Location: East Setauket
Top Restaurants in East Setauket
Top Things to do in East Setauket
- 1. Bridgeport and Port Jefferson Steamboat Company
- 2. Avalon Park & Preserve
- 3. Benner's Farm
- 4. Old Field Point Light
- 5. Three Village Historical Society
- 6. Long Island Museum of American Art, History and Carriages
- 7. East Setauket Pond Park
- 8. Po'Boy Brewery
- 9. Hour Escape - Port Jeff
- 10. The Country Corner
Countries
Most Popular Italian food in East Setauket, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in East Setauket, New York, United States. Setauket-East Setauket /səˈtɔːkɪt/, more commonly known as the Setaukets (or that region's core), is a census-designated place (CDP) in Suffolk County, New York, on the North Shore of Long Island. As of the 2010 United States Census, the CDP population was 15,477. The CDP encompasses the hamlets of Setauket (formerly West Setauket) and East Setauket. It was founded in 1655, the first settlement in what would become the Town of Brookhaven.
Things to do in East Setauket
10. The Trattoria
Overall Ratings
5 based on 92 reviews
Owned and operated by chef Stephen Gallagher. Serving rustic Italian cuisine in a casual environment with an open kitchen. Our menu changes daily. We are a bring your own wine establishment and do not accept credit cards.
Reviewed By Pegamyhart
A wonderful quaint, little place that has one feeling as though theyâre having dinner at Grandmaâs house. Delicious prixe fix menu with interesting imaginative choices. Wonderful to be able to bring our own wine in, as well. Donât miss it!
9. Setauket Pastaria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 39 reviews
Setauket Pastaria is about delicious Italian food served in abundant portions. Owner Vincent Milano created this restaurant as a place to celebrate family and festive occasions in a warm and beautiful setting with attentive service that makes you feel at
Reviewed By IrmaG497
The outside of the restaurant is adorable, and so is the inside. It is inviting and warm. Our friend loved her Italian wedding soup, and the food was very good, however they refused to put a few pieces of salmon on top of our salad for a decent price. They wanted to charge us for a whole salmon meal. Although chicken was four dollars, salmon would have cost $21. Very disappointing. They should have been more flexible. We have never been to a restaurant where they didnât put a few pieces of salmon on a salad for a few extra dollars.
8. Via Pizza
Reviewed By Mfsnyder11050
My friends and I had a casual midweek get together. None of us felt like going out to dinner, so they suggested that we get take-out from Via. I took a look at the menu, which contained so many tasty choices, and ordered chicken francaise. My friends warned me that the servings were large (not that was a problem... so happy to have leftovers!). My meal was perfectly prepared, with the right amount of egg wash and lemon. The side of pasta was cooked to perfection, and I split a salad with my friends. The bread that came along with my dinner was soft on the inside and crusty on the outside. Thoroughly enjoyed my meal, and looking forward to not only the leftovers, but future visits to this fantastic restaurant!
7. Colosseo
Overall Ratings
4 based on 142 reviews
Reviewed By natashat996
âDOMINATING THE PIZZA/ITALIAN EATS WORLD.....IN EXCELLENCEâ.....If you want a.....âA LITTLE TASTE OF ITALYâ in Port Jefferson Station this is the ITALIANO spot to be at....This stop in was for pizza pick order for work....Makayla & Stephanie were friendly & on point....Success...in the bellies of co-workers breaking bread together.... â¨Long standing Primo Perfecto Business....If you havenât been itâs a highly suggested try....â¨
6. Pentimento Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 198 reviews
Established in 1994, located in the heart of Stony Brook Village, Pentimento Restaurant offers innovative Italian cuisine in a quaint & casual setting. Indoor and outdoor seating available as well as gluten and dairy free, vegetarian, and vegan options. O
Reviewed By natashat996
Filled with a....lotttaa....loveeeee.....*From the service*Appetizers*To the dishes *To family... *****a party of 14.... 3 generations of togetherness breaking bread at this cozy little nook of fine eatery....Embellished Appreciation-for the âChef Excellenceâ harvested into precise tasteful deliciousness....*Eggplant Rollatini & the Sword Fish were a big hit at our table....Perfect amount in serving size***Baked to Bella Perfection in my Rollatini*****When you feel the love in every bite you know the chefâs aim to please expectations were by far attainedMy first time & definitely not my last....~Absolutely loved my first experience & I know for sure it was a family loved experience~
5. The Pie
Overall Ratings
4 based on 72 reviews
Reviewed By rskdoa
Pie is on main street in the village of Port Jefferson. A family oriented establishment offers great pizza options with diverse toppings and three sizes. There is more than pizza offered heavy on the Italian influence. Always a good nightly special, all at a decent price. Service always quick and attentive. Limited beer selection especially tap. Desserts are heavy, very sweet and seem child oriented.
