Location: West Islip
Top Restaurants in West Islip
Most Popular Italian food in West Islip, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in West Islip, New York, United States. West Islip is a hamlet and CDP located in the Town of Islip in Suffolk County, New York, United States. Situated on the South Shore of Long Island, the population of the CDP was 28,335 at the time of the 2010 census.
Things to do in West Islip
10. Gemelli Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 70 reviews
Reviewed By W6386MUfranks
I went with my family this past Saturday July 8, 2017-We have eaten here before, enjoyed it and my daughter just recently bought a home about a mile away. The place was not crowded for our 7:30 reservation and we sat outside. We immediately ordered drinks and a scoop of vanilla ice cream for my 31/2 year old grandson requesting the waiter bring it right away. It took a good 15 minutes to get our drinks and i then gave my appetizer order which consisted of both the hot and cold anti-pasta and an order of baked clams. The waiter informed us that we should also order the entrees at this time and I said we weren't prepared yet to just bring my grandson the ice cream now. Another 10 minutes went by and the waiter came back to take our entree order again-Once more I asked for the ice cream-Another 10 minutes passed and the waiter again returned for the entree order-He was told again to bring the ice cream-My wife got up shortly after to talk a manager, a tall blond woman. She came back with the ice cream but with no apology. We were now at the restaurant for 40 minutes- The manager walked by our table shortly after and I asked what the delay was-She stated that the computer froze and the order never went in-No apology-Just looked at us like "whatever"-I informed the waiter to just bring out the appetizers we weren't going to order anything else-Another 15 minutes went by, no appetizers yet and we decided to leave and I asked for a check-Another 5 minutes went by no check and we walked to the front door where manager stated that there would be no bill-Still no apology- I thanked her and walked out-One of the worst dining experiences I've had-Definitely did not know how to make things right and placate the customer.
9. Primi Italian Steakhouse
Overall Ratings
3 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By Steffi818
Enjoyed a delicious meal with friends last week.Met early for drinks to enjoy the cozy seating in the bar area. Bread for starters is delicious & the olives and olive oil mixture is my favorite - don't skip the bread!The homemade papperdelle is delicious! They are a great place to host for parties and get togethers The only thing is when they are super busy the staff could run a bit behind, but I think they just need a little more training than the experience would be even better than it already was.
8. Monte di procida ristorante & pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By Insbro
It's too bad the staff doesn't know what is included in the Wednesday night special. It clearly states on the sign that any Parmesan dish for $ 14.50 including Pasta plus your choice of Soup or Salad. We were shorted our pasta as we were told it's either a choice of the three. Other than that misunderstanding, the service was friendly. I tried the veal Parmesan and my company had the chicken. Although the dishes were made the same way, Onion powder must have been added to mine and not the chicken. The flavor was a bit overpowering and turned a good dish to below average. The Pasta Fagioli was bland and I would not order it again. The salad dressing was good but over mostly iceberg, not mixed greens. The warm bread was a nice touch.Overall, the place has potential although I really think they should honor what they advertise. The ambiance cozy and quiet, but the food is inconsistent.
7. Anthony's Pizza & Pasta
Reviewed By rightfoot
While not the best pizza around, it certainly was good. I did like the friendly staff. Very helpful as this was our first time there we had some questions on options.Would most certainly eat here again if we wanted a change from our regular pizza joint.
Best Southwestern food near West Islip, New York, United States
6. Villa Monaco Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 58 reviews
Reviewed By Lant0ni0
The food is excellent and the wait staff superb. Several times I've been here and it's quality Italian cooking. It's one of my favorites. They care and don't rush and are very very accommodating. Nice warm atmosphere it's like going to a family for an excellent Italian meal. Linen table cloth and napkins-wait staff in tux. Not cheap but worth every bit.
Where to eat Diner food in West Islip: The Best Restaurants and Bars
5. La Famiglia
Overall Ratings
4 based on 92 reviews
La Famiglia is a traditional family owned Italian dining establishment. We're a Ma and Pa type place that is known for its tasty northern Italian homestyle cooking! We set ourselves apart through the high quality of our cuisine and the friendliness of our
Reviewed By sfbmd
First time eating here and definitely will be back! Food was family style and terrific..shrimp and steak specialty entree was very plentiful and good quality! Staff was very pleasant and attentive...fun night out.Thank you for sharing your experience on Trip Advisor. We appreciate your kinds words, and we look forward to seeing you again in the future. Sincerely,Rosario C., Owner
4. Mamma Santina Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 26 reviews
Reviewed By LongIslandMabel
With friendly service and wonderful pizza, Mamma Santina's can't be beat for help with supper plans! My husband and I enjoy a big chopped tomato and chopped onion pizza that lasts for more than one meal at least every couple of weeks and can highly recommend this local pizzeria. They also cook up great Italian meals liked Baked Ziti in addition to their pizzas.
3. Mulberry Street Babylon
Overall Ratings
4 based on 68 reviews
Mulberry Street has been serving Babylon Village for over 25 years with finest Italian Food and Pizza. The owners and staff take great pride in our restaurant, providing an environment and food that are of the highest quality and value. The décor offers s
Reviewed By johnkL3739AE
Looking for a last minute place for dinner, I pulled up the app and noticed the very good ratings for Mulberry st. Thursday is a complete dinner fish special night. Th special included house salad, seafood entree, coffee and dessert for $26The four of us choose different items scallops were excellent I had the mahii mahi my daughter in law selected a pasta dish of radiatore pasta in a creamy sauce made with Gorgonzola cheese. She loved itDessert choice was cheese cake carrot cake even a Reeseâs pieces cakeEverything was very good. With all the restaurant âs in the area this place has withstood years of competition They are doing something right, very right
2. Cafe Europa
Reviewed By Seapinesmiserable
The most professional and friendly restaurant in Town. The staff is just so nice, welcoming you when you walk in even if they are busy. They make great pizza, particularly the custom slices. They make excellent salads and always add extra dressing.Really well done.
Most Popular Seafood food in West Islip, New York, United States
1. Barrique Kitchen and Wine Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 132 reviews
Reviewed By Gergana L
I wouldnât go there again. My food was undercooked. The potatoes were almost raw. 3 times the waitress came to ask me if I am done eating to she can clear my table and bring us the check. I wasnât finished but she made us feel unwelcome and so I said she can wrap it up. A minute later she was back with the check. A minute after that she came to collect the check. I told her we hadnât discussed it yet so I would break it down for her by putting the cards and how much to charge each. She said she will do it for us - she came back with a set of bills that were split equally. I didnât drink alcohol yet I had to pay as if I had. Unacceptable service, food is not good. The only good thing about this place is the venue but that is not enough.We're very sorry that you felt rushed. We want all our guests to be able to enjoy their food in a comfortable and welcoming space. We'll be sure to talk to our wait staff to make sure this kind of thing doesn't happen moving forward. We thank you again for your comments, and we hope you'll be back to see us improve.
