Location: Stuart
Top Restaurants in Stuart
Where to eat Italian food in Stuart: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Stuart, Florida, United States. Stuart is a city in and the seat of Martin County, Florida, United States. Located on Florida's Treasure Coast, Stuart is the largest of four incorporated municipalities in Martin County. The population was 15,593 in the 2010 census. It is part of the Port St. Lucie, Florida Metropolitan Statistical Area.
Things to do in Stuart
10. Casa Bella
Overall Ratings
4 based on 143 reviews
Reviewed By matthewsQ5239AX
Tired ambiance and average food (standard issue Olive Garden menu.). The server was a young energetic fellow that tried hard and was likable. He kept apologizing for the slow service from the kitchen and was in a tough spot. 8 top table and when last meal came out most everyone also was already done. 1 order was mixed up as well. I want to be fair here, so I would say that this place is perfect for a sports team victory party buffet. Not sure I would go there for an anniversary or special occasion.
9. Anthony's Coal-Fired Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 207 reviews
Reviewed By RandyGreen
Stopped in here for lunch with friend today. We ordered a large Mediterranean pizza. Very fresh. Good environment, good service, good pizza. Would certainly go back.
8. Mario's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 152 reviews
Reviewed By Chuck K
Started with Casino Clams appetizer and it was really savory. Just the right flavors in the sauce and in the clam seasonings. Next was pizza bread that was hot and crispy delicious and a house salad, which is not their strong suite, but it is tasty with the house dressing. For main course we had Veal Sorrentina. This combo if veal, eggplant and very thin ham topped with cheese in a Marsala sauce is my favorite meal and it is served with a side of pasta. So good! Took home cannolis for dessert and they were excellent as well.
7. Uncle Giuseppe's "Lil bit a Brooklyn"
Overall Ratings
4 based on 122 reviews
Join us and feel at home in grandma's kitchen!!! Full Bar! Thursdays Trivia 630-830 pm ,Birthday parties,Led Screens SUNDAY FOOTBALL!!,Catering,Free delivery, Come Relax and have a good time with us.. Ciao from Caesar and Giacomo
Reviewed By Jamison92
After a bad experience at a different local restaurant, I wanted to find a nice meal for my birthday. No stranger to dining out, or Italian food, we stumbled across this hidden gem! Not only was everyone friendly, but the food was amazing! Definitely can be picky with food as everything local seems to taste the same, however, this little hole in the wall blew my expectations out of the water. I personally had the Chicken parmigiana sub, I know such a generic choice, but this place has a perfect recipe for their dough! Even if you don't have any room for dessert, YOU HAVE TO TRY THE CANOLLO!!!! With this good of service and the amazing food, prices are probably outrageous, right? Wrong. The prices were beyond fairly priced and I still walked out with leftovers (not something I usually do). It was a blessing to stumble across this place and truly is the only local place that gives you a taste of AUTHENTIC Italian cuisine. Will definitely be frequenting.
6. Carmela's Brick Oven Pizza and Wine Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 280 reviews
Reviewed By ugonow4
This place is good, but not great. I would say it's a little overpriced for the portions you receive. Food is decent however the service is not. Expect to wait at peak times. Also they have ridiculous rules about their take out. Needs some improvement.
5. LouRonzo's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 158 reviews
LouRonzo's is conveniently located in historic Downtown Stuart. Enjoy authentic Italian cuisine paired with an absolutely amazing wine selection in our beautifully redesigned interior. Our professional servers will cater to your every need while the atmos
Reviewed By Shelbydawn27
My husband and I went here for our wedding anniversary, we made a reservation and were serviced by an amazing man who said he would take care of us and he did. We asked for recommendations on a sweeter champagne and he brought us a prosecco that he said would be good and it was spot on. He didnt try to upsell us on anything and wanted to make sure our night was special. Our food was cooked perfectly and was the best quality filet and lamb we have ever had locally and will be our go to restaurant for all special occasions for many years to come. It was a special night that they helped make even more special and I cant be more thankful. They made an upscale restaurant still feel loving and inviting. I honestly cant rave enough about this restaurant and how amazing the food and staff are.Thank you so much for your kind words. We are so happy that you chose us to help you celebrate your special evening. We look forward to welcoming you back again soon!
4. 18 Seminole Street
Overall Ratings
4 based on 217 reviews
Reviewed By Nancy B
Received a gift certificate for this restaurant as a Christmas present. So glad. Not sure if we would have found this restaurant on our ow because it is set on a back street. Nice menu. Really enjoyed our dinner. Would definitely recommend
3. Michelina's Restaurant & Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 145 reviews
Opened in 2008, we serve up a good homemade meal with the freshest ingredients. Dine under the stars in a romantic setting while enjoying the finest Italian cuisine Stuart has to offer. Our hours are 4pm-9pm Monday through Saturday, and we accept all majo
Reviewed By Richard G
Visited with 2 other couples. Took advantage of the Sunset menu which included salad/or soup, main course, and dessert. We choose the chicken parm, chicken francaise, salmon, and veal parm. All course were fresh, delivered on time and well spaced to allow for casual conversation. We never felt rushed and were often checked on by both the waitress (Karen) and the hostess. Their attentiveness was most appreciated. The portions were surprisingly generous considering a sunset menu and we left fully satiated. So happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! Hope to see you again soon!!
2. Luna Downtown Stuart
Overall Ratings
4 based on 340 reviews
Open since 1991, we are a "mom and pop" Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria located in the heart of Historic Downtown Stuart. We offer a Full Service dining room for Lunch and Dinner, as well as a sidewalk Take-Out Window for call in orders or outside seating
Reviewed By BillL739
We recently moved to Stuart and have been trying to visit this place for several weeks. We regularly go out on date night and usually a Friday night. Our visit was on Friday 7/19/19 about 6:30 PM. They do not accept reservations and we expected to wait for a table. However all was for naught as we were seated promptly inside in a comfortable booth. Our server was excellent and efficient. My wife had Eggplant Rollitini and i had Chicken Parm. Food was delivered promptly and was excellent compared to many other Italian restaurants we have visited. Small accommodations inside with several tables outside. We chose inside due to the heat and were very comfortable. The food was plentiful and delicious. This was a good time of the year to visit as I am sure the place is mobbed in the winter season. Thank you Luna for the great experience. We will return and look forward to our next visit.
1. La Forchetta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 613 reviews
Small family owned and operated restaurant, croweded and loud at times. Italian cuisine with a modern twist on some recipes. Gluten Free available Eat In and Take Out. Reservations sugested
Reviewed By 407loisl
Welcome to a dark and noisy restaurant. The garlic bread arrived quickly but the refill of the basket, requested 3 times, was never provided. Salads were small and sad. No crunch and no cheese to top it. The grated cheese was controlled by the server so they must be saving money. Trying to make the best of a poorly prepared meal. I can honestly say I couldn't figure out why the eggplant tasted off until I finally saw the black, burnt eggplant inside the dish. You cannot hide that flavor no matter how much sauce and cheese you dump on it. I couldn't get it replaced because the server was MIA. Everyone else was reasonably okay with their meals. The lasagna and manicotti portions were huge and take home boxes were required. Burnt food and a really poor server only got worse when someone arrived at the restaurant with whiny hungry kids and the server seats them right next to our table. Forget those high reviews. I have no idea what place they went to.
