Top Restaurants in Greenport
Top Things to do in Greenport
Where to eat Pizza food in Greenport: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Find out what Pizza restaurants to try in Greenport including 1943 Pizza Bar, Brix & Rye, La Capricciosa Pizza, Emilio's, Marie Eiffel Market, Original Michelangelo Pizzeria & Restaurant
Things to do in Greenport
6. Original Michelangelo Pizzeria & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 83 reviews
Reviewed By bubbleheadout
Was in town visiting and ordered from there three days in a row. Outstanding pizza!! We had the salad pizza, white cheese and broccoli, and plain cheese pizza. All were delicious and fresh. The cannolis looked incredible but didnât try them....next time! Staff were friendly and helpful. Highly recommended!
5. Marie Eiffel Market
We are a French-owned & inspired brand with a fashion boutique on beautiful Shelter Island and Greenport
Reviewed By stirlinghouse
This satellite space opened this season in Greenport. It is a welcome addition. They have some very tasty lunch choices. It has a small dining area, and offers some of the nice things from Marie Eiffel's gourmet market on Shelter Island. Great soups!
4. Emilio's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 53 reviews
Reviewed By babs7512016
We were heading to the other popular pizza place on Main, but mistakenly went into Emilioâs when gps brought us here. So glad it did! We are fussy about our pizza( who isnât?), and everyone has different criteria. Ours is crispy crust but not dried out sauce, and sauce that is not too sweet or heavy, fresh toppings , especially fried eggplant. Emilioâs got it right on all counts including lovely wait staff. Wish they were closer to home.
Most Popular American food in Greenport, New York, United States
3. La Capricciosa Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 60 reviews
Reviewed By LollysLook
There are so many great restaurants in Greenport so we avoided eating pizza. However every time we pass this restaurant, the pizza smells amazing and the outdoor eatery is so inviting. Yesterday we decide to have a quick lunch here. We were delighted to find out the pizza is done in a brick oven and they have almost every variety of slices! The pizza was crispy, fresh and very good! My husband had the sausage and the pepperoni pizza and I had the artichoke pizza. It was amazing!!!
Where to eat Deli food in Greenport: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Brix & Rye
Overall Ratings
5 based on 30 reviews
Reviewed By Vanessa L
LOVE the pizza, salads, meatballs and cocktails here! Great place to have dinner with friends or a casual date. It can get loud later on weekend nights so I recommend going earlier in the evening to get seated. This is definitely adults only and I've seen people drink too much and be very loud.
1. 1943 Pizza Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 114 reviews
Reviewed By GaddisGadabout
As Greenport lurches toward rebranding itself as Greenhampton, itâs nice to know you can still get a good simple pizza. Although located in the upmarket Stripling Square, 1943 keeps it real with excellent pies, cold beers and good service. The menu has a dozen or so specialty pies with the option of building your own on a red or white platform. FYI, the fennel sausage is excellent. Pizza elites can still get their kale and what not. Caution, the pizza is served hot. The standard pies are 14 inchers, cut into 8 slices. Outside seating is available. Inside is rather woody and dark but will be preferable in the warmer months, kale and other trends.
