Location: Suffern
Top Restaurants in Suffern
New York, United States Food Guide: 10 Pizza food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Suffern
Best Pizza restaurants nearby. Discover the best Pizza food in Suffern. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Pizza restaurants near you.. Suffern is a village incorporated in 1796 in the town of Ramapo, Rockland County, New York, United States. As of the 2010 census, Suffern's population was 10,723.
Things to do in Suffern
10. Forgia Brick Oven Pizzeria
Forgia Brick Oven Pizzeria is Suffern's newest brick oven pizzeria serving you delicious authentic Italian cuisine in a casual setting. Family owned and operated, with over 40 years' experience crafting the perfect pizza using only the freshest ingredient
Reviewed By AndreaR0609
We recently had pizza and chicken Parmesan at this restaurant. It was extremely mediocre. The pizza crust lacked flavor and my spinach topping looked like it wasnât very fresh. The chicken Parmesan was a giant portion ofLackluster chicken covered with a very thin tomato sauce. A sad meal!
9. Domino's Pizza
Visit your Suffern Domino's Pizza today for a signature pizza or oven baked sandwich. We have coupons and specials on pizza delivery, pasta, buffalo wings, & more! Order online now!
Reviewed By JonathanMase
If Jonathan Mase from Suffern, NY knows good pizza (and he does), how can he possibly give Domino's four stars? Well, he's basing his review on the quality of the Suffern location compared to his experiences with the remainder of the Dominos' in the American restaurant chain and international franchise; he's sampled most of them. And also, he doesn't technically consider it pizza. Well, Domino's is poisonous garbage. You already knew that, and you really don't need to read this review. It's fast food.But sometimes, whether you're working late or too drunk to open your last box of pop tarts, Domino's has the poison you need. While a Domino's in New York is the same as one in Florida, I can tell you that the "pizza" from the Suffern location is consistently hot, comes quickly, and the drivers are very friendly. They're also open really late, and very few places in Ramapo are. If the food was edible, I'd give it five stars, but it's not and that's ok. Keep up the good work, Suffern Domino's team; you're doing better than your counterparts.Jonathan A. Mase from Suffern, NY knows good fast food pizza, and this is the best in Suffern, and probably the best in Ramapo and Rockland.http://www.JonathanMase.com/Check out Domino's at www.dominos.com
8. Pasquale Pizzeria & Restaurant
Reviewed By Christina R
I've been to all the pizza shops in Suffern and to most of them numerous times. I feel Pasquales ranks among the best when considering the food (not the atmopsphe). The pizza is excellent and reasonably priced and the dinner items are fresh and plentiful. Better yet is their spanish food (Pork, Beef or Chicken) offered with yellow rice, a small salad and warm bread. The various meats are always tender and delicious and it's a large portion at just $6.50. Don't miss the home made minestrone soup which is served with hot bread and simply delicious. Low key place with fast delivery, surprisingly good food and reasonable prices.
7. Mason Jar
Overall Ratings
3 based on 355 reviews
When you're looking for good food with family, a drink with friends, or even just a place to watch the game, come see what's cooking at the Mason Jar! We believe that variety is the spice of life so our menu is all about options. Choose from a crisp salad
Reviewed By dianep614
While the food is good, it's not worth tolerating the service. We were a table of ten, so I understand some difficulty, but not like this. We waited 15 minutes for a waitress who took our drink orders and was gone for another ten minutes. When she did return, she only brought half of the drinks, came back with all but one, then returned with the last. We waited another ten minutes before she came back to take our food orders. We specifically asked her if she wanted to know how the check was to be split before we started ordering. She did, and appeared to write that information down as she took orders. We waited about 15-20 minutes for our food, which is understandable with such a large party; however, only one or two entrees at a time appeared, and these were all served by different staff members. The food was good, although some had gotten cold as we waited for everyone to be served before we began to eat.After the meal, our waitress came to the table with one check. When we reminded her how the check was to be split, she began bringing one check to the table at a time, asking each person what they ordered before she went off to calculate the next check. The one-at-a-time routine began all over again as she took our checks. As usual with large parties, a gratuity of 20% had already been added to each check. I should have refused to pay it, but all I wanted was to leave.We wish you would have requested to speak to a manager.....The Mason Jar must apologize for the lackluster service....for whatever personal reasons our server had a melt down....One of our floor manager's helped out when she saw our server was not performing up to snuff...Next time you come in please ask to speak to me, Ira Kaplinâ¦..Again we know there was a problem, and hopefully it is now corrected....Thank you for your attention and letting us hear from you.
