The 10 best hotels in Mattoon, United States

July 2, 2022 Carley Gatson

Discover the best hotels in Mattoon, Illinois including Super 8 by Wyndham Mattoon, Holiday Inn Express & Suites Mattoon, an IHG Hotel, Comfort Suites Mattoon, Suite Dreams Hotel, Quality Inn & Suites, Holiday Inn Express & Suites Mattoon, an IHG Hotel, Motel 6 Mattoon, Hampton Inn Mattoon, Baymont by Wyndham Mattoon, Hilton Garden Inn Mattoon.
Things to do in Mattoon

1. Super 8 by Wyndham Mattoon

205 McFall Rd, Mattoon, IL 61938-6211
Excellent
33%
Good
31%
Satisfactory
17%
Poor
8%
Terrible
11%
Overall Ratings

3.5 based on 312 reviews

Super 8 by Wyndham Mattoon

All new renovated rooms, flat screen TV's, and free access to the local YMCA with hotel stay

Great option

Reviewed By 834940

The hotel I normally look to book was full so I ended up here. Clean property, friendly staff, plenty of parking and the internet service was solid. It is close to stores and restaurants and fits all of the needs I had. I will be returning to this one in the future.

2. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Mattoon, an IHG Hotel

121 Swords Drive, Mattoon, IL 61938
Excellent
58%
Good
25%
Satisfactory
9%
Poor
5%
Terrible
3%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 170 reviews

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Mattoon, an IHG Hotel

The premier hotel in Mattoon, Illinois! Welcome to the Holiday Inn Express Hotel and Suites in Mattoon near Lake Land College and Eastern Illinois University. Our Mattoon, IL hotel is the perfect choice for both corporate & leisure travelers. Families looking for lodging in Mattoon, Illinois will not be disappointed by our hotel, located just off I-57 between Effingham & Champaign. We offer you proximity to many local attractions including the Lincoln Log Cabin State Historic Site, Fox Ridge State Park, and the Douglas-Hart Nature Center. Other nearby activities include Lake Mattoon, Lake Shelbyville (11,000 Acres of Water), Rockome Gardens, and shopping at the Tanger Outlet Mall. Business travelers will be impressed by the convenience of our Mattoon, IL accommodations. Situated in a suburban area of Mattoon, Illinois, the hotel is close to several companies including Hydro Incorporated, Mediacom, Bimbo Bakeries, Rural King, Sarah Bush Lincoln Medical Center, and the Mattoon Softball C

Nice newer hotel with some minor problems.

Reviewed By Karl B

We checked in on November 11th 2021. Our first problem was immediately after being assigned a room and given our key card we went to the room only to find that neither of the 2 key cards worked. We had to return to the front desk to have them programed. Once inside the room I found that the note pad had the first 2 pages full of pictures. Then my wife said that in the bathroom we only had 1 washcloth and 1 bath towel. She tried to use the phone on the night stand in the room to call the front desk but found it did not work. She then tried the phone on the desk/eating table and it worked. She called the desk and informed them, the clerk immediately brought another wash cloth, bath towel and hand towel. When we were turning in for the night I turned on the light on the end table between the 2 queen beds and immediately seen the top of the table had not been cleaned, it had three rings from cups/glasses and something smirked on the top of the table. I got a couple of wet tissues and cleaned the table top. After we showered In the morning my wife was looking for the ice bucket to get some ic. She could not find any thing to put ice in. When we went to breakfast we were pleasantly surprised to find a hot breakfast with scrambled eggs and 2 different types of sausages, sausage gravy, hot cinnamon, hot pancakes. They also had a lot of cold muffins and bread. For drinks coffee, milk and a juice machine with a sign on the orange juice out of order the apple juice and lemonade were both working fine. I asked one of the employees if they had any biscuits to go along with the sausage gravy. I was informed they have been out of biscuits for 3 or 4 days. I will say that the eggs, sausage, gravy and warm cinnamon rolls were all very good. When we checked out I asked if they normally have ice buckets in the rooms cause ours did not have one. I was informed that several of the rooms did not have them because the guests keep stealing them. All the employees were very nice that we had contact with. The hotel is a newer one and in good condition. They have adequate parking.

