Location: Middlebury
Top Restaurants in Middlebury
Countries
Where to eat American food in Middlebury: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best American food in Middlebury, Connecticut, United States. Middlebury is a town in New Haven County, Connecticut, United States. The population was 7,575 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Middlebury
10. 121 Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 189 reviews
Reviewed By Ira K
We went with family (and 2, 5 year olds ) for lunch after an event at the Oxford airport and waited over an hour for our food to be served, then one person in our party did not get their order. The wait staff was ok, but the kitchen must have been under staffed even though they knew an event was going on.The food was overcooked and the coffee was cold when I got it. They should have made a bigger attempt to, at least, feed the children firstThe food is over priced for what you get.
9. Pies and pints
Overall Ratings
3 based on 77 reviews
Reviewed By Katey G
Pies and Pints makes our favorite pizza anywhere around. The only complaint I have is about the service. I have had a few encounters there with staff who were slow, rude, or made mistakes and then seemed annoyed at correcting them. The food is excellent, and prices are good. Wish they had delivery service (or maybe it's good for my waste-line that they don't!).
8. Good News Restaurant and Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 327 reviews
Good News Restaurant and Bar is one of the trailblazers in the Farm-to-Table movement. Our mission is to help people reconnect to their local land, as well as to the farmers and artisans who tend them. We continue that tradition by partnering with local f
Reviewed By paulatL5767AZ
My go-to-place for any celebration ........... even by myself. Excellent food and drink! You must try the crab taco appetizer. The lobster mac and cheese is the best. You wonât go wrong with any dessert.......... my favorite is the Bridgewater chocolate to-go after such a wonderful meal!
7. Spartan Pizza & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 83 reviews
Reviewed By ParkerSturbridge
This place has consistently good food and very good prices. Service is super friendly and efficient, but the place really needs a makeover. Dark, drab and almost uninviting....but very clean!!! So don't let the decor turn you off. Greek style pizza, thick crust, crusty on the bottom, somewhat over-cheesed. But when you order a topping, you get plenty. Salads are delicious and very large, with lots of extras on them, not just lettuce. And the burgers are huge and come with some of the best onion rings around. In-town people....you know where it is. Out-of-towners, stop in...i'ts right off I-84 and will fuel you up for your long wait in traffic at the Waterbury interchange. Check it out.
6. Middlebury Consignment Shop
Overall Ratings
4 based on 67 reviews
Vyne restaurant & bar in Middlebury CT offers you a fine dining experience like no other in Connecticut. Whether on our outdoor patio near the waterfalls, in our gorgeous barroom on in the dining room at our Chef's Counter, Vyne will become one of your fa
Reviewed By clh1209
Friday night dinner with several friends. Overall a nice evening but the restaurant was so loud everyone had to scream to talk which of course made everything worse. Entrees very slow coming from kitchen though the appetizers were quicker. Service was fair. Meals were slightly above average. Probably wonât rush back.
5. Maples
Overall Ratings
4 based on 73 reviews
Reviewed By joemiller2016
There was plenty of parking in front of, and around the building.This morning, the restaurant was filled with Christmas atmosphere. There was a well decorated holiday tree in the entryway on the left. On the right, there were several paintings for sale. It was drizzling, and the temperature was around 40 or so. But, Maples was filled with happy customers, exciting conversations, and delightfully warm decorations.We were seated quickly in a large comfortable booth, and our server, Christina, came right over to get us started with coffees. She was very pleasant and she wore a necklace of Christmas lights making good use of the season.Kielbasa ânâ Eggs for me. Eggs over easy, home fries, and rye toast. Hot coffee, and an extra napkin or two for my mustache. The food was very good, and large portions were served.It's not our first time here, and I do plan to return for various occasions. I rate this restaurant five stars, and I recommend it to all my friends and family.Oh, did I mention that the drizzle ended, and it was a sunny day all day?Merry Christmas everyone.
4. Maggie McFly's
Overall Ratings
3 based on 223 reviews
Our Passion is for making our guests fresh, delicious, and locally sourced dishes and drinks while letting them relax in a beautiful atmosphere. From Farm fresh eggs and grass fed beef to our locally sourced cupcakes and everywhere in between. Maggie McFl
Reviewed By Day_Tripper_2008
First, the atmosphere and âvibeâ was fun. Service was lacking. It took 15 minutes until we met our server, and from then on we spent most of our time looking for her - long waits for every phase. It wasnât THAT busy. Food, however came out in a timely manner, brought by an expediter. An hour and a half spent here for burgers and no offer for drink refills. Where was MJ???? The burgers and fries were very good. We also had a flight of drafts, and every glass had different levels of beer (short) and the slots in the flight board were full of beer. We would have asked for extra napkins, but we needed a server to get them. By the way, the menu(s) are ridiculous - WAY TOO MUCH. Like I said, a mixed bag.
3. Vyne Restaurant & Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 51 reviews
Vyne is central Connecticut's dining destination. From a meal on our patio near the gorgeous waterfalls to sitting at our private chef's counter, Vyne is your place. We look forward to seeing you!
Reviewed By ParkerSturbridge
Okay, so the outside looks like a Long Island wedding factory, complete with statues, cascading waterfalls and semi-fake looking rocks. Step inside to what was once one of the most dazzling antique centers in Connecticut. The ambiance is a little flashy so step up to the NYC style bar and have a seat. Get a classic burger with the seasoned fries. Or the lamb "lollypops". Or a salad or a flatbread pizza. You won't be disappointed regardless. I got the burger, perfectly cooked, with lettuce, tomato and mayo (you dress it yourself). Nice. Check this place out...you'll love it.
2. Leo's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 58 reviews
Reviewed By Jeff W
We had a great breakfast at Leo's, but the trip advisor filters and menu say they have lots of gluten free. The only thing we could get though was french toast. Other than that though, the menu is very extensive and food tastes like i made it at home...and I mean that in a good way.
What to do and see in Middlebury, United States: The Best Places and Tips
1. L Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 103 reviews
Reviewed By StomWiltshire_UK
A group of us were in the area for a sporting event and I had called L Restaurant to make a reservation. My first impression was very good! The person I spoke to was pleasant and efficient.When we arrived on the Saturday evening, our table was ready and every member of staff we interacted with proved to be delightful.Our server was attentive and the food was delicious; freshly prepared and just perfect. Two members of our party had particular dietary needs but this did not prove to be a problem as every effort was made to ensure that their food was prepared to the same high standard.I chose this restaurant because of the positive reviews, which, in my opinion, are well deserved. If we were in the area again, we would definitely return!
Middlebury Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Middlebury