What to do and see in East Setauket, United States: The Best Places and Tips
4. Mario's Italian Kitchen Incorporated
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
Reviewed By Mora1234
We had cheeseburger, house salad, and minestrone soup late night at this Italian restaurant. We usually have chicken or pasta dishes and this was a pleasant surprise. Service is always friendly. This is truly a winner. We go here often.
East Setauket Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in East Setauket
3. Mario's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 89 reviews
Reviewed By tomc625
Havenât dined in or out since this restaurant changed hands years ago. I must say the renovation and decor is top notch. On this occasion we ordered takeout as its the closest Italian Restaurant to our home , just 1.5 miles away which means we could be steady customers even during those slow months of the year. At first glance the menu seems a little over priced but my initial thought was âif its really good than its worth it -better be anywayâ we kept it simple and called in an order for linguini and Meatballs which was close to 14 dollars and a Veal parmigiana hero at a whopping 14.75. Again I figured at 14.75 maybe it will be the best hero Iâve ever eaten so I went with it. It wasnât. First negative it was big on bread and small on veal and very little cheese. It tasted fine and the veal which was pounded very thin ,was tender , as expected after a beating with a meat tenderizer.There was just so little veal and cheese. Plenty of sauce on the fresh hero roll which definitely could use some oven crisping to give relief to its soggy stature.The linguini with meatballs was a much better choice and could probably feed two people with the bread included and 4 meatballs, yet it was priced less than the hero. Definitely odd.The meatballs were very good and the pasta was drained of any excess water , a big plus in my book.I hate to complain about price but for 5 dollars less the same hero can be had a short drive away and is a very comparable substitution. A family of 4 saves 20 dollars if theyâre all eating the same hero nearby. Food for thought and the wallet.One additional observation . When we called in the order I asked specifically if I could get get a side of grated cheese with the order. It proved to be a difficult question for the order taker on the other end of the line. Quite frankly she had no idea what I was talking about and eventually said âI dont know if itâs extra â . I did learn she was new on the job when I arrived so Iâll cut her some slack as she was very nice ,but management needs to train people that are going to be the first customer contact properly and thoroughly. Greeters and phone people can make or break a first impression . Put your best foot forward in this department. Canât say well rush back as it was $32 for a hero and a plate of pasta and meatballs but perhaps another visit for a special occasion , just not weeknight takeout. Perhaps thatâs the business model but i doubt it. Pictured - the hero .... but it really wasnât my hero this evening
2. Pasta Pasta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 252 reviews
Reviewed By riceball58
Oh my God.......this was great!!! Went to see the band (which was super great) - Three Kings and A Wise Guy. Now, the food............the food was delicous. The calamari and baked clams were yummy. Parpadelle perfect! Dessert -delicious. Service - great. Atmosphere - very nice. Looking forward to returning soon.
Top 4 Contemporary food in East Setauket, New York, United States
1. Ruvo Restaurant East
Overall Ratings
4 based on 265 reviews
Reviewed By ferryboaters
We visited Ruvo during Long Island Restaurant week because they listed a variety of menu offerings, unlike some restaurants where the offerings are few and predictable. We were not disappointed. From the steamed mussels appetizer, to a flounder and shrimp oreganata, to a berry crumble topped with ice cream - it was all delicious. (And the martinis and coffee were perfect, too). My review would not be complete without a tip of the hat to our server, Sadie, who was gracious and attentive. We will be going back.
