Location: Worthington
Top Restaurants in Worthington
Ohio, United States Food Guide: 10 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Worthington
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Worthington, Ohio, United States. Worthington is an affluent city in Franklin County, Ohio, United States, and is a northern suburb of the larger Columbus. The population was 13,575 at the 2010 census. The city was founded in 1803 by the Scioto Company led by James Kilbourne, who was later elected to the United States House of Representatives, and named in honor of Thomas Worthington, who later became governor of Ohio.
Things to do in Worthington
10. Pasqualone's Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 77 reviews
upscale fine dining Italian. Destination location. reservations highly recommended. Enjoy high quality, freshly prepared Italian food by Chef and owner David Pasqualone.
Reviewed By TheWorldTraveler47
Looked online for a good Italian restaurant in Columbus area. After reading the reviews, I picked Pasqualone's. The service was very good and the food was very good as well. I thought the customer service actually was better than the food, if that is possible. The owner/cook met us at the door. My wife and I could actually hear him in the back pounding out the veal. If you have never been here, I would suggest you give it a try. Their red sauce is amazing. I got the veal. It was excellent. The peach sorbet rocks!
9. Borgata Pizza Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 104 reviews
New York Style Pizza, Pasta, Sandwiches and Salads. We also serve Beer and Wine. Hours are 4:00pm to 11:00 pm Monday through Thursday. 11:30 am to Midnight Friday and Saturday.
Reviewed By chasg_12
Where have I been! Doing the normal Saturday errands and needing a bite to eat we came across this wonderful pizza place. Great atmosphere and seating, and the clean and orderly open kitchen with ovens was a nice touch. We had the mozzarella and tomato salad along with a 16" pie that definitely was reminiscent of my NY origins. Delicious! Can't wait to return.
8. Pizza House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 66 reviews
Reviewed By NoneColumbus
This is a rave review and this place deserves it.We have been eating at the Pizza House a time or two a month for more than 25 years, including at a prior location that they moved from many years ago. It is hard to say too much good about them. Their pizzas are always heaping high with deliciously fresh toppings and lots of cheese. They have little staff turnover, so the wait staff knows us when we come in. The service is always super friendly. We have never once, in all that 25 years plus, had a single bad experience there and on one would ever call me an easy judge of restaurants. Take my word for it, this place is great. I cannot recommend it highly enough.
7. Amano's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 14 reviews
Reviewed By williammZ222ZR
A casual sports bar in the back of Worthington Square that serves outstanding bar food and pizza. Fabulous food with a friendly atmosphere for the entire family. A place to have fun plus great food. Wait staff is very friendly and attentive. Outstanding daily luncheon of pizza, salad, and soup buffet. Good value for the food.
6. Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 148 reviews
Worthington, OH is full of great attractions: The McConnell Arts Center, the historic Orange Johnson House, the Old Rectory, and everybody's favorite Italian restaurant, Buca di Beppo! As the top destination for delicious Italian pastas, entrees, and pizz
Reviewed By james6764
We decided to see what all the hype was about with this place. This was the worst Italian food I have ever had. Our server John was a mediocre server at best. Totally lacking in the social skills to be a server. I watched the bartender sit on a counter with his back to the tables so he could watch tv. Totally unethical and unprofessional. The lasagna we ordered was dried out and tasteless. The bread was edible but the olive oil tasted old. Unfortunately we should have skipped dessert. We ordered the Tiramisu, it was the worst I have ever had. It was not light and creamy like any Tiramisu is, if made correctly. This one was mushy and on the dry side. Then to top it all of it rained while we were eatting, which should have been no big deal, but when we walked out to the parking lot it was flooded in a big area where we had parked. The water was to the bottom of the doors of our car. 8 other customers witnessed this and had even commented about how ridiculous this was. My husband had to take his socks and shoes off and roll up his pant legs as best as possible to get to our car. So beware if you go while it rains, this could happen to you also. We will NEVER set foot back in this place again. james6764, we are concerned to hear this and would like to reach you. If you haven't already spoken with someone about your visit or since this review was posted, please visit bucadibeppo.com/frequently-asked-questions, and provide your contact information on our online guest review form and include the details of your experience. Upon receipt of your contact information, a member of our management team will contact you directly.
