Location: Succasunna
Top 10 Italian food in Succasunna, New Jersey, United States
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Succasunna. Succasunna is an unincorporated community and census-designated place (CDP) located within Roxbury Township, in Morris County, New Jersey, United States, having a population of 9,152 people as of the 2010 United States Census.
10. Cafe Fiori
Overall Ratings
4 based on 109 reviews
Reviewed By PaulieWalnuts12
We went with another couple, had a reservation and we had no issues. This place is BYOB that is a major advantage of coming here especially if your with a large group. Regardless the service and good were more than acceptable we would definitely go back. I know it can get loud in there but some music for ambiance would also be nice.
9. Cambiotti's Tomatoe Pie Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 43 reviews
973-770-1020On the list of Favorite StopsStar-Ledger Restaurant criticPete Genovese 9/26/08
Reviewed By Leigh F
We just recently moved to Landing so we wanted to try the local pizza place. The first time we got a plain pie. It was good but it was cold even though we picked it up when they told us to. I was desperate to like this place so we ordered again recently and got the special Vodkarita pizza. It was absolutely amazing!! Delicious! I hope they keep it around or let me order it still!
8. La Gratella Pizza
Overall Ratings
3 based on 25 reviews
Reviewed By 92thomasg
We decided to try this restaurant based on the fact that all the other restaurants in town were absolutely packed. The service was absolutely terrible it took an hour and a half to get to dishes. We ordered lasagna and we ordered vegetable Primavera. The pasta dish vegetable Primavera, The only vegetables in this dish were zucchini eggplant and string beans from a can. The sauce was green / brown broth that tasted like the water they cook the pasta in .I would love to be fair about this review because they seem like nice people, they will be out of business within one year with food that bad .I would say it is it one of the worst restaurants I have ever eaten .This area has a lot of good restaurants, unfortunately this is not one of them .We would never go back.
7. Joe's Pizzeria and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 11 reviews
Reviewed By b d
We came here at the recommendation of children's dentist who said that this is the only pizza in the area that he will eat - since it is so hard to find NYC quality pizza. He was right. We got a large plain pie ($12.50). It was really good. Sauce was great. Just the right amount of cheese. The crust was thin and not really doughy. Nothing to look at from the outside and inside is nothing fancy. Will be going back for more pizza. A sign over the pizza oven said "since 1958" - how can you go wrong with that track record?
6. New York Pizza & Restuarant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 9 reviews
Reviewed By lone6star
Gave passed this place many times, but never stopped in. Was surprised on a Saturday night at 7 pm that the place was empty Nevertheless, we ordered food to go. On checkout the credit card machine wasn't working. Besides all this our food was very good and was very large from a portion perspective. Parking is free, as it is in a strip mall.
5. Casella's Pizza and Deli
Reviewed By InkedAndTraveling
So, on our journey for a new local pizzeria, we stumbled across Casella's.... And a great stumble it was! Unlike the last pizzeria we use to frequent, this place accommodated to our "needs" without question! They serviced us well, the staff was very pleasant and the pizza was delivered hot and quick! Their pizza was probably the best I have had locally... it reminded me of pizza from New York City - tasty, crunchy and delicious! We ordered a Grandma Pie with Sausage and it was everything we expected and more. The last local place refused to put sausage on their Grandma Pie (most likely because it's run by the Pizza Nazi), so they lose out on our business and it is only to be gained by Casella's! Great job to the staff at Casella's for servicing your customers! I would definitely recommend this place to anyone traveling locally, and if you are curious as to which local pizzeria to avoid, just read through my reviews! My reviews are always honest and informative! Enjoy guys!
4. Luigis Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By jmat3213
I recently stopped in Luigis about three weeks ago and I ordered a large pizza and mozz sticks. Well there pizza is amazing! Great tastes and good ingredients. You can tell they take pride in there food. I was back a week later and tried a cheesesteak again was on the money. Also, Pauly is always friendly and he remembered my name from the previous week now that's a good business owner. I highly recommend going here you will not be disappointed. Enjoy!
Best American food near Succasunna, New Jersey, United States
3. Irpinia
Overall Ratings
4 based on 28 reviews
Reviewed By Beth C
Excellent food and the staff is so friendly. Go there at least 2x week. Like to try the daily specials.
Most Popular Cafe food in Succasunna, New Jersey, United States
2. Anthony & Sons
Overall Ratings
4 based on 58 reviews
Reviewed By JohnRWtzl
Always had high expectations for Anthony & Sons given their business heritage. We come here from time to time mostly for take out food.The deli is beautiful with a wonderful selection of premium priced Italian foods and products. The food is good, near to homemade, but frankly, on the expensive side. So, you may ask, why a 2 rating.Within the last month, I wanted to treat me and my wife to one of my favorite Italian pastries,sfogliatella. Some call it a lobster roll. I grew up in the city (my friends family used to own an Italian restaurant in the village) and I know good Italian pastry. And I thought Anthony's for sure would now how to make a good one. Well, the two we purchased turned out to be flat lumps of flavorless dough. There were no crispy layers that peeled off, the inside was dense and unflavorful They had to be from frozen old dough. So rather than waste the calories, we threw them out and fed them to the birds. BTW, the birds loved them. I was so disappointed... but will not make that mistake again. Anthony, I think you can do better. I'm sure I will be back and we will see how it goes.
1. La Strada Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 182 reviews
Reviewed By 836thomasd
We enjoyed the pre fixe luncheon at La Strada for my birthday. My wife had the Pasta Fagioli soup (close to her grandmotherâs) & Fresh Snapper, I had the Caprese salad & Veal Sorrentino. We enjoyed the flavors & portions were so generous we took home the two cannolis. Nick our server was superb. Highly recommend.
Where to eat Contemporary food in Succasunna: The Best Restaurants and Bars
