Location: Fenwick Island
Top Restaurants in Fenwick Island
Top 10 Seafood food in Fenwick Island, Delaware, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Seafood food in Fenwick Island, Delaware, United States. Fenwick Island is a coastal town in Sussex County, Delaware, USA. According to 2010 census figures, the population of the town is 379, a 10.8% increase over the last decade. It is part of the Salisbury, Maryland-Delaware Metropolitan Statistical Area. The town is located on Fenwick Island, a barrier spit.
Things to do in Fenwick Island
10. Nick's Original House of Ribs
Overall Ratings
4 based on 638 reviews
Nick's smoky BBQ baby back ribs, amazing jumbo lump crab cakes and juicy Certified Angus steaks.
Reviewed By Audrey14750
I went there with my family. The ribs were cold. They had sauce on top but the meat was so dry and I couldnât even eat it. The waitress didnât seem to care that I asked for a box and said that I would need to take them home and put them in the microwave. If they were cooked in the restaurant why would they be cold? Were they left over from yesterday? Seemed like it. Hard to pay $97 for dinner for two adults and two kids and get crap like this. I wonder if they cook them on the premises or buy them pre-cooked.So sorry. Maximizing Happiness is what drives us everyday, however as hard as we try our human selves do make mistakes. This would have been an easy and quick fix, had you have let us know (we arent good at deciphering dropped hints).Scott Heise
9. Catch 54
Overall Ratings
4 based on 391 reviews
Recently named the 'Best Waterfront Restaurant' in the State of Delaware, Catch 54 is committed to serving beautiful simple coastal cuisine in a beautiful setting overlooking the bay. House specialties include our signature Crab Cake, Buttermilk Fried Oys
Reviewed By mjrfamily
I have to admit we were a little disappointed with our last experience at Catch 54. We usually enjoy an amazing view and atmosphere with great seafood. This time our party of 8 was seated at the side of the restaurant on a picnic table with no view accept of the parking lot and the side of a pontoon boat. It was more suitable for employees to sit there for their break. The food was below the quality we usually experienced. My wifeâs shrimp and grits came out cold. The scallops were great as usual. Our server was also awesome. We will be back to give it another chance and will hope it is a better experience.Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. We really appreciate you continuing to come in to dine with us with your family and we are sorry that your last visit wasn't the best. Please never hesitate to speak up to your server or to a manager if you are not pleased with your table so we can move you to a location where you are more comfortable. I would be happy to further discuss if you would like to email me at [email protected], thank you.
8. Captain Macâs Fish House Seafood Market & Dining
Overall Ratings
4 based on 177 reviews
OUR STORY Bruce McGuigan grew up near the water, spending his time recreational and commercial fishing until his passion led him to open Captain Mac's Bait & Tackle. Opening the doors in 1983, Bruce and his father, Charles "Mac" McGuigan, provided Fenwick
Reviewed By treehugger_12
A local told us about this one and he was right. You go up to the counter and order and they call your name. Lots of crab with very little filler perfectly cooked with a local tomato slice. Had to use my fork to shorten the crab cake for ease of eating. Great location looking into the marsh with an osprey nest with two ospreys on it.
7. Twining's Lobster Shanty
Overall Ratings
4 based on 515 reviews
Reviewed By 527suzyb
Twiningâs Lobster Shanty is where we head when the adults are ready for a nice sit-down meal in a relaxed atmosphere that is comfortable enough to easily accommodate children. As the name suggests, the menu is heavy on lobster-based items, but thereâs enough variety to please everyone. The views of the bay are spectacular. The reliably good food and service at Twiningâs keep us coming back year after year.
6. Cafe Mirage
Overall Ratings
4 based on 364 reviews
Reviewed By ZGeeM
It'sfun to find a small restaurant hidden in the corner of a shopping center that has food so good you better have a reservation! If you thought you should just get a house salad, better be prepared to share - it's very large, and it is so fresh! A salad and the shrimp and grits appetizer was more than enough for dinner! Speaking of which, do order the shrimp and grits. The shrimp were grilled to perfection, and the sausage slices added just the right touch of spicy. The lamb chop pops were on the evening specials menu, so look to see if they are available. If so, do not hesitate to order them. They were delicious. It's really a busy place, and we can see why after having tasted the food! It's well worth the trip to this unassuming corner of Ocean City.
