Location: Water Mill
Top Restaurants in Water Mill
Top 4 Cafe food in Water Mill, Southampton, New York
Reviews on Cafe food in Water Mill, Southampton, New York. Water Mill is a hamlet of the Town of Southampton on Long Island and census-designated place (CDP) in Suffolk County, New York, United States. The population of the CDP was 1,559 at the 2010 census. Its ZIP code is 11976.
Things to do in Water Mill
1. Golden Pear Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 166 reviews
Reviewed By Carol W
I couldn't believe the high quality of organic farm-fresh ingredients going into everything served at this Hamptons chain of cafes. Only the best for the rich, huh.As with everything that is of high quality is the high price and the extensive diversity of offerings you don't normally find at any run-of-the-mill cafe. More like a deli/cafe, I saw beef stew in the buffet set-up a little down the counter from the mini-bakery section. Across the way is a small set-up for smoothies and juices, made with farm-fresh organic fruits and vegetables, naturally.Our jelly and chocolate-covered custard donuts were tiny but exquisite in taste, texture. Our South Hampton sunrise juices had tons of fresh flavor.It's the most reasonable place in this small stretch of shops and restaurants.
2. Seasons of Southampton
Reviewed By frankvespe
Having attended many Special Events at this special catering hall, I HAD to bring my wife and four kids there for Thanksgiving dinner when I learned they were open for this special holiday, and I was not disappointed. My family thought I was out of my mind to abandon our happy home-cooked Thanksgiving dinner, but the warmth given by their staff made the six of us feel as though we were in our own house, without the screaming J-E-T-S from my three sons....Nice and quiet. The buffet was well stocked with everything, especially the cream spinach which I sneaked back to enjoy four times! The ambiance is casual but going there makes you feel as though wearing a sports jacket and pressed shirt is the right touch. Sadly though, this special place is only open for weddings and other special events and holidays such as Thanksgiving, as well as outside catering events including summer clambakes. Leaving Seasons of Southampton last month, I had Joseph the Maitre d' pencil us in for next Thanksgiving!!!
3. Cafe Crust
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By dgyuen
We had another delicious dinner at Cafe Crust. Unpretentious in The Hamptons, but fresh, delicious fare! Started out with their Spinach Salad- might have seemed pricey at first, but it was delicious and big enough for two. Had the brick oven-baked Marguerite pie- fresh organic tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and fresh basil (made the other half with sweet Italian sausage and red roasted peppers! Outdoor dining tonight was perfect- always friendly and accommodating wait staff is a plus.
Most Popular Seafood food in Water Mill, Southampton, New York
4. L & W Market
Reviewed By worldview123
Lots of hype ..but where is the beef ...the team from almond need to show more originality ...why isn't there more fresh prepared food or summer soups ..or anything that warrants a trip back... i dont need another coffee shop...but fresh tarts ..or melon soup ..or paella or something special would be worth considering
