Location: Kelleys Island
Top Restaurants in Kelleys Island
Top Things to do in Kelleys Island
- 1. Glacial Grooves State Memorial
- 2. Marblehead Lighthouse
- 3. Lakeside Chautauqua
- 4. Perry's Victory & International Peace Memorial
- 5. Kelleys Island State Park
- 6. South Bass Island
- 7. Cathy's Wire Art Jewelry
- 8. Put-in-Bay Winery
- 9. Kelley's Island Ferry Boat line
- 10. Kelleys Island Historical Association
Top 8 Pizza food in Kelleys Island, Ohio, United States
Find out what Pizza restaurants to try in Kelleys Island. Kelleys Island is both a village in Erie County, Ohio, United States, and the island which it fully occupies in Lake Erie. The area was originally known by the British as Sandusky Island, and later officially designated by the U.S. as Island Number 6 and Cunningham Island. It was renamed Kelleys Island in 1840 by brothers Datus and Irad Kelley, who had purchased nearly the entire island.
Things to do in Kelleys Island
8. Put In Bay Cameo Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 131 reviews
Reviewed By Mooseknuckle81
The pizza was pretty good. Got 2 large to-go and we were not disappointed with the pizza. Good taste, staff was friendly, and toppings were good. Only reason I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 was because it cost $43 for 2 large pizzas! One pepperoni and one pepperoni and sausage, $43! Iâm glad it was good pizza or I would have been mad. If you donât mind expensive pizza, it is great.
7. Canoe Club Wine Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 131 reviews
Reviewed By TravelFan48105
We had an enjoyable evening at this pleasant restaurant. The food was good, with the pizza being the standout item. We had ordered the artichoke and crab pizza (on the specials menu) and it was excellent. My watermelon and arugula salad was very good. One person had the chicken Caesar salad and complained that the chicken was totally dried out. We had started with warmed pretzels for the table (with cheese and mustard dips) and ended with an excellent bread pudding a la mode. It was a satisfying meal at a reasonable price. Service was okay, not the best Iâve experienced but adequate.
6. Frosty Bar Incorporated
Overall Ratings
4 based on 330 reviews
Reviewed By SheilaMarieK
I came in for a quick bite before heading back to the mainland. Service was prompt and friendly. Food was quick and tasty. Music was a nice addition.Recommended
5. Jamestown Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By 231mindyw
Great local hangout with live music on the weekends. Vodka cherries and gummy bears are definitely recommended! Could be a little cooler inside.
4. Bruno's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 93 reviews
Reviewed By ZacBuffett
After a long day fishing on the lake Bruno's hits the spot. I have been going to the Marblehead area for over 40 years. I've seen pizza places come and go and this one is still here. That should speak for itself because without the help of the locals it probably couldn't make it on vacationers alone.
3. Sloopy's Sports Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 88 reviews
Reviewed By OhioTraveller
We were staying at The Fountain Inn (right across the street from Sloopy's). We ate two meals there - chef salads one night and plizza (with cauliflower crust) another night. Both were delicious. We thought the prices were fair and the service was good. We didn't mind having to order at the counter
Most Popular American food in Kelleys Island, Ohio, United States
2. Caddy Shack
Overall Ratings
4 based on 52 reviews
Reviewed By emasonry1
Weâd eat there more but year after year the kitchen help always seem to be bothered to take an order. I see different people year after year in their kitchen and itâs like they are trained to be short and unfriendly. We left Saturday without ordering.
1. Kelley's Island Wine Company
Overall Ratings
4 based on 206 reviews
Reviewed By 968janicec
We came for the afternoon, rented a golf cart and just drove all over. We passed this place, turned around and came back. They have a nice assortment of cheese plates. We got the very good imported plate (warm Brie, Havarti, and goat cheese), plus a small loaf of bread, 2 apples, and mustard ($22),plus 2 glasses of their white wines. The outside porch was really relaxing and our waitress was nice. If we can get back next year, this place will be at the top of our list!
Where to eat Pub food in Kelleys Island: The Best Restaurants and Bars
