Location: Evans Mills
Top Restaurants in Evans Mills
Best Pizza food near Evans Mills, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Pizza food in Evans Mills, New York, United States. Evans Mills is a village in Jefferson County, New York, United States. The population was 621 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Evans Mills
10. Pizza Hut
Reviewed By donlin2015
Went to this Pizza hut and it wasn't busy in the restaurant but they were busy with take out and delivery. Our server didn't get our order right and when it was mentioned she just said sorry and walked away. We had to ask for the bill and when it didn't arrive we went to pay at the cash but she was busy on her cell phone. This is not the service we are used to getting at that Pizza Hut so we will give it another try later this month.
9. Original Italian Pizza
Reviewed By bighrt
20 wings for the Super Bowl Sunday game. This was my first visit to OIP and I will go back again. The original wings with honey garlic flavor was the bomb and so delicous. I recommend this place for wings but I don't know much about their pizza. If you are in town you should stop by.
8. Mr Sub Sandwich Shop
Overall Ratings
4 based on 11 reviews
Reviewed By BriggsDL
I've been going here since I was a kid. This place is legit pig out sub/pizza fare. The subs are huge, the bread is amazing, and the pizza is pretty bomb too. Family owned. Awesome sub shop.Do yourself a favor and eat ya face off here.
7. Domino's Pizza
Visit your Watertown Domino's Pizza today for a signature pizza or oven baked sandwich. We have coupons and specials on pizza delivery, pasta, buffalo wings, & more! Order online now!
Reviewed By MammaLax
We ordered delivery while staying at the comfort inn. We don't have a Dominoes in our town so I had never used their online service before. The way the website works is terrific. You can track your order: processing, preparing, cooking, delivery. It was great! Btw the chicken Alfredo was really really good! I would definitely order here again. I wish we had a Dominoes! Thanks!
6. Cam's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 93 reviews
Reviewed By Brenda W
Recently stayed in Watertown NY over Black Friday weekend. Asked for a recommendation at our hotel for a pizza place that delivers. Was pleasantly surprised. Can't say enough about the delicious pizza we ordered. Will definitely order upon our next visit to Watertown. Give it a try you won't be disappointed.
5. Art's Jug Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 113 reviews
Art's Jug at Huntington St., Watertown, is owned by the Sboro family since 1933. Four generations of the Sboro family continue to carry on the traditions and business principles that have made Art's Jug a highly popular dining destination in Northern New
Reviewed By Charles F
I really hope I can post at least 1 nice thing about Art's Jug but even the interior renovations haven't increased the customer comfort. Our first booth near the kitchen was so loud and drafty we asked our server to move us to another table. Nice thing #1 The waitress was more than happy to move us. I ordered the Sirloin Maison which came with bearnaise sauce and crab meat. The sauce was ok but there was so much shell in the crab I was unable eat any and I still have a bit stuck in my throat. This is the kind of thing the chef should be checking you don't just buy the lowest cost crab and slap it on a plate. My wife's veal Limon was devoid of any lemon flavor and her garlic mashed potatoes weren't warm enough to melt butter. I wish it was better we need additional restaurant choices in our area.We are sorry to hear of your experience. We will look into the crab meat with our chef. Please next time you join us let us know of anything that's not up to your liking while dining with us so we can have a chance to rectify your dining experience that evening.
4. Little Caesars
Reviewed By amlee17
So, it's pretty simple, you have a walk up pizza place. First thing that we asked of them was for a take out menu, as we don't usually frequent Little Caesars. I was surprised to find them scrounging around to look for a menu, they don't have any printed ones. In fact, what we got looked like something that someone printed off their colour printer with no pictures. Here's what I was surprised at, almost as quickly as we ordered, our order came out! WOW!!!! Who does that? In retrospect, I have to wonder how they did that, or whether my pizza was sitting there waiting for me before I even walked into the restaurant. We ordered:- Supreme Pizza- Cheese Pizza- Crazy Bread with Crazy sauce- Buffalo WingsThe kids enjoyed the Cheese Pizza. The Surpreme pizza was quite good but a little doughy. The mushrooms were cooked on to the pizza and kept falling off. This says to me, that the pizza was premade and the mushrooms were added later based on my order. The crazy bread was just garlic bread but the crazy sauce was a big bucket of marinara sauce. Epic fail on the sauce. There's nothing crazy about Marinara sauce. The wings tasted like salt and pepper wings that had been doused with buffalo sauce. It didn't even taste like buffalo wings. Based on my reaction to the food late at night. I will not be eating here EVER again. Sorry, but this is not a restaurant, this is just an assembly line that has no regard for their customers and their customer's enjoyment of the food. You took my money but I didn't get anything good in return.
Where to eat Sushi food in Evans Mills: The Best Restaurants and Bars
3. Domino's Pizza
Visit your Fort Drum Domino's Pizza today for a signature pizza or oven baked sandwich. We have coupons and specials on pizza delivery, pasta, buffalo wings, & more! Order online now!
Reviewed By Ronce73
So I got a medium pizza and some cheese sticks on Saturday evening. The pizza had very little sauce on it and only had 8 pieces of pepperoni on it with a handful of banana peppers. The cheese sticks were under cooked and still had dough on the bottom. Wasn't impressed at all.
2. Pizza Hut
Overall Ratings
3 based on 8 reviews
Reviewed By Grumpy O
The thing with this Pizza Hut is that you may get great quick eat-in service, but the next time you're stuck there for hours waiting.We were very lucky and had a great waitress who got our food right to us. The pizza was tasty as was the Supremo sandwich.You can find all sorts of coupons and deals if you order online to go, but eating in costs more.
1. Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 80 reviews
Reviewed By Quest757681
We were visiting family in Natural Bridge in July, and I hadn't been to Stefano's in years (after moving) so I was excited to finally go back! To say the service was horrible is an UNDERSTATEMENT. Short staffed, cursing staff, careless staff, and completely and utterly rude, staff. Every single item we ordered was wrong. Every - single - item. The waitress should have been dragged out by her rude mouth, the kitchen manager putting on a facade like he actually cares, should have had a swift kick in the butt. NO WAY TO DO BUSINESS. We were very patient, did not complain, and had to deal with her attitude everytime we told her what was wrong with our orders. Like it was our fault you can't get your stuff together? No. She WAS the only one waiting tables and they were busy, but just because your job requires you to handle things like this, doesn't mean to take it out on the customers. I'll buy a frozen pizza next time we come up before going back. I've never had service this bad and we've had some pretty horrible servers before...but Stefano's?Takes the cake on this one. Absolutely disgusted.
Most Popular Japanese food in Evans Mills, New York, United States
