Top Restaurants in Garnerville
Top Things to do in Garnerville
Top 10 Pizza food in Garnerville, New York, United States
Reviews on Pizza food in Garnerville, New York, United States including Mr Crispy's Brick Oven Pizza, Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant, Ben's Trattoria, 3 Boys From Italy, Marcella's Pizzeria & Family Restaurant 845-271-3414, Pizza Hut, Venite Pizzeria & Restaurant, Mariella's Restaurant & Bar, Rocco's Family Restaurant, Blu Fig
Things to do in Garnerville
10. Blu Fig
Overall Ratings
4 based on 96 reviews
Reviewed By Suziq614
Blue Fig has really good food. Salads Are especially good. Portions are large. My only issue is that in cold weather every time the door opens the cold air gets in. Yes, they have a curtain across the front that helps a little but itâs still chilly. I much prefer the outdoor patio or even inside when itâs warmer outside. Iâll wait or at least try for a table in the back.
9. Rocco's Family Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 91 reviews
Reviewed By Michael C
Roccos has been a staple of New City for years. To start, the staff is incredible always warm and welcoming making you feel at home. The front of the restaurant provides you with a traditional pizzaria in the case you were looking for a quick slice. The are famous for their large slices and loaded toppings. Some of my favorites include the salad slice, chicken marsala, and chicken bacon ranch. If you are looking for something lighter you can never go wrong with their margarita with the fresh basil and mozzarella.The dining room provides lots of room for families to get together and have a great Italian feast. Always check their specials as they often offer great platters such as stuffed shrimp, stuffed sole and various other specialty plates. The main menu is quite extensive offering many options of chicken plates, seafood, veal and pastas. Over the years I have come to find my favorite dish "the chicken Michelangelo" which is a heaping portion of chicken parm and two pieces of their eggplant rolantini. I promise you you will not be disappointed. The entrees also include a nice house salad and a side of pasta and of course Roccos famous garlic Balls!!!! . I highly recommend the penne vodka! The portions are not just tasty but massive and when going there I am just as excited knowing I will soon have delicious leftovers as I am to actually have the first meal!All in all it is an awesome family restaurant that we will continue to enjoy going to for years to come
8. Mariella's Restaurant & Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 12 reviews
Reviewed By jtcamp
Had dinner here on 6/21 and was not disappointed. The Gnocchi Alla Nona tossed with peas ans prosciutto was delicious. My wife's Menza Luna Agnolotti, cheese ravioli with onions, sausage, and basil was equally delicious. The best Sangria I have ever tasted !
7. Venite Pizzeria & Restaurant
Reviewed By MajorJoy
Pizza, Sandwiches, Calzones, but they have great dinners as well. Really casual dining, but worth the extra 1/2 from Exit 13. My favorite is the Ravioli. Sometimes they have shrimp filled, or spinach or cheese - and of course meat. But always great and pretty quick.
6. Pizza Hut
Reviewed By Catrine m m
I came here for the first time to get my son a personal pan. We waited about 15 minutes The place is really small and had a few tables. Maybe seats 6 altogether. It was very clean inside which is most important to me. I do suggest to order in advance so you dont have to wait and it is mainly a "Take out" place. FYI They do have a "Wing street" here as well.
5. Marcella's Pizzeria & Family Restaurant 845-271-3414
Reviewed By Justin W
Marcella's Pizzeria looks much older than it's recent history. Not too fancy and more of a pizzeria, they have many exotic type of pizza like Baked Ziti pizza where after one slice, you are full for the rest of the day. Their regular pies can feed a family quite nicely and people at the service register are always nice when we come in. Their slices are very big, so take time to decide what you like. The choices are very good.
4. 3 Boys From Italy
Overall Ratings
4 based on 11 reviews
Reviewed By MaryjanePennsylvania
While working for a week at a new store site in this plaza, we had occasion to have several meals from here and wish we were able to come back. Pizza was outstanding, salads with grilled chicken fresh and of high quality, sandwiches made-to-order were excellent. Prices very fair and reasonable. Always a smiling face behind the counter.
3. Ben's Trattoria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By SCAR-TRIPS
We brought a bottle of wine in with us and sat down. Waiter came and asked how many people need wine glasses. Really enjoy a BYO!Had fried calamari which was good served on some greens.A nicely crafted salad came with the entrée.Everyone enjoyed their salad and entrees.There was a large party in the other room which had a slight distraction from our service but my expectations are higher than most.
Most Popular Bar food in Garnerville, New York, United States
2. Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant
Reviewed By Boricua_Globetrotter
Nice and cozy pizzeria outside the Big City! Great service, affordable prices and really good pizza! The Wings and those Garlic Knots were not bad either! Decent Italian spot upstate NY!!!
Top 10 American food in Garnerville, New York, United States
1. Mr Crispy's Brick Oven Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By Bensionq
Great place for a slice of pizza or soup,I usually order Lentil soup which is my favourite and garlic wings,lately their sodium content is a little high but other than that no worries
Where to eat Italian food in Garnerville: The Best Restaurants and Bars
