Location: Watkinsville
Top Restaurants in Watkinsville
Top 10 Italian food in Watkinsville, Georgia, United States
Reviews on Italian food in Watkinsville, Georgia, United States. Watkinsville is the largest city and seat of Oconee County, Georgia, United States. As of the 2010 census, the town had a total population of 2,832. It served as the seat of Clarke County until 1872 when the county seat of that county was moved to Athens, a move which ultimately led to the creation of Oconee County in 1875. It is included in the Athens-Clarke County, Georgia Metropolitan Statistical Area.
Things to do in Watkinsville
10. De Palma's Italian Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 457 reviews
Reviewed By MARY W
The good was amazing and so was our server. We were early enough to be seated quickly, even though there were 6 of us. Our appetizers came out pretty quickly but it took a very long time for our main dishes to be ready. The Housemade Focaccia Bread is so good for an appetizer. Our attentive waiter came by often and apologized for the long wait. I had pasta and my husband had the scallops. Both were so good. We chalked it up to there being more people for dinner than the restaurant expected for a week night for the long wait so this would not stop us from coming here, again, because the food was so good.
9. Doughby's Pizza
Reviewed By FredL757
Party of three visited for the first time at the end of evening dinner rush hour on a week night. The restaurant was busy although the hectic rush was passed and customers were clearing out. The inside seating area was very noisy. We chose to sit on the covered patio. Our server (Emma) was very attentive and provided our drinks quickly and kept them full. We ordered a large pizza which took more than 25 minutes to arrive. Orders are relayed to the kitchen by some sort of WiFi device. I think our order got lost or the order had to be remade. While it came out very hot, the pizza taste was just so-so. We would not order pizza again. There are a number of sandwich and pasta items on the menu. We will visit again and try something else. Plenty of off street parking was available. The restaurant has a fresh and clean appearance.
8. Peppino's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 54 reviews
Reviewed By Keith L
I have been eating at Peppino's ever since they were located in downtown Athens. It's a little weird that they are located out in the middle of nowhere, but who cares. The great tasting food will make you drive to this place. My favorite pizza is a large ham and mushroom. If you live in the area, you have to try this pizza at least once. The place is a little pricey, but that old saying goes "you get what you pay for" definitely applies here. I don't mind paying the extra amount for a good quality pizza every once and awhile. Give it a try, you will not be sorry.
7. Your Pie
Overall Ratings
4 based on 34 reviews
Your Pie is the world's originator of the fast casual, brick-oven, customized personal pizza category. Founded by Drew French in 2008, the Your Pie concept was inspired by family recipes from the Italian island of Ischia. Your Pie uses hand-tossed dough,
Reviewed By gafood
Your Pie makes your pizza, calzone, or panini fresh, right in front of you. The ingredients are fresh and they are very generous with the toppings. The service was good and the restaurant was very clean. There are booths and longer tables. We enjoyed it and will go back.
6. Fox's Pizza Den
Reviewed By rayrayjulian
I do not remember ever in my life having a calzone with so LITTLE cheese. Like, literally almost NO cheese. There was most certainly ONLY mozzarella present and NO other cheeses typically found in calzones! In addition the bread tasted poorly like over processed factory bread... not home made like I would have expected. I ordered a peperoni in mine and it has exactly 6 peperoni in a MEDIUM calzone. It was mostly sauce and bread. I can't believe I spent so much money out of my hard earned pay check for such food. Hate to say it but I won't ever spend another dime on anything branded by this company. We have had fox's in years past (maybe 3 total visits) and always remember positive food experiences.
5. Fully Loaded Pizza Co.
Overall Ratings
4 based on 17 reviews
Reviewed By Gantt524080
Worst food experience in a while. Ordered take out and it was a disaster from the beginning. Couldnât find my order even though I had already paid online for it. Took three people asking about my order and name over and over before anyone could find it. Guess I should have checked the order while I was there but didnât as it was crowded and the bags were tied. Got home and found out the order was wrong. No fries like I ordered, instead we had nachos and and the cup of cheese dip for them on the side was full of black hair. The wings tasted disgusting and had zero flavor. There was barely any sauce on them and they simply tasted like plain wings and grease. Threw the entire order in the trash and went somewhere else. Called back to let them know we had received part of someone elseâs order and the bartender was totally overwhelmed and had no idea what to say. Will not be going back. Do better for your other customers!
4. Your Pie
Overall Ratings
4 based on 34 reviews
Your Pie is the world's originator of the fast casual, brick-oven, customized personal pizza category. Founded by Drew French in 2008, the Your Pie concept was inspired by family recipes from the Italian island of Ischia. Your Pie uses hand-tossed dough,
Reviewed By gafood
Your Pie makes your pizza, calzone, or panini fresh, right in front of you. The ingredients are fresh and they are very generous with the toppings. The service was good and the restaurant was very clean. There are booths and longer tables. We enjoyed it and will go back.
3. Mirko Pasta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 110 reviews
Reviewed By 876simonr
First time here and we came at 2:30 for a late lunch. Service was friendly and efficient and the food arrived expeditiously. Nice bread and bean dip. There are standard entrees and pick a sauce and pasta which was a little overwhelming if you are not familiar with the 18+ varieties offered. I enjoyed my Granchio/gnocchi, my wifeâs ravioli was a little rubbery for her liking. Ambiance is simple bordering on spartan with a nice bar. Unfortunately the sun showed the dirty windows and the floors could have been swept. If you feel like Italian this restaurant is worth a try.
2. Dominick's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 80 reviews
Welcome! Since 1996, Dominick's has worked to serve the best Italian food possible, using family recipes and fresh ingredients. Over our classic Italian dishes, strangers become friends and friends become family.
Reviewed By mja1982
Met friends here who are locals as they said this is one of their favorite places. They didnât steer us wrong. The food was excellent and the portions were huge. The large sizes are definitely enough for 3 or 4 adults. We like the pastas and the caprese salad as well. We would have had dessert but we were stuffed and still had a lot to take home with us. A nice warm place inside that is perfect for families.Thanks, we appreciate your business and comments, glad you enjoyed it. Hope to see you back soon.
1. Your Pie
Overall Ratings
4 based on 34 reviews
Your Pie is the world's originator of the fast casual, brick-oven, customized personal pizza category. Founded by Drew French in 2008, the Your Pie concept was inspired by family recipes from the Italian island of Ischia. Your Pie uses hand-tossed dough,
Reviewed By gafood
Your Pie makes your pizza, calzone, or panini fresh, right in front of you. The ingredients are fresh and they are very generous with the toppings. The service was good and the restaurant was very clean. There are booths and longer tables. We enjoyed it and will go back.
