Location: Andover
Top Restaurants in Andover
Top 10 Italian food in Andover, New Jersey, United States
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Andover. Andover is a borough in Sussex County, New Jersey, United States. As of the 2010 United States Census, the borough's population was 606, reflecting a decline of 52 (-7.9%) from the 658 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn declined by 42 (-6.0%) from the 700 counted in the 1990 Census.
Things to do in Andover
10. A G Pizza & Restaurant
Reviewed By Omato9
Love their buffalo chicken pizza and their hot wings. We always do takeout so can't say about the restaurant itself.
9. Newton Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 18 reviews
Reviewed By Jean L
Newton Pizza has seen some hard times in recent years. It went through a phase where the food was tasteless. We stopped getting pizza here, opting to drive across town instead. We were sorry about this, since Newton Pizza is right in our neighborhood. However, it seems to be coming back. I decided to stop here for take-out after a long day, and was pleased that my favorite dish--eggplant parm with ziti--was delicious. Service seems a bit slow, but I also saw that they are advertising for help. I hope this neighborhood place hangs in there and continues its upward trend.
8. Terranova Pizzeriatrattoria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By DocRKS
Terranova has never failed to deliver both truly excellent meals and outstanding Pizza . Whether ordering 'to go' or dining in this lovely BYOB Trattoria- Pietro and Fran have crafted a very dependable and very delicious stop for a wide variety of excellent Italian meals as well as that wonderful pizza! Terranova has earned our continuing support and I believe you will be very pleased you stopped at their excellent Trattoria in the Panther Valley Mall just off Exit 19 on I-80.
7. Carmine's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 90 reviews
Reviewed By jimr20162016
If youâre looking for a location with an extensive menu, this is the place. The food is really good and this time we had the âspecial pizzaâ. Our friends suggested ordering the pizza well done as their experience has been pizzas with lots of topping tend to have soggy dough inter all the filling. Their suggestion was right on and the pizza was delicious with a very nice crust. Weâll visit again.
6. The Windlass
Overall Ratings
4 based on 276 reviews
The Windlass is a new and true lake experience. Brand new facility sporting a state of the art kitchen, unique antique boat bar, sunny dining room and ample outdoor dining. Our friendly waitstaff professionally delivers some of the finest prepared meals m
Reviewed By Jim B
Waterfront restaurant on the East Shore of Lake Hopatcong, NJ. I haven't been there in years and we used to love to go there for the best Italian food anywhere around the lake. Open 12 months you could always look forward to the ambiance, good service and good food. Now after my many years of absence there has been a complete renovation and reconstruction with everything kind of low end on the inside atmosphere and the food just OK. The prices are definitely tourist oriented for medium quality food. If you don't mind they had a waiting line for outdoor diningwhich was very noisy but lakeside non the less and how many times a year can you say you sat outside by a beautiful lake and had an OK meal with great company. I am hot high on going back but I would if the weather was nice and I wanted the lakeside atmosphere.We are one if many lakeside restaurants. There are options if that is the primary goal. However, we believe we offer the best food in the most thoughtful atmosphere for our neighbors and visitors. Thank you for your feedback.
5. Cesco's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 55 reviews
Reviewed By 50StateVisitor
We enjoyed our Saturday dinner with friends here in Fredon Township. Cesco's offers all of the traditional Italian favorites on their menu, plus all of the pizzeria options. There was some noise from Route 94 where we were seated in their enclosed gazebo. My personal pizza was a little overdone. My spouse's Chicken Saltimbocca special with white wine sauce was good but a little salty; it was accompanied by very good mashed potatoes. I found their dessert Tiramisu a little soft. The young servers provided attentive service even though the gazebo dining room was full. The main building is a busy place that is small inside; reservations are recommended.
4. Pezzo Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 29 reviews
9730-300-0197
Reviewed By Joanna332
The food here is not consistent. You may get a good pizza or just OK. It depends who is making it. We have tried on several occasions to give this restaurant the benefit of the doubt. We have our doubts.
3. Dominick's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 131 reviews
Reviewed By adriana0420
This is our favorite place for authentic Italian cuisine. My boyfriend and I come here a few times a month, and we always have excellent service and get treated like weâre family. We love just about everything here. Of course, their pizza is amazing, but our other favorites include: baked ziti, chicken Parmesan, and the âmake your ownâ pasta dishes. I have created my own pasta dish that they always make just right: angel hair pasta with fresh diced tomatoes and a garlic/butter sauce. For dessert, I absolutely love the limoncello flute (which is not on the menuâso youâll have to ask for it) which is nice and light. Also, Dominickâs is a BYOB, so donât forget to bring your favorite bottle. Kudos to the amazing service from Meagan tonight, she was a rockstar and was there any time we needed anything. We will be back again and again!!!
2. Bella Italia Pizzeria & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 58 reviews
Reviewed By Jean L
We live right up the road from this restaurant, and finally we tried it. We have a lovely early dinner here. Good food; if you want a smaller portion you can order from the lunch section of the menu--larger portions, order from the dinner menu. Nice atmosphere and friendly service.
1. Casa Bellisima
Overall Ratings
4 based on 143 reviews
Reviewed By Bcreagh
Listen. Pay attention. This place is everything you want from a fine dining Italian restaurant.Cozy elegant atmosphere... checkWhite table cloth..... check Great service...... check Extensive wine list..... checkHot and fresh delicious food..... checkHot bread and bruschetta complimentary......checkEverything was tasty ckn parm,mussels, rigatoni bolognese !!!!!Awesome place, you'd be a fool not try it, a must if in the area.
