Top Restaurants in Cat Island
Out Islands, Caribbean Food Guide: 8 Seafood food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Cat Island
Discover Restaurants offering the best Seafood food in Cat Island, Out Islands, Caribbean. Cat Island is simply ameowzing. Really, all puns aside. Legend has it that magical creatures inhabit the underground caverns of Mermaid Hole, and the ruins of Deveaux Mansion and Armbrister Plantation are breathtaking. A hike up to the Hermitage stone monastery on Mount Alvernia, the highest point in the Bahamas, will reward you with panoramic views. A guided tour of the island’s diverse creek systems is a must for nature lovers.
Things to do in Cat Island
8. Sammy T's Restaurant & Bar
7. Fountain Bay Beach Front Dining
Reviewed By 14Global
This is a new resort that opened seven months ago. We did not stay here during our vacation but we ate, drank, and used their beach a lot during our month on Cat Island. The owner is hands on and his whole family are part of the operation. They make the best mango Piña coladas I have ever had. They use real mango not a mix! For food we shared the spicy Island wings, coconut shrimp, Caesar salad, and the rib-eye steak. So far this is one of our favorite spots on Cat.? We still have two more weeks here and plan on trying more menu items. We are bringing our family here the night they arrive for dinner. As far as the facility & beach, they are gorgeous. The club house where the restaurant is located has a large full service bar, flat screen tvâs, inside + outside ocean front dining, and they serve all three meals. Fountain Bay is kept immaculate from the bathrooms to the beach. They even let us use their skim boards, and stand up paddle boards if resort guests arenât using them. This place is a gem!!
6. Starlite Restaurant and Bar
Reviewed By Rocks_road
This is a small restaurant that is very popular with Cat Islanders up and down the island. We have seen the police stopped here for lunch several times. There are several tables inside, a bar, and a nice little beach and cove right outside. Get here early because they can run out. You might even call ahead to find out if they have what you're looking for. We ate here twice and saw quite a few people come in to get take out. Our first trip we had the conch fritter 'snack.' That's conch fritters with french fries. There was plenty and it was GOOD. The second time we had a lobster wrap and a chicken wrap. These things were big and GOOD. This food probably falls in the category of fast food, but every order is cooked to order so it's not really 'fast.' The prices are very reasonable which I think has something to do with how busy they are.
5. Mary's Crab Shack
Overall Ratings
4 based on 12 reviews
Reviewed By island1man
Go for the chicken wings or fried lobster. Fish is excellent but make sure the fish is grouper. You have to see the crab box. Three hundred crabs in box live next to kitchen. Very friendly place. About 45 min to get food. No problem just drink beer and get a education in Bahama world
4. Mermaid's Restaurant at The Ocean Dream Beach Resort
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
Reviewed By Scooby0529
The woman running the restaurant was very friendly and sweet. The food was delicious! The view was beautiful. Delighted that you enjoyed the meal, the amazing view and our outstanding service. Please visit our oceanfront restaurant again, whenever you are in Cat Island.
What to do and see in Cat Island, Bahamas: The Best Places and Tips
3. Hidden Treasures
Overall Ratings
5 based on 36 reviews
Reviewed By TTexasTom
Located in the Fish Fry at New Bight, this is one of the best places to relax, enjoy good conversation and some great food. Denise whipped up lobster 2 ways with some of the sweet potato fries. Absolutely delicious. And as Denise will tell you, it is always cooked with love!!
Cat Island Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Cat Island
2. Yardie's Restaurant, Bar and Conch Stand
Overall Ratings
4 based on 115 reviews
Reviewed By 298TimC
Odette and Derrick run the coolest place on Cat Island!Great food, cold beer, rental cars, taxi, boats.....you want it they got it!!!!Plus they are a lot of fun....enjoy the island magic!!!!!
1. Da Smoke Pot
Overall Ratings
4 based on 206 reviews
Reviewed By 166douga
Da Smoke Pot is fine. The food is decent, the atmosphere is good and the music is fun. But this place is not worthy of near legendary status. The meal was no better than anything else I've had on the island. The atmosphere is laid back and quirky, but the entire island has those characteristics. For my money, I prefer other places. Go to Hidden Treasures, better food, right on the water, and Cat Island quirky/charming. Da Smoke Pot is fine and if you're on the island for any period of time it's certainly a consideration, but you can do better.
Where to eat Caribbean food in Cat Island: The Best Restaurants and Bars
