Location: Montauk Motels
Top Hotels in Montauk Motels
Top 6 Motels in Montauk, United States
A 200-year-old lighthouse serves as a beacon for the Long Island town of Montauk, where fishing, beachcombing, kayaking and surfing vie for your attention. Pack a camera and binoculars for seal watching walks in Montauk Point State Park during the winter. Second House, a 1700s cottage built for East Hampton shepherds, adds to the local history. Summer season brings live music to the town's pubs and cafes. Hither Hills State Park provides access to ocean swimming, a 40-acre freshwater pond and camp sites.
Things to do in Montauk
1. Marram
Overall Ratings
4 based on 133 reviews
Great location, friendly staff, great facilities
Reviewed By Kei KThe pictures of this place is accurate! There's no TV but with two kids 7 and 12, with their pads, wifi was more than enough. Plus, it helps wind down and helps concentrate on the wonderful atmosphere and environment. Very Zen-like, with the beach and pool just in the 'backyard' and evening/night fire pits with s'mores and complimentary water/seltzer/Nespresso coffee is just icing. During my stay the staff from the beach crew, to the pool and to the fire pit crew were just wonderfully accommodating. Special shout out to Akeem who helped me find an extension cord to help me charge my car, even though he didn't have to go out of his way. If you want ice, there's only one though, but a large thermos helped me fill what i needed and the room fridge kept drinks cool enough. As to the room, we booked a two queen bed room facing the parking lot and it was enough for a family of 4. Beds were comfortable as well as the linens and honestly, I preferred the bare stone floor more than carpets that can trap and accumulate all the sand and dirt. Air conditioning was excellent and we slept well!
2. Haven Montauk
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 104 reviews
Crisp. Clean. Contemporary. Haven Montauk is the perfect low- key and friendly Motel experience you were looking for. Haven features 27 thoughtfully designed guestrooms with all the essentials for a stay in Montauk. Residing directly on the harbor, the property is centrally located and accessible to all. We encourage you to explore the many beautiful beaches right in our backyard, charter a fishing boat or relax poolside at our property. Our complimentary bicycles provide the perfect transportation along the beach to Gossman's Dock, where you can enjoy the fresh catch of the day while you revel in Montauk's killer sunsets. In the evening, as the air begins to cool, lounge around our fire pit with your friends to keep warm. Enjoy all the excitement of Montauk with the knowledge that there is a peaceful place to lay your head once the beach-day sunshine catches up with you and it's time to put out the bonfire.
Awful Experience
Reviewed By justintJ8851EHMy wife and I stayed here for her birthday, and we will never stay here again. I’m shocked at how many good reviews there are for this place. For the rates they charge, on a weekday no less, what you get is a tiny motel room with a lack of upkeep. Our options were limited because we wanted a pet friendly spot (more on that later), but I expected a much better experience. We visited in the middle of a heat wave, and all you get in your room is a small wall A/C unit that doesn’t go below 72 degrees and sounds like a jet engine. The bathroom was in terrible condition, and the bed was 3 feet from the front door that had a huge gap on the bottom, so not only could you hear everything outside your room but the huge gap also allowed the heat to easily get in so the room never stayed cool during the day. The photos they provide on their website are very misleading. Feel free to compare them to the photos I took. I decided to pay extra for a Premium room instead of the Classic, thinking we’d get a nicer room and/or a view of the ocean. We got neither. The pictures on their website and other websites show an ocean view with a room that looks nothing like the room we got. The only difference between a Premium and Classic room is what level you’re on (the Premium rooms are on the second floor). My last gripe is with the pet policy. They charge you a $150 pet fee, but their policy is that you cannot leave your pet in the room alone. We’ve stayed at a number of pet friendly hotels and this is the first time we’ve come across this ridiculous policy. The fact that it was a pet friendly motel didn’t prevent some other guests from complaining to the front desk about our dog barking (a 7 lb Maltese). I would have loved to have had a conversation with whoever complained twice in one day about our dog barking. Both complaints were in the middle of the day. Why are you in your crappy room during a beautiful day? If you have a problem with dogs barking at a pet friendly hotel/motel, don’t stay at a pet friendly hotel. There’s plenty of other places to stay in Montauk that aren’t pet friendly. I highly recommend staying anywhere other than here.
3. Hartman's Briney Breezes Beach Resort
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 724 reviews
Overlooking the Atlantic Ocean's clean white sandy beaches you will relax and enjoy a spectacular ocean view from all 44 1 and 2 room efficiencies, with A/C Heat, HBO and a balcony to sit and unwind. Outdoor heated pool, Barbecues,short walk to the village and Tee Times at Montauk Downs.
Amazing, highly recommend!
Reviewed By emory_corsoHad the most lovely time staying here. The property is gorgeous, it is right across the street from the beach and has all the amenities you need. The staff was also so friendly and helpful. Will be going back!
