Location: Tallmadge
Top Restaurants in Tallmadge
Ohio, United States Food Guide: 10 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Tallmadge
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Tallmadge, Ohio, United States. Tallmadge /ˈtælmɪdʒ/ (often mispronounced /ˈtɔːlmɪdʒ/) is a city in Summit and Portage counties in Ohio, United States. It is a suburb of Akron and part of the Akron Metropolitan Statistical Area. The population was 17,537 at the 2010 census. Tallmadge was founded in 1807 and is the second-oldest city in Summit County, following Hudson, which was founded in 1799.
Things to do in Tallmadge
10. Gionino's Pizzeria
Reviewed By sue r
Love their pizza and rigatoni with meatballs! Good is always tasty, and the staff are always helpful and friendly. They work long hours to serve this community.
9. Pizzeria 1081 & Bakery
A From Scratch Italian kitchen! Akron's premiere pizza! Delivered hot and fresh. Our menu is made with only the best ingredients and value in mind. Once you try our delicious selection you will be a customer for life!
Reviewed By cnate330
Most strip mall pizza places are similar, and that's what I expected at Pizzaeria 1081. I was pleasantly surprised to find their pizza breaks that stereotype while still remaining "pizza". The crust is not thin, nor pan style, but somewhere in the middle. Garlic taste is very noticeable but complementary, not overpowering. Pastries looked amazing... and who would think to find them in pizza joint? Salads are also rather nice.I look forward to trying a large part of their menu. Prices are a little steep on some items, but they advertise the use of Boar's Head products (among others) which accounts for some of the price.
8. Leo's Italian Social
Overall Ratings
4 based on 17 reviews
Italian Social
Reviewed By Heathercoe
We just stopped in for a cocktail and a quick appetizer at the bar. The staff was very friendly and helpful. We had the pepperoni dip and it was very good. I canât give it 5 stars because we didnât have dinner, however there were many tables already filled at 4 pm. Looking forward to going back for dinner.Thank you for the review and great feedback. We hope to see you for dinner soon!Best,Leo HinesGM
7. Altieri's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 64 reviews
Home of Stow's First & Favorite Pizza for 50 years!! The Best Pizza, Chicken, Wings, Pasta, Subs and Salads! Carryout Only!!
Reviewed By 394larrya
If your looking for the best tasting pizza,then this is the place for you. Please don't forget to order the salad and get thier house dressing Because you will not regret it.
6. Olive Garden
Overall Ratings
3 based on 94 reviews
Reviewed By 3CTraveler
The menu is the same as every other Olive Garden. The food was good but nothing special. Our server was very pleasant and attentive. She handled a few special requests from our group perfectly and made the evening better than expected.
5. Dontino's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 71 reviews
Reviewed By MWK51
Located in Akron's North Hill, an area once known a strong Italian neighbourhood, this family owned restaurant sits on the corner of a busy street. It would be easy to drive by and not think about stopping unless you knew better. They have off street parking in the back. Although we have lived in the area for 35+ years, we had never been here. We went with friends who took their kids here and it is still a big favourite of all of them. We were there late on a Monday, two of our group had the spaghetti and meatball special (I think it was $8.95) which included a salad (lettuce, sliced beets and thinly sliced tomatoes - big helping of shredded cheese was extra) and bread. I had cheese ravioli with homemade sauce. Nothing to rave about, but it was certainly good enough for what I wanted that night. I asked for balsamic dressing (on the side) I received balsamic vinegar. I had been forewarned by the waitress that it was not a vinaigrette, but wasn't expecting that. Order one of their regular dressings! My husband enjoyed his chicken pomodoro. A half split of a weak Chianti was $7.50. It accompanied the ravioli just fine. I understand there are huge crowds for their fish fries during lent. Have no t been. I would probably return.
What to do and see in Tallmadge, United States: The Best Places and Tips
4. Romeo's Pizza
Romeo's offers a pizza menu with the best pizza you can find as well as subs, wings, salads, and more. The secret to Romeo's award-winning pizza is the sweet sauce which has quickly made Romeo's a favorite of people all over. Romeo's always has pizza spec
Reviewed By 587bend
As far as commercial pizza goes, they're the best. Sweetness to the sauce is their signature, so if you don't like that then this isn't for you. The sub options are really good too, try the lunch special and get the Godfather.
Tallmadge Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Tallmadge
3. Luigis Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 858 reviews
Reviewed By BikerEats
The people were very friendly but the Italian food was just average. Salads were just iceberg lettuce and cheese versus some healthy mixed greens and additional vegetables. The lasagna and sauce were average - nothing to rave about or say must come here. We did not like the meatballs but that could be just personal preference. They were a bit hard and dry. Perhaps this is better as a pizza place??
Where to eat Fast Food food in Tallmadge: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Danny Boy's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By Shana J
We went for a late lunch. The deep dish pizza had a thick outer crust but the middle was paper thin. I ordered a personal pan pizza with ricotta, sausage and mushrooms. I played the "find the sausage and mushroom" game as they were virtually non-existent. The pizza was supposed to be $6.99 with two toppings so I guess the third one was $4??? They were installing some type of window near the dining area and after about 15 minutes of hammering my husband finally asked them to stop until we finished our meal. I would not recommend this restaurant. The server seemed miserable, the food wasn't good and it was overpriced.
1. Gionino's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 35 reviews
Reviewed By JanineandJack
Gionino's never disappoints! Pizzas have ample ingredients and they don't skimp to save a few cents--they please the customer!! Chicken and jo-jo's are a hit too in our household. Tip--order the daily combo--Large pizza, 8 piece chicken, jo-jos and coleslaw (also very good) for a bundle price!!
