Location: Keyport
Top Restaurants in Keyport
Where to eat American food in Keyport: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best American food in Keyport, New Jersey, United States. Keyport is a borough in Monmouth County, New Jersey, United States. At the 2010 United States Census, the borough's population was 7,240, following a decline of 328 (-4.3%) from the 7,568 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn declined by 18 (-0.2%) from the 7,586 counted in the 1990 Census. Keyport's nickname is the "Pearl of the Bayshore" or the "Gateway to the Bayshore".
Things to do in Keyport
10. Uncle Louie G
Reviewed By JCSINY
Very few times I get wowed by ice cream but had to make it known of what an amazing product I received at Uncle Louie G in Keyport, NJ. From over 36 flavors of ice cream to over 48 flavors of Italian ice. Every flavor is better than the next. So fresh and so good. Check it out and Enjoy!
9. Burlew's Seafood and Steak
Overall Ratings
3 based on 84 reviews
Reviewed By epr120
Although most of the negative reviews are concerning service, the food and ambience are great. Yes, the servers struggle on a busy Saturday night, but they try hard. I witnessed one server spill a bowl of soup in the kitchen over the clean silverware. Speaking of soup, I never got mine that I ordered but when she realized the error I was sent home with soup. The drinks are great and the seafood was very fresh as were the appetizers. No complaints. Sitting on the upstairs porch is terrific. A very enjoyable evening. Glad we tried it.
8. McDonagh's Pub
Overall Ratings
3 based on 68 reviews
Reviewed By Rich F
This was my first time at McDonagh's Pub but it won't be my last. I met others there for a business lunch and really enjoyed the place. Our server was wonderful, my corned beef reuben was excellent and the restaurant was clean. I highly recommend.
7. Yesterday's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 93 reviews
Reviewed By JohnP761
This restaurant offers an unlimited salad bar, unlimited soup and unlimited mussels in marinara sauce and then the meal. The stuffed pork chops over a bed is spinach was amazing. The house Merlot was exceptionally reasonably priced. Overall this is a great restaurant for a family that wants a satisfying meal.
6. Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits
Overall Ratings
4 based on 69 reviews
At OLD GLORY we pride ourselves on using only the freshest and finest ingredients available while supporting local fisherman, farmers and selling the highest quality meats, produce and seafood available. Our 900° rotating brick oven not only makes great p
Reviewed By LCSCONST
Recently went to Old Glory Kitchen and Grill after not wanting to wait at another restaurant. From the hostesses to the wait staff to the good runners it was nothing but smiles and friendless. Situated in an old church building, its cozy on the dining room. Snd on nicer weather they have outdoor seating and a bar. My wife wasn't as hungry as I was do she ordered soup and the drunken clams from the app menu, I ordered fish and chips. Our waitress explained that the clams come from the grill and the fish comes from the kitchen, so they might not come out at the same time, but she would try to time it do they would. The clams did come out first and the waitress came over twice to apologize and after the second time said she would go into kitchen to check on it. She returned with the dish and it was hot and plentiful. My wife's soup bowl was a good size and there was at least a dozen clams in her dish. And the bread they put on the table,wow. It's a cheesy topped oven baked bread that tasted like a grill cheese sandwich. We asked for a second portion.we will definitely be going back.LCSCONST, Thank you so much for your wonderful 5 star review! We greatly appreciate it & we look forward to serving you again soon!
5. Lenora's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 46 reviews
Reviewed By sv1972
I was in the area mid-week for work. We decided to stop in for coffee but ended up having breakfast. A nice place. Simple, very clean and really good service. I had the rancheros and my wife had two fried eggs with wheat toast. Really good. My wife's cappuccino was nice, but my coffee was a little weak (typical diner coffee).
4. Maloneys Pub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 133 reviews
Reviewed By Didojen
3.5 stars but I'm rounding up. Maloney's is a nice little local pub with a tremendous selection on tap. Me and my husband came with a group of friends. Our waiter joined together a few of the wobbly bar top tables for us in the front of the restaurant. My husband ordered the steak which was surprisingly really good. The steak was cooked to perfection and really tasty. I ordered the black and blue salad (salad with blackened chicken and blue cheese) which was also really delicious. Both of our dishes were huge! Service was excellent and very friendly. The space is large and casual. Street parking is fairly easy to find. I did feel prices were a tad high (especially for the beers) but I still wouldn't hesitate to return.
3. Mike's
Overall Ratings
5 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By 719scarletts
By far the best sub you will ever get - don't confuse this family run establishment with Jersey Mike's. Jersey Mike's is a Subway type shop. This is the real deal.
2. Broad Street Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 63 reviews
Reviewed By valeriemabel
I saw the diner on television and heard that it was rated one of the best diners in New Jersey. I ordered a waffle, sausage links and scrambled eggs with cheese. The food came hot and quick. It looked wonderful. The sausage links had that snap I like. The waffle was a Belgian waffle. It was light but no seasoning. It needed a lot of syrup. I do not knot know if this is my misyake, when I order scrambled eggs with cheese I should not have to say, "scramble the cheese into the eggs." I think it is lazy to put the cheese on top. Plus I found a part of the shell. The staff was very nice. I will try it again but that diner in Harrison is still the best in my eyes and I wanted the best to be in my neighborhood.
1. Drew's Bayshore Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 239 reviews
Reviewed By FooseMan
So each visit is exciting. The seating is always cozy. The byob option really appeals to all here. Food is diverse but appropriate seasonally & otherwise. Have had nothing but excellent meals.. Try the Creole selection. Bam!!
