Location: Freeport
Top Restaurants in Freeport
Where to eat Italian food in Freeport: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Freeport, New York, United States. Freeport (officially The Incorporated Village of Freeport) is a village in the town of Hempstead, Nassau County, New York, US, on the South Shore of Long Island. The population was 43,713 at the 2010 census. A settlement since the 1640s, it was once an oystering community and later a resort popular with the New York City theater community. It is now primarily a bedroom suburb but retains a modest commercial waterfront and some light industry. It is serviced by the Freeport station on the Long Island Rail Road.
Things to do in Freeport
10. Sorrento's Pizza and Pasta
Reviewed By RedCamOp
Baldwin has about a half dozen different local pizza shops (I'm not going to even include the garbage chain pizza) and Sorrento's is the best. Its just your traditional pizza parlor, nothing fancy, but good pizza and heroes, etc.
9. Limoncello Trattoria & Bar
Reviewed By Tracy E
I am usually a fan of the eateries in Freeport however this new edition does not elevate the local dining scene. First a menu which was absolutely boring. All of the standard Italian American dishes minus creativity. Caprese, parmigiana, francese, blah, blah, blah...boring!I could look past the menu if the service was good. Poor service all around. My party of two arrived within the first half hour of opening so I can not blame the crowds. There were many staff members walking around however they still did not fill water glasses, ask if we would like coffee or dessert. Do NOT waste time or money at Limoncello....
8. A Touch of Italy
Overall Ratings
4 based on 32 reviews
Reviewed By Gloria W
I've been going here for more than 20 years. It is a family Italian eatery that we have watched grow, expand, and get better with age like a good red wine. Pizza is great,chicken garden salad is a fav along with caesar slice. The garlic knots are to die for and my kids grew up on the path dishes esp when they were young and picky.
Freeport Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Freeport
7. San Marzano Brick Oven Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 39 reviews
Reviewed By Tinyte13
We ordered out for dinner with family. When I picked it up the girl at the counter just stared at me and said name, not hello are you picking up, nothing. Waited a bit but in the meantime she refused to sit two people because the third person in the party was parking the car. Said it was policy that everyone had to be there to sit (there were plenty of empty seats) and the manner that she said it I personally would have left.Ordered the meatball pizza, the rapini and the Margherita as well as two calzones. Over sixty bucks which was a little steep. We served them immediately when we got home. Thought the calzones were a little watery although huge and tasty. The Magherita was a little too thin, but the other pizzas were tasty. Overall, don't think this is a place I must return to but had to try it since we pass it by all the time.
Most Popular Greek food in Freeport, New York, United States
6. Galleria Of Merrick Ristorante, Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 36 reviews
Reviewed By Wmjeagen
I love going to Galleria Pizza because they have a specials night and they make a great variety of pizzas . They also have Italian Ices, cannoli and for the diet conscious delicious salads. When my family goes there we always run into someone we know so you know it has to be good
Most Popular Diner food in Freeport, New York, United States
5. Novi
Overall Ratings
4 based on 23 reviews
Looking for a spot to enjoy appetizers, drinks or a hearty dinner? Our NOVI Lunch, Dinner and Drink Menus boast something for everyone! Having a party or need a venue for your next event? We do on & off premise catering! â From pizzas to pastas to seafood
Reviewed By jamessG1695IR
I was originally from Baldwin and remember the old Venice Inn with its white tablecloths and subdued pink fluorescent lights edging the ceiling. The pizza crust was thin and you could easily fold it. I went back to what is now NOVI. The white tablecloths are gone as is the lighting. However, the restaurant and its food are still good. We were there for lunch. We shared an order of calamari which was plenty for 4 people. It could have been seasoned a bit more. We shared the white pizza which had no sauce but was ricotta, mozzarella and plenty of garlic. This was delicious. They also had several other pizza and Italian dishes available. The service was good and the staff was friendly and attentive.
4. Umberto's Pizzeria and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 91 reviews
Reviewed By atv76
We stopped by umbertos a few weeks ago before seeing a movie /sunday â¦.We had the pizza which was excellent ...We decided to come back the following week on Saturday for a formal dinner ..it was a disaster...When we arrived it was crowded and there was no-one to take your reservation..All the workers were busy attending to their tables ..Finally a fellow came over I think he was the owner..he kept shaking my hand..When we were seated we ordered a margarita pizza which came out after 8 minutes...but I had ordered off their takeout menu the manager told me the order would be no problem-veal/milenese which is fried veal with bruschetta,onions ,olive oil,and arugala salad @balsamic oil...It took them about 40-minutes to bring my dinner-out..However they forgot to include the toppings(bruschetta,onions,olive-oil,arugala on the veal..The manager by the way took the plate back and I could see him directing the chefs /rather young on how to complete this dinner..I should mention since it was busy the manager had been serving us and he kept shaking my hand and trying to explain when something wrong+but his English was not very good...The problem seemed to be that the chefs/owner didn't know their own menu..I will add that the margarita pizza was good although when the mgr ask my lady if she wanted parmesan cheese on her pizza she said no and he gave her extra parmesan....I would say if you go to umbertos in bellmore get the pizza but for a formal dinner be careful !!!! Ive been to umbertos in newhyde park which is a first cabin restaurant....The Bellmore manager didn't even apologize for the mistakes or offer a dessertor drink on the house..amazingâ¦...
3. La Strada Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 82 reviews
Reviewed By thetraveler002
Went on a Friday nite without reservations but next time will make them. By the time we (2 couples) left, the restaurant was packed. Arrived at 6PM for a Birthday celebration dinner with friends. We each ordered something different. Got to taste my husband' s entrée of eggplant parm with lots of vegetables and side dish of linguine with (had to be) homemade sauce. So glad we took leftovers home - just as good the next day for lunch. I ordered the Lobster Ravioli, topped with a basil creamy sauce and small shrimp. Very good but no accompanying salad, although the entrée itself was filling. Our friends ordered Chicken Parm and something LaStrada. They enjoyed their meal but didn't offer to share. Oh well! Neither did I! We each had a nice size wine glass of Chianti. Very good. Too full for dessert, maybe next time. Prices seemed reasonable but hey we didn't pay. Would definitely return and order something else scrumptious from their menu.
Best Mediterranean food near Freeport, New York, United States
2. Raimo's Pizza & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 35 reviews
Reviewed By 374samm
Came here with family and friends food excellent and we'll presented. Staff friendly and helpful would definitely recommend to others pizzas a treat plenty to pick from you will not be disappointed.
Where to eat Seafood food in Freeport: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. La Parma III Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 72 reviews
Reviewed By maries939
We have been coming to La Parma (all three of them) for many years. The one in Woodbury is our favorite but we decided to try again the LaParma 111 because it was closer to our friends houses. The food was good, plentiful and served with a smile. Definitely family style and LOTS of garlic, but I like that! It is noisy, crowded and good for large family gatherings.