3. Comfort Suites Mattoon

1408 Broadway Ave E, Mattoon, IL 61938-4636
Excellent
64%
Good
19%
Satisfactory
11%
Poor
1%
Terrible
6%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 113 reviews

Comfort Suites Mattoon

We know that you and your guests will find the comfort you are looking for at the newly remodeled Comfort Suites Mattoon. The hotel's lobby as well as guest suites is designed to be sophisticated and welcoming, incorporating natural stone, rich wood tones and warm colors. Whether its business, adventure, or relaxation that brings you to Coles County the Comfort Suites Mattoon has you covered.The Comfort Suites Mattoon is conveniently located off of Exit 190B from I-57. Our all-suite hotel is located in the heart of the Mattoon business district and is within walking distance to several restaurants as well as shopping centers. Only minutes away from area attraction including Eastern Illinois University, Lake Land Collage, Lincoln Log Cabin, and Tanger Outlet Center. Enjoy the great outdoors with a walk through Douglas Hart Nature Center or Rockome Gardens, the stepping stone to Illinois Amish Country. The area's best fishing and boating can be found at Lake Mattoon or a short drive over to Lake Shelbyville. Our contemporary design and Hometown Hospitality feel welcomes all types of travelers. Both vacationers and business travelers will appreciate the extras we've added including triple sheeted bedding, flat panel HD televisions, queen sized sleeper sofas, microwaves and refrigerators in all guest suites. If business brings you to Mattoon, IL, we've added features designed to keep you productive on the road including complimentary high-speed Internet that ensures you're always connected with the home and office, an oversized desk accompanied by an ergonomic office chair and Your Suites Success Re-Charge Device.

A Few Issues

Reviewed By WDMTraveler

We stayed at this hotel one night while visiting family in Mattoon. The front desk personnel were very friendly and our room was very clean. I reserved a handicap accessible room however the room we were assigned was not totally handicap accessible. There were grab bars beside the toilet, however there was a bathtub with grab bars, not a roll-in shower. The tub was too high for me to step into so I was not able to take a shower. Also the bathroom only had a sink and lacked any counter space to set personal items on. I realize a person in a wheel chair would need to roll up to the sink, however it would be nice to have a counter of some kind beside the sink, not just a tray on the wall. We also had considerable difficulty with the TV remote. It was hard to change channels and adjust the volume. The bed was ok - just could have been a little firmer. In addition, the walls were very thin - we could hear the TV and voices next to us. The breakfast was the standard breakfast fare. The scrambled eggs were kind of chunky however everything else was satisfactory. Our great granddaughter was extremely disappointed the pool was closed. We would stay in this hotel again, however in the future I will be more specific on my handicap accessible needs.

4. Suite Dreams Hotel

300 Broadway Ave E, Mattoon, IL 61938-4602
Excellent
44%
Good
21%
Satisfactory
14%
Poor
5%
Terrible
16%
Overall Ratings

3.5 based on 43 reviews

Suite Dreams Hotel

Families traveling will not be disappointed by our Suite Dreams Hotel with the largest indoor heated pool in the Mattoon area. Located just one mile off I-57 we offer you close proximity to many attractions, including Shelbyville Lake, Douglas-Hart Nature Center, and Little Theater on the Square in Sullivan, Illinois.

Clean rooms but needs updated

Reviewed By Pam S

Stayed here for 3 nights. The rooms were clean but very outdated. They were very friendly. The pool is completed closed and the only thing for breakfast was waffles and cereal. We had our baseball team here and wished they could have used the pool.

