Location: Sylvan Beach
Top Restaurants in Sylvan Beach
Top Things to do in Sylvan Beach
Best American food near Sylvan Beach, New York, United States
Reviews on American food in Sylvan Beach, New York, United States. Sylvan Beach is a village in Oneida County, New York, United States; in the southeastern end of the Town of Vienna. In 2015, the year-round population of Sylvan Beach was estimated to be 892 persons.
Things to do in Sylvan Beach
10. Johnnie's Pier 31 Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 47 reviews
Reviewed By Bernie G
Johnnie's as we locals all know it, or Johnnies Pier 31 is a staple in the Canastota, Sylvan Beach area.a great view, A true family ran restaurant, It has a comfortable atmosphere, friendly and welcoming. Attentive service and the food is consistently good. A variety for all on the menu. You wont be disappointed and give them a try.
9. Gary's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 28 reviews
Reviewed By ssreca
I had Joes chicken sandwich and it was delicious!! My husband ordered a steak medium and it came out mooing!! He won't ever send food back so he ate part of it but left quiet a bit. The prices are reasonable but our waitress was a bit rough. We were seated by Jess who was great but our waitress told us how she couldn't wait for the weekend to be over & how tired she was. Mind you we were the only ones in the place ? I doubt we will return if we are going to pay for a steak it should be better.
8. Captain John's Restaurant & Tiki Bar
Overall Ratings
3 based on 30 reviews
Reviewed By snowball-6364
We were on the way to a 4th of July party we decided to have dinner before. We sat at the bar and ordered drinks. Served promptly and were great. We ordered Utica greens for an appetizer and the showboat for dinner which included broiled haddock, scallops and shrimp along with wild rice. Everything was delicious. Food was hot and Andy the owners son was spot on for service.
7. Anchor Light Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 29 reviews
Reviewed By melvinelpis
went to dinner new years eve and we both ordered the prime rib when food came my wife ordered hers med well it came out rare she sent hers back I started to eat mine had a very tough time cutting rib and was very tough to eat hers came back and she said the same that the rib was like shoe leather when waitress came back we told her that the rib was very tough she went over and talked to owner nothing was done we ordered derssert and while waiting we over herd another couple complaim to each other how the rib was tough waitress came back with dessert and my wife took couple bits and said did not taste rite almost tasted bad when waitress came back she ask if everything was all rite we told her NO the rib was tough and the pie tasted bad she left returned with bill and left we went up and paid bill to owner he never said a word to us never ask if everything was all rite or notWell let me say this We sold an 18 lb ribNo complaints!Sold tons of dessertsNo complaintsSome people complain for a discountSorryThatâs not how it worksAnd I do believe thatâs what happened here
6. Harpoon Eddie's
Overall Ratings
3 based on 77 reviews
Reviewed By shannalee29_NY
I came here with seven friends one night and I ordered the harpoon nachos. They would normally be an appetizer, but I make them my meal. Every time I get them people look at me like I will never be able to finish them. However I prove them wrong each time. The experience of sitting outside, listening to a band, and being right on the water with great food is awesome.
5. Eddie's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 114 reviews
Reviewed By Donna H
A very nice place. The ambiance is simple and homey. Everyone enjoyed their meal. I had the Chicken Pot Pie. I was slightly disappointed that there werenât any vegetables in the gravy but it was still good. I also had the clam chowder soup, that was so delicious. None of my food was overly salty which was appreciated. Our server was top notch. She was attentive and friendly. We will be back.
4. Captain John's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 71 reviews
Reviewed By JenK65
We have been here a few times. Besides the prime rib/seafood special (7 oz prime rib) , burgers or one other dish everything is well over $20.00 with most closer ton$30. Entrees do not include salad which is $3-5 more. They only come with 1 side. Food was good but sides were with the wrong entree. Waitress put the food down and left not asking if we needed anything. She didn't return until we were done. Desserts look good but $9-11 is too much for me to spend on a piece of cake. It's an ok place once in a while but be prepared to spend. 2 for 1 margaritas was good but they seemed to forget the alchohol as it did nothing to me. For the price I want fine dining.
3. Crazy Clam
Overall Ratings
4 based on 53 reviews
Reviewed By Dawn C
Went there for lunch. I had a cup of clam chowder and it was delicious. Nice amount of clams to ratio of potato, very tasty and creamy. I had chicken wings for my meal and they were cooked to perfection. They somehow managed to make the outside crispy the way I love them without being dry. 5 Stars on that alone! Husband had grilled Rueben, one of his favorite sandwiches that he gets frequently when we go out and he said it was the best one he's ever had. Now that's a pretty big statement because he has had them in almost every state we have been too. I am looking forward to go back for dinner. Hope it's as great as the lunch was!! Highly recommend. Our server was great and he was very informative when I asked him about various things on the menu. Wish I could remember his name because he was really great!
What to do and see in Sylvan Beach, United States: The Best Places and Tips
2. The Pancake House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 28 reviews
Reviewed By Brooke R
The selection of food items is amazing. The portions are more than generous! Everything is made from scratch, from the delicious home fries to the sausage patties to the pancakes (which are as big as a platter). The only problem is choosing which one to have. I had the sausage biscuits with gravy on my first day there and had the 2 egg breakfast with a side of pancakes on the second day. All of the food is cooked to your liking. The coffee is a real treat as well. The place is clean, the staff and the owner make you feel like you are old friends and treat you royally. The prices are more than fair considering the size of the meals. You could easily split the portions with another person. There were 4 of us, everyone got something different and everyone was more than pleased!
Sylvan Beach Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Sylvan Beach
1. Canal View Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 136 reviews
Casual Waterfront Dining overlooking Oneida Lake and the Historic Erie Barge Canal since 1977. Classic Oak Beer and Wine Bar. Our popular 79 cent Shrimp Night happens every Monday starting at 3. Choose from Cajun, Bam Bam, Cocktail, Scampi, Buffalo or Bre
Reviewed By jbd1529
One of my most favorite places to eat ! A taste of home,out ! Everyone is so friendly and welcoming . Jean the owner, takes pride in serving her customers with her very best in each meal .Her customers always come first. She goes out of her way to accommodate you . We have so many favorite dishes . My new craving is her Caesar salad ! I enjoy it so much . Her onion soup , eggplant parmagean and Mediterranean platter are a must try . Her cakes are fantastic ! Monday night " Shrimp Night" is a time to gather with friends and family and enjoy a great night out . Thank you Jean for serving our community all these years .
