was some loose and missing trim and things just seemed dated.
7. Maria & Sal's Pizzaria
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 18 reviews
Reviewed By Fulltimevagabonds - Chambersburg, Pennsylvania
Great food, clean, friendly and priced right. We love coming here, very large portions, everything we have tried has been great. They are very friendly and make you feel welcome.
8. Copper Kettle Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 258 reviews
For over 50 years the Copper Kettle has been serving the areas finest steaks, famous Prime Rib and seafood. Add to that the famous Copper Kettle Lounge and great friendly service, and you know why the the Copper Kettle is the area's first choice in casual fine dining.Come join us for a wide selection of food and beverage. Our private dining rooms offer you a chance to have a great meal in a secluded setting. Great for that special event or company meeting.We offer a diverse selection of fine wines and domestic and imported beers for your enjoyment in our comfortable lounge. And our non-smoking establishment offers everything you need for a relaxing evening
Reviewed By Linda T - Aransas Pass, Texas
We picked up dinner here--didn't dine in. It was absolutely delicious! And they got the order right! They only forgot the utensils and napkins. The salad was fresh, steak cooked to perfection, everything that was supposed to be hot was hot. I had chicken with crab meat and asparagus. Moist and tender! The kettle potatoes are delicious. They sounded a little disorganized on the phone so I'm not sure how the service would be in the restaurant, but I highly recommend this place. Yum!
9. Ciao Bella
Overall Ratings
3.5 based on 38 reviews
Reviewed By sunfired_ - Fayetteville, Pennsylvania
I've been looking for a place that serves Veal Parmesan since Olive Garden stopped serving it. What better place than one with an Italian name. The food was good, but not worth going back for. I was with my granddaughter and great-granddaughter. We were there at lunchtime but ordered from the dinner menu. The portion size was one would expect for a lunch, not dinner. What made it more palatable was that we had a coupon for 2/$20. Otherwise I believe the normal price is too much for what you get. As I said, the food was good, but not great.
10. Windy Knoll Farm Market and Creamery
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 24 reviews
Reviewed By William S - Fayetteville, Pennsylvania
Windy Knoll is my favorite local creamery for ice cream. A newly renovated deli/sandwich counter also offers good, affordable sandwiches, burgers, pressure-cooked chicken, and subs, too. Frequent specials are offered here in the deli area. The market is a superb place to obtain local fruits and vegetables in season. Baked goods, frozen foods, milk, eggs make for a good place to buy staples for the household. The people are quite nice to deal with always.