5. Quality Inn & Suites

4922 Paradise Rd, Mattoon, IL 61938-8925
Excellent
65%
Good
20%
Satisfactory
7%
Poor
4%
Terrible
3%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 216 reviews

Quality Inn & Suites

Quality Inn & Suites Conference Center is a 2 time award winning hotel (Gold & Platinum)Conveniently located right off I57. We are a host hotel for Lake Land College and EIU. Our award winning staff take pride in this hotel as well as all our guests! We look forward to seeing you during all your travels!

Fine for one night stay while on a driving trip

Reviewed By Explorer06543302635

This was our 4th choice hotel in Mattoon. It was a Saturday night in March. The other hotels were all booked. We paid $107 plus taxes. We arrived at night and the signage and hotel property were very dimly lit. It appeared kind of sketchy. There were only a few cars in the parking lot. Our room was actually pretty good compared to our first impression of the hotel. The bed was very comfortable and it all seemed clean. The heater was noisy but we did get a good nights sleep. The breakfast was very minimal and disappointing. All that was offered was bottled water and apple juice boxes, granola bars, packaged sweet roll and some kind of packaged breakfast sandwich. This hotel was fine for a one night stay while on the road.

6. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Mattoon, an IHG Hotel

121 Swords Drive, Mattoon, IL 61938
Excellent
58%
Good
25%
Satisfactory
9%
Poor
5%
Terrible
3%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 170 reviews

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Mattoon, an IHG Hotel

The premier hotel in Mattoon, Illinois! Welcome to the Holiday Inn Express Hotel and Suites in Mattoon near Lake Land College and Eastern Illinois University. Our Mattoon, IL hotel is the perfect choice for both corporate & leisure travelers. Families looking for lodging in Mattoon, Illinois will not be disappointed by our hotel, located just off I-57 between Effingham & Champaign. We offer you proximity to many local attractions including the Lincoln Log Cabin State Historic Site, Fox Ridge State Park, and the Douglas-Hart Nature Center. Other nearby activities include Lake Mattoon, Lake Shelbyville (11,000 Acres of Water), Rockome Gardens, and shopping at the Tanger Outlet Mall. Business travelers will be impressed by the convenience of our Mattoon, IL accommodations. Situated in a suburban area of Mattoon, Illinois, the hotel is close to several companies including Hydro Incorporated, Mediacom, Bimbo Bakeries, Rural King, Sarah Bush Lincoln Medical Center, and the Mattoon Softball C

Nice newer hotel with some minor problems.

Reviewed By Karl B

We checked in on November 11th 2021. Our first problem was immediately after being assigned a room and given our key card we went to the room only to find that neither of the 2 key cards worked. We had to return to the front desk to have them programed. Once inside the room I found that the note pad had the first 2 pages full of pictures. Then my wife said that in the bathroom we only had 1 washcloth and 1 bath towel. She tried to use the phone on the night stand in the room to call the front desk but found it did not work. She then tried the phone on the desk/eating table and it worked. She called the desk and informed them, the clerk immediately brought another wash cloth, bath towel and hand towel. When we were turning in for the night I turned on the light on the end table between the 2 queen beds and immediately seen the top of the table had not been cleaned, it had three rings from cups/glasses and something smirked on the top of the table. I got a couple of wet tissues and cleaned the table top. After we showered In the morning my wife was looking for the ice bucket to get some ic. She could not find any thing to put ice in. When we went to breakfast we were pleasantly surprised to find a hot breakfast with scrambled eggs and 2 different types of sausages, sausage gravy, hot cinnamon, hot pancakes. They also had a lot of cold muffins and bread. For drinks coffee, milk and a juice machine with a sign on the orange juice out of order the apple juice and lemonade were both working fine. I asked one of the employees if they had any biscuits to go along with the sausage gravy. I was informed they have been out of biscuits for 3 or 4 days. I will say that the eggs, sausage, gravy and warm cinnamon rolls were all very good. When we checked out I asked if they normally have ice buckets in the rooms cause ours did not have one. I was informed that several of the rooms did not have them because the guests keep stealing them. All the employees were very nice that we had contact with. The hotel is a newer one and in good condition. They have adequate parking.

