Top Restaurants in Middletown
Where to eat American food in Middletown: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best American food in Middletown, New York, United States including Quickway Diner, MIX N MAC - MAC & Cheese, The Olde Erie Pub, Holydog, Texas Roadhouse, Americana Diner, Outback Steakhouse, Clemson Bros. Brewery, Colonial Diner, Copper Barn
Things to do in Middletown
10. Copper Barn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 29 reviews
Reviewed By WadeandLori
Found a number of good items on the menu. Appetizers, small plates and large plates were offered for dinner. Everything we ordered seemed fresh and tasty. Only item we questioned was why there was an extra charge for refills on iced tea. Seemed unusual.
9. Colonial Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 63 reviews
Reviewed By neonmomf
Went here for lunch, it was a local dinner which seemed small but had nice amount of room inside. Parking was good seemed like could park around dinner. It had a ramp if needed for handicapped. Service was great, was seated right away, our waitress Rosawas patience, made suggestions and was helpful. Homemade French Onion soup was not bad, actually for a dinner I thought was pretty good. Salads were generous and specials seemed reasonably priced with good amount of food. Also was flexible for substitutions.
8. Clemson Bros. Brewery
Overall Ratings
4 based on 67 reviews
Reviewed By Noreen M
Clemson Bros. Brewery is located in a gorgeous building in the industrial area of Middletown. Their logo indicates that they have been around since 2012. They did a wonderful job renovating the former factory. Seems like they have a significant amount of property, because they have a large "Beer Garden" outdoor area. We were in the area and stopped for lunch because they advertise on the local TV channel. The waitstaff were helpful and laid back. They could have been slightly more attentive as we had to request silverware after our meal was served. I had the chicken wings - Sesame Thai flavor as an app. They were awesome! My companion had the pierogis and loved them. They were prepared beautifully and he really enjoyed them with the sour cream and mustard sauces. I had a great burger - it was called the "Big Bad Wolf" and featured bacon and ham and smoked gouda. It was huge and delicious. The truffle fries were amazing. The grilled cheese on marble rye with onions was very good too. They have a good beer menu that explains and describes their beverages well including the alcohol contend AND the bitterness rating which is important to me. Their beer menu lists all their beers and they have posted menu above the bar which lists what is currently available on tap. If you can't decide what to drink, they offer beer flights so you can sample a few and decide. Overall, we had an enjoyable time.
7. Outback Steakhouse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 188 reviews
Reviewed By irisb781
We love outback. Their caesar salad is fantastic. We love their onion soup and sweet potato. No matter you order, you won't be disappointed. The manager of the outback in Middletown, NY is great. She goes to all the tables to make sure everything is oik. We highly recommend eating in Outback
6. Americana Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 126 reviews
Reviewed By retiredandtraveling5
Whenever Iâm in Middletown looking for a great breakfast, reasonably priced, I always end up at the Americana where coffee refills are always offered! Omelettes and breakfast specials are delicious and great deals.They also have great lunch specials and tasty soups... a cup of their matzah ball soup is always very satisfying and their sandwiches are great!NOTE: most of the menu allows you to take a senior discount of 10% off the bill when you pay.
5. Texas Roadhouse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 200 reviews
Reviewed By Mje12518
We have visited several Texas Roadhouse (TRH) restaurants primarily in FL, VA, NY/NJ. We find the menu selection good, appetizers tasty, hamburgers above average, hand-cut steaks good (but not as flavorful as Longhorn) and server friendliness better than most.We were in the area visiting friends and were passing thru the Middletown area and stopped here for a quick dinner.We were surprised that two normal items were ignored, the peanuts and bread. No big deal, but a slip from expectations. Our appetizers were unusually greasy, compared to normal TRH fare. Our burgers were good but for some reason tasted below normal standards.We might have caught them on a bad night, or with a less experienced chef, but based on this visit I only feel Average applies, not "very good"
4. Holydog
Overall Ratings
4 based on 51 reviews
Reviewed By mrobin66
It's been awhile since I've been here but the hot dogs are really good. So many different ways to make a hot dog. The owner is also very pleasant.
3. The Olde Erie Pub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 162 reviews
Reviewed By Nhd106
My friend and I have been here many times with both family and coworkers (from Catholic Charities). While food was fine we were SHOCKED that they overcharged for a drink after quoting a price to our waiter. He told us $5.50 and then asked âon the rocks?â She said âWhy notâ. The bill came and it was $9.00! He tried 3x to have Maria honor the quoted price but she wouldnât budge! Apparently adding ice, also makes them add more alcohol which we we not told. Unbelievable! A great night ruined by a nasty cheap manager. We will never ever return and will continue to tell everyone about this stupidity.
2. MIX N MAC - MAC & Cheese
Overall Ratings
4 based on 164 reviews
WE love MAC & Cheese! What could be more comforting than our over 35 varieties of custom baked gourmet creamy MAC & Cheese creations! Mix it your way with your own ingredients or just try our Fresh deep fried MAC & Cheese Balls with our tomato cream dippi
Reviewed By amyfaltraco
My step daughter and her husband just had this at their wedding. Everyone LOVED it! A huge thank you to the staff as well. After a mix up on our end, they came through and delivered for our event on short notice. Thank you so much! Cant wait to try this again when we come back to town!
1. Quickway Diner
Overall Ratings
3 based on 106 reviews
Never miss your breakfast! Grab a yummy sandwich from Quickway Diner while you're on your way to work in the morning. Voted 'Best Diner', we have received accolades for our coffees, soups, breakfast and lunch specials. Visit our local and family-owned res
Reviewed By Steve G
Having eaten there a few times before, we found on the last visit subpar service and mediocre for. Waitress called everyone honey (sorry not for me) a nd items were left off the order.I'm sorry that the service was subpar and you took offence that she calls everyone one honey. Do you remember who waited on you not sure if she was having an off day. I would love for you to give us another try sine you have eaten here a few times. Thank you
