Location: Puyallup
Top Restaurants in Puyallup
Where to eat Italian food in Puyallup: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Reviews on Italian food in Puyallup, Washington, United States. Puyallup, Washington (/pjuːˈæləp/ ( listen) pew-AL-əp or /pjuːˈɔːləp/ pew-AWL-əp) is a city in Pierce County, Washington, about 10 miles (16 km) southeast of Tacoma and 35 miles (56 km) south of Seattle. The population was 37,022 at the 2010 Census and the Washington State Office of Financial Management estimated the 2014 population at 38,670. Named after the Puyallup Tribe of Native Americans, Puyallup means "the generous people". It is also home to the Washington State Fair, the state's main fair.
Things to do in Puyallup
7. Farrellis Wood Fire Pizza
Overall Ratings
3 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By michael_smith56
Stopped in for lunch and ended up ordering two pizzas, a pineapple and Canadian bacon, and Margarita. Other than a salad, the menu is limited if you are looking for a vegetarian option. The Margarita pizza was delivered topped with congealed cheese and balsamic vinegar, some type of gritty red sauce and a sprinkling of diced tomatoes. The crust was alternately mushy in the center and doughy/gummy on the outside. Most boxed, frozen pizzas, as bad as they can be, are better than this "artisan" pizza from Farrelli's. The large pizza was $27 and a cup of coffee $3.75, so the grand total for one small pizza and one large, plus two cups of coffee came to a grand total of $49.16.
6. Round Table Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 24 reviews
Reviewed By QCao009
This is one of the worst delivery experiences I ever had. A pizza for 33.00 delivered an hour later, lukewarm, tasting like cardboard. I had called the restaurant back twice when the promised 45 mn delivery was exceeded. And the staff and delivery service were anything but helpful. To make matters worse, we live right around the corner.
5. Wicked Pie Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 35 reviews
Reviewed By April P
I recently dined at Wicked Pie Pizza. The restaurant is fairly small but clean, cozy and excellent food. The staff were super nice and even allowed me to modify a pizza for my dietary needs. Thank you for the 4 Star review. Glad to hear you enjoyed your pizza and the staff was up to par .We hope to see you soon!
4. Olive Garden
Overall Ratings
4 based on 106 reviews
Reviewed By IDW_52
Just returned from a Luncheon from your Establishment with 19 other People present. Was not very impressed with your Personal. The young Lady the way she spoke to the elder Customer was not impressive. My Waiter âRâ made the assumption since I ask about Garlic not to even order the rest of my Food. When he ask me for a Refill I said yes maybe half a Glass, did not get that either. When it came for the Payment with Credit Card he takes of with in his hand, kept seeing him walking with it. As far as I know, the reason the Screen are on the Table is so the Waiter does not take of with Credit Card. Was very disappointed don't think I will be back.
3. Casa Mia
Overall Ratings
4 based on 76 reviews
Reviewed By OldPilot1967
FOOD: a very good Mexican alternative for lunch. Fresh ingredients.SERVICE: Friendly and attentive wait staff.VALUE: A good meal for a reasonable price.ATMOSPHERE: the buzz of low conversations from couples, families and business folks. This is not a romantic get away; a nice little diner. We look forward to returning soon.
2. Mama Stortini's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 215 reviews
Reviewed By charlesodonnell
Food was very good and moderately priced. Service was very good as well. Meatballs were a little too spicy to suit me, but the home made sauce was great. Gluten free pasta and other GF options were nice to see.
Most Popular Pub food in Puyallup, Washington, United States
1. Toscanos Italian Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 140 reviews
Steaks, seafood, and pasta served with Tuscan style in a warm and comfortable atmosphere. Toscanos features freshly prepared Italian dishes using local ingredients . Everything is fresh. Everything is made to order. We feature the areas most complete wine
Reviewed By KTCO
Toscanos is certainly one of the nicest restaurants in the area. But food service was quite slow even for a Friday evening. I ordered the PORK LOIN INVOLTINI. The meat was quite tender and juicy but lacked flavor, the fillings really did not seem to contribute much. The meat was placed on top of angel hair pasta dressed with olive oil only, and all that on top of fresh spinach. I was expecting a more complex sauce. Next time I am in the mood for Italian food I will drive farther in search of something else.Thank you for your feedback we are very sorry to hear the Pork Loin Involtini entree was a disappointment. We have discussed your feedback with our staff and appreciate your comments.We hope you will give us another opportunity in the future.Thank you again.
