Location: Blue Hill
Top Restaurants in Blue Hill
Countries
Where to eat American food in Blue Hill: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best American food in Blue Hill, Maine, United States. Blue Hill is a town in Hancock County, Maine, United States. The population was 2,686 at the 2010 census. It is home to the Blue Hill Public Library, Blue Hill Memorial Hospital, George Stevens Academy, the Blue Hill Harbor School, New Surry Theatre, Kneisel Hall, Bagaduce Music Lending Library, the Kollegewidgwok Yacht Club, the Marine & Environmental Research Institute, and the Blue Hill Country Club. A community on Blue Hill Bay, the town is the site of the annual Blue Hill Fair.
Things to do in Blue Hill
10. Blue Hill Inn Restaurant
Overall Ratings
5 based on 18 reviews
We're excited to be offering five-course, wine-paired dinners on Monday and Tuesday nights through Labor Day. Brooklin-raised Chef La Mason is returning to the inn for locavore dinners after receiving such a positive response last summer. Chef La has a mo
Reviewed By Lisaandtoni
Pre fixe dinner served only two nights a week. Portions are very small, but there are a few courses and a different wine with every course. No before dinner cocktails included, which adds to the $85. PP cost, which includes tax and tip. Service was friendly and attentive. Cozy setting.
9. Marlintini's Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 28 reviews
Reviewed By LBPICO
I was looking for a good dinner after arriving in Blue Hill and found Marlintini's on the main road. The server was very friendly and I asked for her suggestions which was a good choice. Between the ribs and the haddock basket she suggested the haddock. It was excellent. Not greasy or oily at all. Very thin "breaking" which was crisp and fries that were also "just right". Not oily. The tartar sauce was the best I've ever had. I will eat here again before I leave town.
8. The BoatYard Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 56 reviews
New restaurant. Opened about 3 weeks ago.
Reviewed By grahambolt98
Go for the overall experience...food is OK, limited menu, beers good, nice bar area...feels like Caribbean transported to Maine! If the weather is nice, sit outside and let the kids enjoy the old lobster boat that forms a play area!! Creative, fun, donât take it too seriously and you will enjoy it!!
7. Thurston Co. Restaurant & Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By Mimi J
We had a wonderful dinner last night. We started with the fries, oyster tostadas and mussel--all wonderful. For our entrees, two had the special halibut, one had the duck confit rigatoni, a lazy lobster, pork chop and fried chicken. All were delicious, as were the desserts, a watermelon lemon sorbet and a s'mores pie. Wonderful friendly server and prompt service. All in all a very nice night.
6. Sandy's Blue Hill Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 25 reviews
Reviewed By William L
My wife ordered the tuna sandwich and I opted to try their signature dish, a haddock currie on rice. not having been there before I wanted to try their stuff. I also opted for their fresh brewed iced tea - not a sweet tea like in NC or VA. the tuna was very nice but the curry was outstanding in its own bowl. I almost finished it. the haddock was in bite sized pieces. the curry, light as it was, took care of any possible fish taste. I was asked if the dish was a "taste of Maine". I said no, tasted better. looked like a lot of other good stuff on the menu. I'll return.
5. The Harbor House Cafe Of Blue Hill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 76 reviews
Where old friends gather and new friends meet! Home cooked food using the freshest ingredients. Daily soups, chowders, quiche, and lunch specials along with our daily menu. Enjoy one of our pastries or one made from our very own pastry chef. Ask about our
Reviewed By JackieLiangStudio
Stopped by today for lunch. We sad outside on the deck. The view - beautiful. The food - amazing. The service - friendly. I can't image a better lunch experience anywhere else. Oh, I had the "blacken haddock reuben" - rather delicious. Try it.
4. Marlintini's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 92 reviews
Reviewed By PopeyeCT
Great price point if you do not want to spend a lot, food is average though, nothing wow. The locals really seem to like it, fun spot with huge bar and free popcorn.
3. Barncastle
Overall Ratings
4 based on 131 reviews
Reviewed By didr
We have dined at Barncastle twice now. The first time we chose an entrée and were not very impressed. The second visit was for pizza, however, and this time the meal made up for the shortcomings of visit number one. Barncastle apparently inherited the pizza recipes of a former Blue Hill favorite, and they are carrying on the tradition in delicious style.
2. The Farmhouse Inn & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 54 reviews
Welcome to The Farmhouse Inn B&B in Blue Hill, Maine The Farmhouse Inn is a family owned & operated, 1870s bed & breakfast in Blue Hill, Maine. The Inn sits on 48 acres at the base of Blue Hill Mountain, just 3 miles from the center of Blue Hill village &
Reviewed By Michele R
Stopped in for dinner and was not disappointed. Beautiful setting inside and out with fresh ingredients for drinks and food and friendly waitstaff.
1. Arborvine
Overall Ratings
4 based on 212 reviews
House in a fully renovated 1823 Cape in Blue Hill, Maine, Arborvine opened its doors in July of 2000. Family owned, Arborvine has consistently been offering fresh, locally sourced and thoughtfully prepared fare for nearly two decades.
Reviewed By Ghost
This is an ideal restaurant for a special occasion. It is tastefully appointed and the food was attractively presented and served in a timely fashion.Minor problems were that the dining room can be noisy at the height of the dining hour and that the quality of the desserts did not live up to the quality of the rest of the meal.
