Location: West Islip
Top Restaurants in West Islip
Best Cafe food near West Islip, New York, United States
Find out what Cafe restaurants to try in West Islip. West Islip is a hamlet and CDP located in the Town of Islip in Suffolk County, New York, United States. Situated on the South Shore of Long Island, the population of the CDP was 28,335 at the time of the 2010 census.
Things to do in West Islip
1. Brownstones Coffee
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By Alan W
The food here is extraordinary. Everything is perfectly seasoned... and plentiful. I had the Avocado BLT Benedict. The hollandaise sauce was rich and lifted with lemon, the eggs were perfectly poached and the home fried potatoes that accompanied it were flavored so well they needed neither salt nor ketchup. My fiancee had the "Little Italy," a flatbread panini of grilled chicken, roasted red peppers and fresh mozzarella. The chicken's flavor was actually layered, from the charred outside to a juicy inside to a subtle burst of flavor at the end. The cooks know what they're doing.Being lactose intolerant, I very much appreciated the fact that they have two dairy substitutes for their varied coffee offerings, soy and almond milks. The white chocolate mocha was a tad sweet, but was silky rich. I don't want to leave out the service. Our server, Tori, was friendly and comfortably informal. She seems legitimately proud of and knowledgeable about this place, which feels very homey, having almost a college town vibe. She quickly offered my fiancee a free refill of her ice tea. Even the music was right, softly in the background but nice classic rock choices. And to top it all off, the prices are quite reasonable, especially considering the large portions. One of the other couples there left with five take-out containers! This is the kind of restaurant we've been looking for. We're already planning our return trip next week for Valentine's Day, but both of us, each with dietary restrictions, are already considering which of a number of their offerings we want to try next. I'm a breakfast person, she's not, she's a lunch person, and this place is perfect for both of us.
Most Popular Seafood food in West Islip, New York, United States
2. Milk & Sugar Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 118 reviews
Reviewed By Michael0952
As soon as you enter the atmosphere automatically destresses you! This is an experience in excellent service with the food to match in a totally intimate surrounding of high back chairs and family time! My wife had the grilled vegetable panilli and as an appitizer we had the coconut shrimp, a total winner!
3. Tricia's Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 58 reviews
Reviewed By Lynne S
We went to Tricia's years ago and just never had the occasion to return. Too many other places to go to with a family. So we decided to try it again now that it's just the two of us and what a pleasant surprise. The cajun shrimp we had for the appetizer was so spicy hot but so good! My crab cakes were delicious as was the salmon. We returned a few weeks later with our son and had the burgers. They were fresh and delicious. They put a bowl of pickles on the table and there was plenty of our meals left to bring home. The restaurant is small and they don't have a selection of wines, just 3 types. But they do have a decent beer selection. I know we will be back soon.