Most Popular Beer restaurants food in Suffern, New York, United States
6. Villaggio Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
Reviewed By coanders
After waiting for an hour and 15 minutes for a pizza to be delivered, it arrived and was cold. My wife called the store and we were met with zero accountability. No one would accept the responsibility as to why the pie was so late. Previous visits to here were good so we were confused as to why on this evening service and accountability were so bad.
5. Nonna's Pizza & Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 55 reviews
Reviewed By Russell L
Ordered delivery since we didnât feel like going out. They were right on time and large portions. The food was fine but nothing special. Still great if youâre looking for easy delivery while on the road
4. Kinchley's Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 313 reviews
Kinchley's Tavern located in Ramsey NJ offers Italian food & pizza in a casual, family setting. Come see why we were voted "Best Pizza in the Tri-State"
Reviewed By psudino
I've been going to Kinchley's Tavern for decades. If you are a connoisseur of thin crust pizza then this is the perfect place for you. The crust is almost like a crispy cracker with an awesome crunch. The toppings are always fresh, in particular, the pepperoni is outstanding. The service is Jersey so you better move in and out quickly and have your cash ready, especially on a weekend when the line is to the door.Also, if you plan to eat in on a weekend, get there early, it fills up fast.Order a pie per person since you will seriously eat one on your own!Finally, bring cash, no credit cards accepted.It's been a pleasure treating you to a wonderful experience for so many years. Our savory thin crust pizza will always be here for you to indulge in and satisfy all those pepperoni cravings. We've always recommended multiple pies so you can try many flavors and have lots of leftovers if you choose! We look forward to seeing you back our way soon.Until next time,The Kinchley's Kares Team
Where to eat Diner food in Suffern: The Best Restaurants and Bars
3. La Gondola
Overall Ratings
4 based on 111 reviews
Reviewed By Brian M
This place has the best pizza, hands down, anywhere outside of NYC. I also had a chicken and pasta dish that was out of this world good! Forgot the name, but it was chicken breast, mushrooms, roasted peppers over angel hair. Absolutely OFF THE HOOK!!! Fresh and hot!!! Go and give it a try, you won't regret it!
Where to eat Italian food in Suffern: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Roxanne's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 181 reviews
Thereâs always that one friendly spot you, your friends, and your family love to flock to for a warm, hearty meal and equally warm hospitality. We know this because weâve been that place for many Mahwah families for almost 15 years. Incorporating our own
Reviewed By 522lauraz
My husband took our extended family (9 of us) to Roxanneâs for my birthday dinner. They offer Family Style dining, so we ordered 2 bottles of wine, a few sodas, 2 Caesar salads, Vegetable Chips, Spaghetti and Meatballs, Sweet Italian Sausage with peppers and onions, Baked Ziti and Chicken Parmesan. We brought in a cake from a bakery. The food was excellent!! There was PLENTY, so we are looking forward to leftovers tonight. The service was excellent as well. We sat in the back room, which had tile floors. I will say that the floor was EXTREMELY SLIPPERY! It was like there was a coating on it. Iâm surprised no one fell, quite honestly. Other than that, the restaurant was great. This is a louder restaurant, so if you have a hard time hearing in loud places, this may not suit you.We valet parked our car. They Valet people were very nice.522lauraz, thank you for bringing the celebration -- it was our pleasure to host this special occasion for you and your family! We're so happy you guys all enjoyed the family-style food and our attentive service. Sorry if the floor was slippery for you. We have yet to receive any similar complaint, but we'll take your feedback in mind. If you ever need assistance, please don't hesitate to let us know. Hope we'll see you back our way soon!Until then,Roxanne's
1. Sonny & Tony's Pizza and Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 161 reviews
Reviewed By ExperiencedReviewers
Ordered a vege pizza here and it was delicious. From ordering on the phone down to the delivery person, the service was easy and friendly. Definitely recommend and would order again! Thank you!
