Location: Old Lyme
Top Restaurants in Old Lyme
Top Things to do in Old Lyme
Countries
Where to eat Pizza food in Old Lyme: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Find out what Pizza restaurants to try in Old Lyme. Old Lyme is a coastal town in New London County, Connecticut, United States. The Main Street of the town, Lyme Street, is a historic district. The town has long been a popular summer resort and artists' colony. The town is named after Lyme Regis, England.
Things to do in Old Lyme
10. il Pomod'Oro Restaurant & Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
5 based on 177 reviews
Located in East Lyme amidst one of the most picturesque areas of Southern Connecticut and the Mystic region, il PomodâOro Restaurant & Pizzeria beckons Italian food aficionados with an intoxicating selection of dishes sure to tantalize everyoneâs appetite
Reviewed By Robertjcordisco
When people speak about dining out at an Italian Restaurant they rarely experience dining as if they were in Italy. The American influence has changed the Italian restauranteur to cater to the American palate instead of staying true to the Italian culture. Il Pomod'Oro does not waiver in the style that their heritage and customs have been instilled by the owner, Petrit. Their chef, Bruno, has brought his Italian culinary training to America for the first time in Il Pomod'Oro. They don't believe in sacrificing quality, their integrity is paramount to Italian country cuisine. It separates them from any other restaurant in Connecticut. Not one other dining establishment does what they do, the sacrifice is to great. The customer at Il Pomod'Oro is paramount. The staff is sworn to a dining experience like no other, this is the difference. They always make me feel that I am the most important guest in the house. There attention to detail is a benchmark in the industry. Wine Selection, food pairing, cleanliness, from outside to inside they are unrivaled. The menu creativity is what places this restaurant completely apart from a so-called competitor. If your not dining at IL Pomod'Oro once a week or twice a week you are missing the taste of True Italian Cuisine, I mean organic, farm fresh quality that is never compromised, never. Take a drive to East Lyme, settle in to the Italian way of life that one experiences in Europe. Bellissimo Il Pomod'Oro, Bellissimo!
9. Pizza Plus
Overall Ratings
4 based on 10 reviews
Reviewed By Chris H
Absolutely the best pizza on the Connecticut coast.We always start our shore vacation with pizzas from Pizza Plus. She likes their vegetarian gourmet pizza, with broccoli, eggplant, and fresh tomatoes, not just the tired old usual. He prefers the shrimp scampi pizza, a white pizza with delectable shrimp, lots of cheese, and just the right amount of garlic.However, this place is a genuine hole in the wall, crowded, no AC. I'm not even sure about their rest rooms. Take this wonderful pizza home and enjoy it in a better ambiance!
8. il Pomod'Oro Restaurant & Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
5 based on 177 reviews
Located in East Lyme amidst one of the most picturesque areas of Southern Connecticut and the Mystic region, il PomodâOro Restaurant & Pizzeria beckons Italian food aficionados with an intoxicating selection of dishes sure to tantalize everyoneâs appetite
Reviewed By Robertjcordisco
When people speak about dining out at an Italian Restaurant they rarely experience dining as if they were in Italy. The American influence has changed the Italian restauranteur to cater to the American palate instead of staying true to the Italian culture. Il Pomod'Oro does not waiver in the style that their heritage and customs have been instilled by the owner, Petrit. Their chef, Bruno, has brought his Italian culinary training to America for the first time in Il Pomod'Oro. They don't believe in sacrificing quality, their integrity is paramount to Italian country cuisine. It separates them from any other restaurant in Connecticut. Not one other dining establishment does what they do, the sacrifice is to great. The customer at Il Pomod'Oro is paramount. The staff is sworn to a dining experience like no other, this is the difference. They always make me feel that I am the most important guest in the house. There attention to detail is a benchmark in the industry. Wine Selection, food pairing, cleanliness, from outside to inside they are unrivaled. The menu creativity is what places this restaurant completely apart from a so-called competitor. If your not dining at IL Pomod'Oro once a week or twice a week you are missing the taste of True Italian Cuisine, I mean organic, farm fresh quality that is never compromised, never. Take a drive to East Lyme, settle in to the Italian way of life that one experiences in Europe. Bellissimo Il Pomod'Oro, Bellissimo!
7. Pizzeria Da Vinci
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By ANNE R
Asked for a white pizza with spinach---what we got was a crunchy, thin to the point of crumbling into broken pieces crust, with whole spinach leaves laid over a thin smear of cheese, then the spinach was actually burnt as if too close to the broiler! the whole experience was distasteful, nasty looking and tasted worse. We have ordered other pizzas from other locations and had issues with the salads--this is the last straw! If pizza and salad cannot be done right--why go there?
