Location: Evans Mills
Top Restaurants in Evans Mills
Top 10 Italian food in Evans Mills, New York, United States
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Evans Mills. Evans Mills is a village in Jefferson County, New York, United States. The population was 621 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Evans Mills
10. Savory Downtown
Overall Ratings
3 based on 65 reviews
Reviewed By Mike D
We ate here on Thursday Night and Friday night while staying at the attached Best Western.Thursday -Happy Hour 4 till 6 + $2.00 wine night made for a very busy restaurant. Seven of us for Dinner, served by a very flustered waitress who had difficulty getting the simple orders straight. She was still bringing side dishes when everyone at the table had finished their meals. The food was superb, huge portions and very reasonably priced.Friday-Two of us on a quiet evening, with Trey as our server. Great service, and again excellent food.
9. Original Italian Pizza
Reviewed By bighrt
20 wings for the Super Bowl Sunday game. This was my first visit to OIP and I will go back again. The original wings with honey garlic flavor was the bomb and so delicous. I recommend this place for wings but I don't know much about their pizza. If you are in town you should stop by.
8. Art's Jug Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 113 reviews
Art's Jug at Huntington St., Watertown, is owned by the Sboro family since 1933. Four generations of the Sboro family continue to carry on the traditions and business principles that have made Art's Jug a highly popular dining destination in Northern New
Reviewed By Charles F
I really hope I can post at least 1 nice thing about Art's Jug but even the interior renovations haven't increased the customer comfort. Our first booth near the kitchen was so loud and drafty we asked our server to move us to another table. Nice thing #1 The waitress was more than happy to move us. I ordered the Sirloin Maison which came with bearnaise sauce and crab meat. The sauce was ok but there was so much shell in the crab I was unable eat any and I still have a bit stuck in my throat. This is the kind of thing the chef should be checking you don't just buy the lowest cost crab and slap it on a plate. My wife's veal Limon was devoid of any lemon flavor and her garlic mashed potatoes weren't warm enough to melt butter. I wish it was better we need additional restaurant choices in our area.We are sorry to hear of your experience. We will look into the crab meat with our chef. Please next time you join us let us know of anything that's not up to your liking while dining with us so we can have a chance to rectify your dining experience that evening.
7. Olive Garden
Overall Ratings
4 based on 318 reviews
Reviewed By CMN14
While Olive Garden can't be described as a gourmet restaurant, it is reliably consistent, reasonably priced and usually quick to get in and out. On top of that, it has some gluten free options, which we appreciate.We each ordered what has come to be our standard Olive Garden meal -- gluten free pasta and marinara sauce for my husband and the minestrone soup and salad combo for me. Our waitress at this location was efficient, though she certainly wasn't overly friendly. All in all, it was a reasonably good experience and met our expectations.
6. Primo's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 15 reviews
Reviewed By William S
Just had take out from Primo's. Had a Delmonico steak with scallops. Steak was excellent and the scallops cooked perfectly. MY two sides were a baked potato and spinach. All this plus salad and bread for $31. That is a great deal. Everything is packaged good and as always it was service with a smile.
5. Fairground Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 273 reviews
Reviewed By stephanielou66
Have had many prime ribs, but, never as delicious as the one here... Was there a week ago to thoroughly enjoy one, and, going back tonight just to have another!!!!Waitress was great also !
4. Pete's Trattoria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 257 reviews
Reviewed By sherid981
Sauce is different, pasta is different, desserts are different. They try too hard to present the basics. This use to be my favorite restaurant as it was in my family's neighborhood. I believe many people will agree with me that growing up in the area, we had many amazing italian restaurants, this use to be the last great standing reasonably priced restaurant in Watertown. When i last visited the restaurant, , the gnocchis were terrible, the sauce was lacking and bread was hard. Every item I tried or could view from my chair had balsamic glaze on it...just FYI, I don't use balsamic on any item ...won't go back and luckily moved away so I can make my own gnocchi, thanks for the prior Pete's memories!Thanks for trying us and sorry you didnât care for the gnocchi. We actually retained the kitchen staff when we took over in 2012 and the recipe and prep cook have been the same for 18+ years now. We use balsamic reduction on 5 items and easily can be omitted if requested. Thanks again for coming in on your visit.
3. Muleskinner Dining Facility
Military dining facility open for breakfast, lunch and dinner.
Reviewed By jeffn499
Definitely the best on Drum. Very well stocked salad bar, usually good selection of entrees although sometimes things are over cooked. (Thatâs hard to avoid with quantities they are accommodating.) All in all a good choice compared to food court options - and the price is right!
Where to eat Sushi food in Evans Mills: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Pizza Hut
Overall Ratings
3 based on 8 reviews
Reviewed By Grumpy O
The thing with this Pizza Hut is that you may get great quick eat-in service, but the next time you're stuck there for hours waiting.We were very lucky and had a great waitress who got our food right to us. The pizza was tasty as was the Supremo sandwich.You can find all sorts of coupons and deals if you order online to go, but eating in costs more.
1. Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 80 reviews
Reviewed By Quest757681
We were visiting family in Natural Bridge in July, and I hadn't been to Stefano's in years (after moving) so I was excited to finally go back! To say the service was horrible is an UNDERSTATEMENT. Short staffed, cursing staff, careless staff, and completely and utterly rude, staff. Every single item we ordered was wrong. Every - single - item. The waitress should have been dragged out by her rude mouth, the kitchen manager putting on a facade like he actually cares, should have had a swift kick in the butt. NO WAY TO DO BUSINESS. We were very patient, did not complain, and had to deal with her attitude everytime we told her what was wrong with our orders. Like it was our fault you can't get your stuff together? No. She WAS the only one waiting tables and they were busy, but just because your job requires you to handle things like this, doesn't mean to take it out on the customers. I'll buy a frozen pizza next time we come up before going back. I've never had service this bad and we've had some pretty horrible servers before...but Stefano's?Takes the cake on this one. Absolutely disgusted.
Most Popular Japanese food in Evans Mills, New York, United States