5. Piada Italian Street Food
Overall Ratings
4 based on 29 reviews
Reviewed By RobertWorldWanderer
We were there the final night of the summer menu with changes to be coming the very next day. The server talked us through the drill of what each item was. Some was standard italian fair, but with a twist. the food was very well prepared. My dining companion chose a past dish with a gigantic meat ball and I had what can only be described as an italian burrito, however, we were both very happy with our choices, and the food was delicious! I hope this restaurant comes to my area, I believe it would do well.
4. Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 148 reviews
Worthington, OH is full of great attractions: The McConnell Arts Center, the historic Orange Johnson House, the Old Rectory, and everybody's favorite Italian restaurant, Buca di Beppo! As the top destination for delicious Italian pastas, entrees, and pizz
Reviewed By james6764
We decided to see what all the hype was about with this place. This was the worst Italian food I have ever had. Our server John was a mediocre server at best. Totally lacking in the social skills to be a server. I watched the bartender sit on a counter with his back to the tables so he could watch tv. Totally unethical and unprofessional. The lasagna we ordered was dried out and tasteless. The bread was edible but the olive oil tasted old. Unfortunately we should have skipped dessert. We ordered the Tiramisu, it was the worst I have ever had. It was not light and creamy like any Tiramisu is, if made correctly. This one was mushy and on the dry side. Then to top it all of it rained while we were eatting, which should have been no big deal, but when we walked out to the parking lot it was flooded in a big area where we had parked. The water was to the bottom of the doors of our car. 8 other customers witnessed this and had even commented about how ridiculous this was. My husband had to take his socks and shoes off and roll up his pant legs as best as possible to get to our car. So beware if you go while it rains, this could happen to you also. We will NEVER set foot back in this place again. james6764, we are concerned to hear this and would like to reach you. If you haven't already spoken with someone about your visit or since this review was posted, please visit bucadibeppo.com/frequently-asked-questions, and provide your contact information on our online guest review form and include the details of your experience. Upon receipt of your contact information, a member of our management team will contact you directly.
3. Borgata Pizza Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By Marston M
Friendly staff. My brothers and I come here for pizza, but last visit I had a sandwich, which came with a side of pasta salad. I'm not usually a big pasta salad fan, but this stuff was really delicious. My brother seemed to regret that he didn't order it after he took a taste. I will definitely come here again.
2. Villa Nova Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 152 reviews
Reviewed By jayrandall24
This is one of our favorite places. Their lasagne is the best! Pizza is pretty awesome too! They always give good service as their wait staff is very good. I only give 4 out of 5 because the hostess is terrible. In my opinion a hostess should be friendly and somewhat interactive with the patrons, but the girl that was there the last few times has zero personality and does better at helping to clean off tables than greeting people. If you want people to have a good dining experience it starts with when they walk in the door. I still recommend it highly!
1. Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 148 reviews
Worthington, OH is full of great attractions: The McConnell Arts Center, the historic Orange Johnson House, the Old Rectory, and everybody's favorite Italian restaurant, Buca di Beppo! As the top destination for delicious Italian pastas, entrees, and pizz
Reviewed By james6764
We decided to see what all the hype was about with this place. This was the worst Italian food I have ever had. Our server John was a mediocre server at best. Totally lacking in the social skills to be a server. I watched the bartender sit on a counter with his back to the tables so he could watch tv. Totally unethical and unprofessional. The lasagna we ordered was dried out and tasteless. The bread was edible but the olive oil tasted old. Unfortunately we should have skipped dessert. We ordered the Tiramisu, it was the worst I have ever had. It was not light and creamy like any Tiramisu is, if made correctly. This one was mushy and on the dry side. Then to top it all of it rained while we were eatting, which should have been no big deal, but when we walked out to the parking lot it was flooded in a big area where we had parked. The water was to the bottom of the doors of our car. 8 other customers witnessed this and had even commented about how ridiculous this was. My husband had to take his socks and shoes off and roll up his pant legs as best as possible to get to our car. So beware if you go while it rains, this could happen to you also. We will NEVER set foot back in this place again. james6764, we are concerned to hear this and would like to reach you. If you haven't already spoken with someone about your visit or since this review was posted, please visit bucadibeppo.com/frequently-asked-questions, and provide your contact information on our online guest review form and include the details of your experience. Upon receipt of your contact information, a member of our management team will contact you directly.