6. Luigi's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 183 reviews
Reviewed By Travelings5
We went there for lunch as there were great reviews. There was a large dining room to escape the heat. The food was delicious and the portions enormous-we ate our lunch for dinner also. Loved the bread, the salad and the entrees. Had great food for my vegetarian son, would very much recommend and come back when in the area!!!
5. Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace
Overall Ratings
4 based on 35 reviews
Reviewed By Skip W
Teddy's is decked out with Football (Soccer) Banners from around the world. His menu captures the favorites of Italian & Greek restaurants with pizza, stuffed shells, lasagna, gyros, greek salads and many more. Enjoy a meal and the friendly staff will make sure you will want to come back!
4. Pizza Works
Overall Ratings
4 based on 114 reviews
Reviewed By 301andyb
I gotta give props to Connecticut for pizza.Frank Pepe rocks and I had excellent gluten free pizza at Mondo Mondo in Middletown. Grimaldiâs in North Haven is quite good also.Pizza Works and Suds did not disappoint.And I have had a lot of great pizza in my life. In NYC: Johns, Patsyâs, Lombardiâs, Pizza Fresca, etcStaff was knowledgeable, friendly and cooperative when we inquired about gluten free choices and methods.It was great for my teenage sons and their friends.The pizza was very tasty.I would definitely go back.
3. TJ's Restaurant and Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 97 reviews
When you are here, you can enjoy dinner in our full-service dining room or a quick bite in our front seating area. Our selection of fresh salads, homemade soups, specialty sandwiches and delicious dinners are sure to please everyone's taste. Weather permi
Reviewed By BronxSteve
If you want an old-style Italian pig-out, this is the place., Charming decor, good service, with an Italian pasta, chicken, veal, etc., and pizza menu. After recovering from the flu, my wife and I needed a pick-me-up - TJ's hit the spot. Servings are huge - each one could easily serve two. The pizza is Greek-style - very nice. The Chicken Florentine was extremely tasty, lots of chicken with spinach and pasta.. Only downer was the wine - small selection, and only middling quality. Also, get there by 6 on a Saturday night, as the dining room is small. Otherwise you may face a long wait.
2. La Marea
Overall Ratings
4 based on 108 reviews
Savor the authentic tastes of Italy when you dine at La Marea. Located on the shoreline of CT in Old Saybrook, our family owned Italian restaurant prepares northern and southern Italian cuisine using a mix of the finest imports from Italy as well as fresh
Reviewed By jcharisman
I met a friend here for Happy Hour. This place seems to be fairly popular with the locals and there were quite a few regulars. At 5:30, 1/2 hour after they opened the place was empty but filled up rather quickly. Service was at lease good and waitress was fairly attentive. We only ordered a pizza which was quite tasty but not too different. Prices were a bit high.
Best American food near Old Lyme, Connecticut, United States
1. il Pomod'Oro Restaurant & Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
5 based on 177 reviews
Located in East Lyme amidst one of the most picturesque areas of Southern Connecticut and the Mystic region, il PomodâOro Restaurant & Pizzeria beckons Italian food aficionados with an intoxicating selection of dishes sure to tantalize everyoneâs appetite
Reviewed By Robertjcordisco
When people speak about dining out at an Italian Restaurant they rarely experience dining as if they were in Italy. The American influence has changed the Italian restauranteur to cater to the American palate instead of staying true to the Italian culture. Il Pomod'Oro does not waiver in the style that their heritage and customs have been instilled by the owner, Petrit. Their chef, Bruno, has brought his Italian culinary training to America for the first time in Il Pomod'Oro. They don't believe in sacrificing quality, their integrity is paramount to Italian country cuisine. It separates them from any other restaurant in Connecticut. Not one other dining establishment does what they do, the sacrifice is to great. The customer at Il Pomod'Oro is paramount. The staff is sworn to a dining experience like no other, this is the difference. They always make me feel that I am the most important guest in the house. There attention to detail is a benchmark in the industry. Wine Selection, food pairing, cleanliness, from outside to inside they are unrivaled. The menu creativity is what places this restaurant completely apart from a so-called competitor. If your not dining at IL Pomod'Oro once a week or twice a week you are missing the taste of True Italian Cuisine, I mean organic, farm fresh quality that is never compromised, never. Take a drive to East Lyme, settle in to the Italian way of life that one experiences in Europe. Bellissimo Il Pomod'Oro, Bellissimo!
Most Popular Italian food in Old Lyme, Connecticut, United States