5. Warren's Station
Overall Ratings
4 based on 261 reviews
Reviewed By snzrmatt
I ordered one of the House specialties, served for over 55 years, the oven roasted turkey dinner with all the fixings, cranberry sauce, mashed potatoes, stuffing, and gravy. Delicious hand craved white and dark slices of fresh and tasty turkey. You can request all white or dark if you like for no extra charge. Large portions, you wonât leave hungry. $11.99 Great value, family restaurants, casual dress,no reservations needed, Warmly greeted, fast and friendly service. Good parking.
4. David Twining's Nantuckets Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 314 reviews
For over 29 years, Nantuckets has been providing a wonderful fine dining experience with a great bar and happy hour daily. Try hand-crafted cocktails, fine wines, great seafood and some of the best steaks at the beach.
Reviewed By Michael C
Had a reservation and seated promptly in the front room..... the room was extremely hot after about 10 minutes and a little uncomfortable. Our servers were outstanding especially our waitress Alyssa. My wife ordered a Shrimp and Scallops dish with a white wine sauce. ABSOLUTELY NOT ONE PIECE OF SHRIMP.... and the wine sauce tasted like dish water. Send it back and they agreed no shrimp... go figure. We both then got the crabcakes... another mistake. Among the worst I've ever had... mine I make at home are outstanding compared to the tasteless things they served. Guessing they pretty much don't have a chef. Not a good nite for $100+.
Best Pizza food near Fenwick Island, Delaware, United States
3. Lizzie's Cafe & Bistro 142nd St
Overall Ratings
4 based on 407 reviews
Lizzie's Cafe & Bistro 142nd St., an American Bistro established 2004 serving locals and tourists. A recipient of "Award of Excellence" year after year, Lizzie's serves breakfast, lunch, & dinner. Famous for Lobster Rolls, Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes, Crab Roll
Reviewed By Francelia T
I am sorry I meant to give your Bistro 5 stars which is Excellent. Because I enjoyed myself when I was there and I had the Best Reuben sandwich that I ever had, and the hospitality was great. No worries, and thank you for fixing that and taking the time to review us. Our family is happy you enjoyed your experience at Lizzie's and loved your REUBEN sandwich. We hear our guest say often "the REUBEN melts in your mouth". Come back again soon and we would love to thank you in person and serve you another meal. <3 <3 Cathie/Owner
2. Just Hooked
Overall Ratings
4 based on 571 reviews
Down-to-earth dining spot featuring locally-sourced seafood entrees, bar bites & a full bar.
Reviewed By Wilkinson1947
Six of us, including two kids, showed up at 5:30 and were seated instantly. The service and food were great and the kids were treated like celebrities. Two of us split their tuna and crab cakes to create our own Surf and Surf and they were both spectacular. I highly recommend this restaurant!We appreciate your kind words and awesome recommendation! So glad to read that the adults and the kids in your party enjoyed themselves, as well as the food and service here at Just Hooked! Hope that you'll join us again, and we look forward to seeing you then! Thanks so much.
Where to eat American food in Fenwick Island: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Delmarva Boil Company
Overall Ratings
5 based on 60 reviews
Delmarva Boil Company is a locally owned and operated seafood catering and take-out business specializing in traditional "Coastal Low-Country Boils", serving the coastal Delmarva Region. Our mission is to provide visitors, locals and vacationers alike, an
Reviewed By mjlytlevieira
Excellent Service! The shrimp boil was a success with our family! He came on time and spent several hours cooking and then an impeccable cleanup!The food was great and the whole cooking experience was a lot of fun.Very nice employee, obviously interested in the whole process and in pleasing his customer.
Most Popular Italian food in Fenwick Island, Delaware, United States