4. Born Free Suites by the Sea
Overall Ratings
3.5 based on 75 reviews
Nestled between the sun and surf is Born Free Suites by the Sea. Offering a choice of twenty-four accommodations. One and two bedroom suites for the evening, weekend, or week. Adjoining rooms are available. Each has a living room, kitchen/dining area, and bedroom. Open all year long! All the pleasures of a shore vacation combined with the comfort and fun your entire family will enjoy at Born Free Suites by the Sea. Live every moment to the fullest! Our beach is a great attraction where ocean bathing is without equal. Surf cast, beach comb, jog, or stroll along our beautiful beach… or just relax. Sailing, motor boating, horseback riding, and many other outdoor activities are offered nearby. Deep-water fishing on the open sea with licensed captains is also available. At Born Free Suites you can walk to a beautiful wide sandy ocean beach… yet be only one block from the center of town. Play tennis and enjoy the other facilities of Montauk Downs, which include a championship 18-hole golf course designed by the famous Robert Trent Jones. Comfortable living by the sea whether you’re single, a couple, or a family. By day enjoy the sun-drenched beaches. After sundown enjoy a moonlight walk along the beach. Relax to the sound of the surf and romantic setting of the moon over the water. When your appetite has been whet by the day’s activities, try one of the many fine restaurants Montauk has to offer.
Amazing stay at Born Free!
Reviewed By alyzad2021Born free suites never ever disappoints! Check in was timely and smoothe…which after driving for two hours is always a pleasure. The suites are always clean and well-stocked with all the necessities needed for a relaxing beach get-away. My husband and I have been coming here for five years and have never had a poor experience! Just across the road from the beach and minutes from town. The location is fabulous! Thank you Born Free for helping us create wonderful memories in Montauk!!
5. Sun 'N' Sound
Overall Ratings
4 based on 76 reviews
Looking for a place to stay in Montauk? Then look no further than Sun 'N' Sound, a family-friendly motel that brings the best of Montauk to your doorstep. You’ll enjoy relaxing rooms that offer air conditioning, a refrigerator, and a kitchenette, and you can stay connected during your stay as Sun `n` Sound Hotel offers guests free wifi. The motel features a sun terrace. Plus, Sun `n` Sound Hotel offers a pool, providing a pleasant respite from your busy day. For guests with a vehicle, free parking is available. Close to some of Montauk's most popular landmarks, such as Gosman's Dock (1.3 mi) and St. Therese of Lisieux Catholic Church (2.7 mi), Sun `n` Sound Hotel is a great destination for tourists. If you like seafood restaurants, Sun `n` Sound Hotel is conveniently located near Montauket, Harvest on Fort Pond, and Gosman's Restaurant. During your visit, be sure to check out a popular lighthouse like Montauk Point Lighthouse, which is a short distance from the motel. We’re sure you’ll enjoy your stay at Sun 'N' Sound as you experience everything Montauk has to offer.
Trashy Long Island Motel Charging Resort Prices
Reviewed By wavypearlThis place charges you an arm and a leg to stay here because it's in Montauk, it's on the water. You expect it to be somewhat nice. It's not. What a disappointment. Nothing more than your average Super 8 motel, it's beyond disgusting. The only thing ok is the bed, but maybe not even that great because it rolls. The furniture is gross and old, the decorations in the room subpar or non-existent, and the place feels poorly cleaned, which is no comfort during the time of COVID. As for your balcony/patio area, ha, what a joke. It's not private at all. A lot of people walk by, right outside your patio door, hang out, have parties on the picnic tables. Enjoy the smell of the sound AND the smoke from all of the cigarettes other guests are smoking near and above your patio. Great stuff during a respiratory pandemic. Basically you're paying resort prices for a terrible, low-end motel. The staff has an attitude as the day is long, not caring at all about your family's health needs or concerns. If you have money to spend, don't spend it here. If you don't have money to spend and want to splurge, do not splurge here. What a wretched place. One of the worst motels I've ever stayed at in my whole life. We felt duped and lied to - the website is quite misleading.
6. Sole East Beach
Overall Ratings
3.5 based on 79 reviews
Looking for a place to stay in Montauk? Then look no further than Sole East Beach, a motel that brings the best of Montauk to your doorstep. Rooms at Sole East Beach Hotel provide a flat screen TV, air conditioning, and a refrigerator, and getting online is easy, with free wifi available. And, as an added convenience, there is free parking available to guests. While staying at Sole East Beach, visitors can check out Gosman's Dock (1.9 mi), which is a popular Montauk attraction. While in Montauk be sure to experience local shrimp favorites at Harvest on Fort Pond, Gosman's Restaurant, or Muse at the End. During your visit, be sure to check out popular attractions like Montauk Point State Park (0.1 mi), Deep Hollow Ranch (0.1 mi), and Shadmoor State Park (0.5 mi), which are all within walking distance of the motel. We’re sure you’ll enjoy your stay at Sole East Beach as you experience everything Montauk has to offer.
Beach Hotel is a Dump
Reviewed By 1437EmilyCsole east resort has a stellar reputation, but the beach property is a complete nightmare. The rooms at the motel were an all day/night rave - with about 12 boys blasting music with a strobe light - and their door open - until 3am. we complained multiple times and the situation persisted. The lack of security was appalling. the front desk was never staffed. Bongs, weed, and empty beer bottles with left outside our door. This was supposed to be a pet/kid friendly location, but these items were just left open for the taking - or for animals / children to ingest. Not to mention it invites unwelcome, non-guests. It was a total safety hazard and just simply disgusting - especially considering the price. We never would have stayed here had we known it was a party hotel for 18-21 year olds. You need to disclose that this property is an entirely different experience and not up to the same standard as the resort. And prices need to reflect that. It’s wildly misleading to even share the same brand name, as the two properties are not AT ALL the same. Additionally, the AC unit did not work. The room remained at 80 degrees the entire stay. On our last night, they offered to relocate us via text, but it was far too little too late. Since leaving, I have yet to receive a call from anyone attempting to rectify the situation.