7. Motel 6 Mattoon

4200 Lake Land Blvd I-57 exit 184 north on US-45 / Lake Land Boulevard, Mattoon, IL 61938-9028
Excellent
46%
Good
15%
Satisfactory
23%
Poor
15%
Terrible
0%
Overall Ratings

4 based on 13 reviews

Motel 6 Mattoon

My Honest Opinion

Reviewed By RSB519

I found this motel on Hotels.com and chose it based on location and price. The previous night I stayed at a Motel 6 and it was great. This one was not. My 1st room had a huge cricket on the curtains and I noticed animal hairs on the sheets. I called the front desk and they switched rooms. They said sometimes the crickets just jump in when the door opens. Room 2 appeared cleaner, bug-free, and the sheets were very clean and smelled good. In the morning I did find 2 crickets and a spider came out of the shower faucet. I can tell they did some recent remodels. It was fine for one night, but I would not stay there again.

8. Hampton Inn Mattoon

1416 Broadway Avenue East, Mattoon, IL 61938 1 (855) 605-0317
Excellent
52%
Good
28%
Satisfactory
9%
Poor
5%
Terrible
6%
Overall Ratings

4 based on 456 reviews

Hampton Inn Mattoon

The Hampton Inn Mattoon hotel is located on the northeast side of Mattoon, Illinois at I-57. The Tuscola Outlet Mall is nearby and we are 1.6 miles from Coles County Airport. Lakeland College is 5 miles south of our hotel. Dining options around Mattoon, Illinois include: Cody's Steak House, Stadium Grill, Alamo Steakhouse, Hunan Restaurant or Cracker Barrel, all within 2.5 miles of the Hampton Inn Mattoon hotel. The Hampton Inn Mattoon hotel features 3 stories and 61 rooms. The hotel offers king specials with microwave and mini-fridge units, same day dry cleaning and indoor pool. Amenities at our hotel include complimentary continental breakfast and TV with cable. We also offer connecting rooms, and cribs. Laundry/valet services are available for a nominal fee. We love having you here at the Hampton Inn Mattoon hotel in Illinois.

Standard Hampton Inn near the expressway

Reviewed By 795davec

Standard hotel off I-57. A little challenging to get to with the road configuration. Comfortable and quiet, like most Hampton Inns. Needs some upgrading. Good sized rooms. Friendly staff. Good for an overnight stay.

9. Baymont by Wyndham Mattoon

206 McFall Rd, Mattoon, IL 61938-6210
Excellent
41%
Good
33%
Satisfactory
14%
Poor
5%
Terrible
7%
Overall Ratings

4 based on 486 reviews

Baymont by Wyndham Mattoon

The Baymont Inn & Suites in Mattoon, Illinois is pleased to provide our guests with exceptional service and quality amenities at an affordable price. Whether you are here for business or leisure you can enjoy your heated swimming pool and hot tub, free wireless internet in every room, free HBO and cable, and much more. After a restful night of sleep, you can look forward to starting your day with a Complimentary Enhanced Breakfast.

Visit with family

Reviewed By kastbrown

Had a 2 night reservation only to get to hotel and it is not in business. Totally shut down for renovation. Got emails saying looking forward to your stay, being charged for my stay, etc. But, hotel doesn't exist, called number, out of order doesn't work. Not happy.

10. Hilton Garden Inn Mattoon

100 Coles Centre Parkway, Mattoon, IL 61938

We’re off Interstate 57 between Mattoon and Charleston. Reach Eastern Illinois University, historic downtown Mattoon, and Sarah Bush Lincoln Health Center in about 10 minutes. Our hotel is also within 40 minutes of several lakes, state parks, and natural areas. Enjoy our indoor heated pool, 24-hour fitness center, restaurant, and 8,400 sq. ft. of event space.

ThingsTodoPost © 2018 - 2024 All rights reserved.